John David
Posts: 373
Joined: 3/21/2002 From: Montreal, Quebec Status: offline
|
Drex, Yes there was allot of propaganda in Victory At Sea. There is allot of propaganda in almost ALL military documentaries. Take Battlefield for example. I loved it. It was one of the best series ever. Yet, it was done by the BBC. If you watch the North Africa campaign, the discussion on it was mostly after Montgomery became commander, and it almost totally ignores the German campaign with Rommel in 1941! Added to that, the part played by Patton and the 7th army is given only a perfunctory shrug of recognition, as is 7th army's role in the episodes of the Battle for Italy! I don't know if you saw the extra 2-hour part called Battlefield: The Battle of the Riehnland. This was narrated by and American, where as the other parts in the series was aptly done by an Englishman. The whole tone of that part was completely different in the way it stressed more of the American participation, then the other Allies. Obviously, that part was written and produced by a predominately American crew. Most of Battlefield, if you watch and listen carefully, had allot of British slant towards it. Sure, it wasn't as blatant as Victory At Sea, but then Victory was done just a few years after the war! Do I think either the British or American slant in the Battlefield series take away from their enjoyment and usefulness. Absolutely not! That series was outstanding! Just don't think that there was no propaganda in that!! Lastly, anyone interested in history or military accounts of wars, should never base their opinions solely on one series or one book. A person must have a well rounded exposure from all sorts of information to get a better understanding of the whole even, along with being able to judge an individual TV show or book in the greater context of their own knowledge. Again, I agree, of all the series on TV, Victory had more propaganda then most anything else, But as I stated here, taking it into context, it is still a valuable series that I would want people who have never seen it, to view it for what it was. Just my opinion:) John
_____________________________
The only thing good about war, is it's ending!
|