Moondawggie
Posts: 403
Joined: 10/18/2003 From: Placer County CA Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Cap Mandrake ....Pescadores ******SWPAC HQ, Darwin, August 11, 1943, Operation Hot and Sour Plenary Planning Meeting****** Gen. Short: ...right, so it is decided then, 1st Marine and 3rd Marine with 2 coy of 193rd Armored go ashore at H-Hour, with Americal in reserve, what I don't understand is why we have to sail all the way around the south and east side of the island to land up here in the north. Why don't we just...<walks closer to map> go through here...the...<looks closely>..Strait of Formosa. why don't you just send your ships through there, Chips? Admiral Carpdender, 7th Fleet CO: Naval Treaty of 1925. Section XXII, second paragraph. <looks at notes> "whoever shall retain possession of the Pescadores Islands may, unless the right of passage has been explicitly granted in writing, compel the vessels of another nation to stop for one day upon reaching the Pescadores Islands. Gen. Short: Chips, I gotta tell you that seems really stupid. The Strait of Formosa has got to be 100 miles wide. I mean, what the Hell could they do about it? Admiral Carpdender, 7th Fleet CO: 111, but that is not the point. What if they lodge of treaty violation complaint with the League of Nations? Do you realize you could be personally responsible? And, now that we have discussed it, we could both be accused of conspiracy. Gen. Short: "Conspiracy", you mean like the attack on Pearl Harbor? Admiral Carpdender, 7th Fleet CO: Oh come on, Walt. Everybody knew that was coming. I guess they might have attacked Manila or Singapore but Pearl was the obvious choice. It was in the House Rules for Christ's sake. Gen. Short: Well, what about the Naval Treaty of 1925, then? Admiral Carpdender, 7th Fleet CO: House Rules override the Naval Treaty of 1925, everybody knows that. Gen. Short: Well, what say we just burn the minutes from todays meeting and we make a pact to keep quiet about it? Admiral Carpdender, 7th Fleet CO: You want to add obstruction of justice? Nope, I say we avoid the Formosa Strait. The day we lose sailing around the island we would have spent waiting at Pescadores. What if someone doesn't get the "Do Not Unload" order and they begin unloading at Pescadores? Can you imagine the cluster f***? No, thank you. It will look like we are heading to Okinawa or something as we head around the east side of the island. We can have the air boys bomb Okinawa just to rattle their cage......... Impressive, Mandrake, quite impressive...only a gifted theater commander can see the opportunity presented by stupid rules and use them to misdirect the enemy about your true intentions...
_____________________________
"The Yankees got all the smart ones, and look where it got them." General George Pickett, the night before Gettysburg
|