Froonp
Posts: 7995
Joined: 10/21/2003 From: Marseilles, France Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: brian brian so how does this rule work "plus 50% of the unit's cost (minimum of 2)" ? we play it that you must add at least 2 BP to the cost - so GARR and FTR2 cost 4 each, and cv planes 3 each. you could alternatively read that to mean you can't build 1 point units (carrier planes) ahead at all. In our list of questions to Harry, there is this one. ****************************************** Q347 13.6.5 When advance building units, the phrase "minimum of 2" is written with respect to the additional amount to advance build from next year's units. But below that when the rules talk about advance building two and three years ahead, the minimums are written with respect to the total cost. Which is it? Example : Does a GARR cost 3 or 4 to advance build one year? ****************************************** No answer from Harry yet, but out of 4 rule gurus that answered, 3 said "cost 4", and the 4th said the rule should be rewritten. So I guess that playing it that you must add at least 2 BP to the cost is a good guess. And this one too : ****************************************** Q348 13.6.5, 14.6 When advance building planes (playing with PiF and pilots), do you : a) calculate the cost to advance build the unit with a pilot, then subtract 2 for the pilot, or b) advance build the plane without the cost of the pilot considered (thus having an advance built plane cheaper than with a)? Example : Does a 5 cost FTR cost 6 (5 times 1.5 = 8 minus 2) or 5 (3 times 1.5 = 5) when advanced built. ****************************************** No answer from Harry yet, but out of 4 rule gurus that answered, 2 said one way and 2 the other way. There is also this one about advance building : ****************************************** Q009 13.6.5, 28. You build ahead (advance building) by TYPE (as opposed to gearing CLASS), for example both a FTR and a NAV are of the CLASS plane but they are each a different TYPE and hence can be advance built separately. Question : Is an INF DIV a different TYPE than an INF Corps / Army? That is, do you need to build all available DIV before you can advance build like corps and vice versa? ANS> No. INF Divs are a different type to INF. Date: 28/01/1998 ****************************************** And this one : ****************************************** Q281 13.6.5, 28. I wish to build an AA piece. There are none in my force pool. Question: a) I have to build all guns before I can advance build. i) and even then I’d have to draw randomly from all 4-build-point guns from the next year. b) I need only build all AA units before I can advance build (with the extra cost, of course). ANS> (b), see 28. for the different unit types (or classes). Date: 20/01/1998 ******************************************
|