Joseignacio
Posts: 2449
Joined: 5/8/2009 From: Madrid, Spain Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: paulderynck quote:
ORIGINAL: Joseignacio Hello, if Vichy is created, there are no territories for Free France, but then the german collapses Vichy, the lands overseas from the former vichy belong to: - Vichy in exile - A new Free France? Login Joseignacio Free France is created in this case. From Question 17.2-4 in the latest issue of the FAQ: Q. Can a completely conquered Free France upon Vichification (17.2) be liberated by returning a French Minor Country? A. No, Free France has to be founded as per the Vichification rules. If and when Free France is created and then immediately conquered, it can be re-created only by Collapsing Vichy. You liberate France (which then replaces any existing Free France) by retaking Paris. Note that by RAW France will cooperate with its liberator and the U.S. (per "who can cooperate" in 18) so if the U.S. is the liberator (on the occasions when Free France is conquered) then France will not cooperate with the CW unless the CW has territory to return to it and does so. Jeez, it's not clear at all. Sorry for asking before checking the clarifications but it was 12 pm yesterday and we are supposed to play today too just after work, so there was no much time for that. It seems contradictory, no?: quote:
Q. Can a completely conquered Free France upon Vichification (17.2) be liberated by returning a French Minor Country? A. No, Free France has to be founded as per the Vichification rules. quote:
If and when Free France is created and then immediately conquered, it can be re-created only by Collapsing Vichy. Apart from rather contradictory, the only way the would fit together would be (IMO) if there is no Free France unless it was created when Vichificaton is made and could only come back if it is conquered and it would be re-created if Vichy is collapsed or Paris liberated. But in my case, although Vichy has been collapsed, it can not be re-created because it was never created. :( Am I wrong? quote:
Also, from RAW 17.4 : ********************************* Other home countries and territories aligned with Vichy France align with Free France (or become Free France with a new home country if it is currently completely conquered). However this would mean that if Vichy is collapsed the territories would become Free FRance, I am confused.
|