Posts: 520
Joined: 3/31/2005 From: Bellevue, NE Status: offline
Not that I don't love this one! Although the user interface is something akin to using a belt sander in lieu of toilet paper at times, this is one of my most favorite games of all time and I play it a lot. But I do need something else to do when waiting for turns
I like all kinds of wargames except for RTS types. I figured I'd ask in here first since most of us share the same interests as far as gaming is concerned I think. I am slowly reading through some AARs of Bombing the Reich and checking out War In The East although that doesn't look like it is coming out this year. I also own TOAW (another all time favorite of mine) and IL-2.
I am open to just about any kind of non-RTS, shoot-em up game (naval, sub, tactical, operational, strategic, whatever).
Posts: 3107
Joined: 2/22/2005 From: Secret Underground Lair Status: offline
Crown of Glory Emperor's Edition is a great game IMO. Also by the same guys (Western Citadel Software) is "Forge of Freedom." Both of those games have active boards here on the Matrix forums so you can read AARs, see screen shots, etc.
ADDIT: sorry didn't notice you said WWII.
TOAWIII is good! Lots of WWII scenarios in that one.
< Message edited by Anthropoid -- 11/22/2009 12:29:56 PM >
hrmm... turn based WWII... I imagine you've played Steel Panthers, if not it's free from matrix, another grisgby masterpiece, even the ancient WIR is fantastic, again free from matrix... how about some of the combat mission games? barbarossa to berlin say? excellent. I've been eyeing Warship Combat: Navies at War, a turn based tactical ship to ship combat game that I hear good things about from NWS. There's also John Tiller's stuff, I've played a couple of the panzer campaign series and liked them, hps sims. The Campaign series from tiller isn't bad, I own the originals, they've been updated here at matrix. If you can stretch to real time a bit then panther games airborne series, highway to the reich etc might interest you or possibly hearts of iron.
You can also get the "steamless" version of HOI2 Complete which includes the main game and two expansions from Gamersgate ( http://www.gamersgate.com/DDB-HOI2COMP/hearts-of-iron-2-complete-bundle ) for $25. Avoid HOI3 since it seems to be a "dumbed down" version of HOI2. This trend towards dumbing down concerns grognards like me and I fear that a soon-to-be-released war in the east title may also suffer from it, but I hope not. Matrix games is today's SSI among other things, and I thank them for letting us non-twitch gamers have fun too.
_____________________________
"It is generally inadvisable to eject directly over the area you just bombed.." -U.S. Air Force Manual
Posts: 520
Joined: 3/31/2005 From: Bellevue, NE Status: offline
Hi, thanks for the feedback guys. I have most Paradox titles already (All EU, All the HOI, CK, Victoria, etc). I also own Forge of Freedom and AACW. I also own 688(I) but I've lost the disks somewhere along the line
I haven't tried some of the free games like Steel Panthers, so I might mess around with those a bit. Is there anything like Forge of Freedom for WWII? Something with both a strategic and tactical component?
Posts: 223
Joined: 5/12/2001 From: Ft. Lewis Washington Status: offline
Silent Hunter IV. With the mods this is the best Pacific War simulation made.
I am also fond of Battle of Britain II: Wings of Victory by A2A simulations and sold here by Matrix Games. I don't have any qualms about recommending this product. I reviewed it a few years ago and loved it (like it's earlier cousin from Rowan) and the team updates the game better than any other simulation made-to include IL2.
_____________________________
Thomas S. Cofield Feature Editor, SimHQ.com t.co0field@comcast.net (stopped the SimHq mail since I get nothing but spam)
Depends on the level you want - the best company/battalion of WW2 as far as I am concerned are the 'airborne assault' series by Panther and carried by Matrix; one on the Market Garden campaign, another on Crete/Greece/Malta and one coming on the Bulge. You can also try all sorts of mod scenarios.
Posts: 3685
Joined: 8/24/2002 From: London UK Status: offline
quote:
ORIGINAL: SimHq Tom Cofield
Silent Hunter IV. With the mods this is the best Pacific War simulation made.
I am also fond of Battle of Britain II: Wings of Victory by A2A simulations and sold here by Matrix Games. I don't have any qualms about recommending this product. I reviewed it a few years ago and loved it (like it's earlier cousin from Rowan) and the team updates the game better than any other simulation made-to include IL2.
