pasternakski
Posts: 6565
Joined: 6/29/2002 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Nikademus Jeremy Brett forever! Yah. A real princess of a guy, especially in a black party dress and three-inch heels. Brett was the best of the Holmes portrayers, I think. He had the benefit of writers who tried to stay close to "the canon" when crafting episodes. Too bad he couldn't have stayed healthy for awhile longer. Who did you like better as Watson, Burke or Hardwicke? Rathbone had the "look," but also the misfortune of working with lesser material not particularly well rooted in the original. Those WWII-based episodes take the whole Holmes thing out of its proper context. And the Nigel Bruce Watson? Please. The best moment of the Rathbone movies for me was his song-and-dance schtick in "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes." I did like this new movie, in the same way many have mentioned, as an entertaining, but not faithful, rendering. I suppose you've got to have action these days to draw an audience. Two problems: the villain (and, hence, the plot) was silly and uninteresting, and the Irene Adler paste-on job? Please.
_____________________________
Put my faith in the people And the people let me down. So, I turned the other way, And I carry on anyhow.
|