76mm
Posts: 4688
Joined: 5/2/2004 From: Washington, DC Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Senno I have been far, far, far to timid, as others have pointed out. This whole game I have been waiting for a Flavio counter/attacking type defense. I always though, "okay this turn he will spring it", and it just never happened. We see the AAR's, and the testers posts and people constantly say they can indeed counter-attack. And TD's excellent example of a crushing Soviet defense in his first AAR. And that was TD's first game. I think you've been playing a great game, particularly for your first game--bravo! But IMO you are correct that you have been too timid, or at least in the initial turns. As to the constant references to the necessity of, and possibility for, Soviet counterattacks--I just don't agree that many counter-attacks are possible, necessary, or even desirable. I'm in the middle of my first PBEM game, but in my opinion a good, aggressive German opponent will inflict enough casualties to make counterattacks difficult, and will threaten troops concentrating for counterattacks with encirclement enough to make counterattacks unwise. TD has played a couple of great games, but I also think that he has been fortunate in his selection of German opponents., who have been rather conservative. Just to be clear, I am talking about actual counterattacks, rather than slipping units into gaps to relieve pockets, etc. This is critical for Soviets to do, but this doesn't qualify as counterattacks in my book.
|