Silent hunter 5 is due out mext feb/mar and its back in the atlantic again ,, huzzah ! . I loved SH3 and will definately get SH5.
_____________________________
sorry for the spelling . English is my main language , I just can't type . and i'm too lazy to edit :)
I would second Advacned Squad Leader. It a great game, but like WITP, it is not for the those with a weak heart. It's almost impossible to find an opponent after they look at the 400 page rule book. But if you can get a game, its totally worth it.
If you like first person games, WWII Online (now Battleground Europe) is also a lot of fun. Its an online game but it is a true virtual battlefield. Believe me, its a totally different ball game from ARMA, Battlefied whatever, and the like.
Posts: 1822
Joined: 11/21/2005 From: Beijing, China - Paris, France Status: offline
quote:
ORIGINAL: Graymane I also own 688(I) but I've lost the disks somewhere along the line
If you liked 688(I), get Dangerous Waters. Its princing is ridiculous by now, and it's 688(I) a thousand times better by the same guys at Sonalysts (although now you can operate Seawolves, Akulas, Kilos, Perries, SH-60 & Orions too!) The multiplayer is a killah.
Posts: 520
Joined: 3/31/2005 From: Bellevue, NE Status: offline
Wow, lots of great suggestions. I'm going to be reading up on them all!
@hjalmar99 The Battles In Italy looks like a similar interface to TOAW, is it an operational level game?
@Fishbed, @SimHq Tom Cofield and Rob Brennan UK Thanks for the heads up! I've been looking for a better sub game for a long time. I'll have to check them out.
@Mr.Custer Jutland sounds interesting. Is that a tactical level ship sim?
@mariandavid Any level appeals to me really as long as the game is done well. I really do like everything squad-level to grand strategy as long as I can play it single-player, it is turn-based (or pausable like the Paradox game model), and it makes you work but have fun at the same time =)
Jutland has a campaign game and a tactical game.The Campaign game covers all of 1916.Every ship available to the Germans and British is available. It plays in real time, but can be speed up when required. If your into WW1 Naval warfare, I'd say its a must. Only downside, its a download only, and the campaign part of the game is sold separate. Would recommend getting both.
you really ought to check out the Airborne Assualt series from Panther games...........Highway to the Reich and Conquest of the Agean......they will have another hitting the shelves soon (Dec or Jan) Battles for the Bulge.
_____________________________
"Git thar fust with the most men" - Gen. Nathan Bedford Forrest
paradox just finish latest patch for HoI III, pretty good game but at first it was imcomplete... http://www.heartsofirongame.com/
Agreed HOI III is the best SP & MP grand strategy WWII game on the market. HOI III is as detailed as you like. Many different user settings can allow a new user to hop right in the game. 1.3 Patch was a major add-on. Paradox patches there games forever it seems always tweaking them to make them as good as they can be. It is variable speed & pausable RTS. The speed is as slow as you want. No rush like RTS "strategy games" :)
Tactical try WWI (soon to be WWII) JUTLAND. The best naval tactical game on the market IMHO.
_____________________________
My Top Matrix Games 1) CMO MP?? 2) WITP/AE 3) SOW 4) Combat Mission 5) Armor Brigade
If you liked 688(I), get Dangerous Waters. Its princing is ridiculous by now, and it's 688(I) a thousand times better by the same guys at Sonalysts (although now you can operate Seawolves, Akulas, Kilos, Perries, SH-60 & Orions too!) The multiplayer is a killah. [/quote]
Curious how is the MP games....how does it work. I'm a sub your the destroyer etc? Can you have MP teams on say the same platforms?
Thx
_____________________________
My Top Matrix Games 1) CMO MP?? 2) WITP/AE 3) SOW 4) Combat Mission 5) Armor Brigade
Posts: 520
Joined: 3/31/2005 From: Bellevue, NE Status: offline
I downloaded the demo of Dangerous Waters. Looks good and the interface is exactly the same as Jane's 688(I), so easy to learn for me. I also ordered Silent Hunter 4, I found a $3 version on amazon $3?? I also downloaded steel panthers. I wanted to try some of the other Matrix games but the ones I'm interested in don't seem to have any demos, so a lot of them are going to get a pass I think. I will look for AARs and stuff. The Panther games especially looked good.