Considering buying ... need comparison!

Matrix Games Forums

Forums Register Login Photo Gallery Member List Search Calendars FAQ

My Profile Inbox Address Book My Subscription My Forums Log Out

Considering buying ... need comparison!

View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest

Users viewing this topic: none

Printable Version

All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [American Civil War] >> Gary Grigsby's War Between the States >> Considering buying ... need comparison!

Page: [1]

Message

<< Older Topic Newer Topic >>

Considering buying ... need comparison! - 4/22/2011 4:01:22 PM

WriterJWA

Posts: 73
Joined: 6/24/2009
From: Atlanta
Status: offline

Hi! I'm considering buying this game. I have AGEod's American Civil War, and though I enjoy it, I'm a BIG fan of Grigsby's games because of the level of detail he offers. How does his Civil War game compare to AGEod's Civil War game?

_____________________________

Jay
USMC '98-'06
0311-4341

"Amateurs study tactics, professionals study logistics."
- Gen. Omar Bradley

"A good plan violently executed now is better than a perfect plan executed next week. "
- Gen. George S. Patton

Post #: 1

RE: Considering buying ... need comparison! - 4/24/2011 5:53:43 AM

mikeCK

Posts: 565
Joined: 5/20/2008
Status: offline

Wow...well first, you can find 101 different threads comparing GGWBtS, AGEODS ACW and Forge of Freedom. In the end, one is not clearly better than the other so dont think I am telling you that. Now, having said that, i am an AGEOD fanboi for sure...I have 'em all. I will tell you that I find GGWBtS to have the better AI. AGEOD has more involvment and detail regarding organizing your forces...much more micro. More sub types of units and such. I think this makes it harder for the AI to properly organize forces. Also, although AGEOD has more territories, I think this can create a problem for the AI as well. In the end, I think AGEODS game has more detail and micromanagement but is more suited for PBEM.

I havent played GGWBtS in years but just fired it up after trouncing the AI in ACW. I prefer GG's map and I like the concept of theater commanders. Sometimes, its nice to worry about the big picture. With AGEODS ACW, I watch the big picture but Im also screwing around with independent divisions here and there. Put it this way, in GGWBtS, you are Grant post March 1864. In AGEODS game, you are every general from Grant on down.

So, basically, AGEODs ACW offers more detail but GG is certainly not lacking in that area....its just more macro. If you like strategic ACW play, you will like GGWBtS. I will tell you it is NOT as complex as Gary's other games like WiTP and WiTE. Thats a good thing.

(in reply to WriterJWA)

Post #: 2

RE: Considering buying ... need comparison! - 4/30/2011 4:59:03 PM

michael1776

Posts: 132
Joined: 2/3/2008
Status: offline

I have played both, and will say straight away that both are very enjoyable. I love the AGEOD map, it has a great look to it. What I often find frustrating with ACW, however, is that I sometimes find myself involved with serious micromanagement of troop movement to combat cavalry in my rear. I find that AGEOD's games focus upon troop movement, and praying that you don't lose too many units to desertion and disease between turns. It can be very annoying when playing out the larger campaigns.

Grigsby's WBTS takes a different approach to managing the war. I find that it really comes down to using leaders effectively. Concentrating on the right combination of leaders to manage your forces is key. Understanding the leader activation system for turns is imperative to making a solid effort of fighting the war. Having said that, there is some abstraction that you must come to understand in said system. Getting these mechanics down can make your first few efforts frustrating, but once you understand the engine it is very enjoyable. Although, you will find that there are times when a commander just won't activate -even though all the requirements for him to do so are met- and it subsequently completely spoils a well prepared attack. Nothing is more frustrating than knowing that you can deal the Confederacy a serious blow, only to find that some general just won't budge; rendering his troops useless for a turn. This is somewhat realistic, though, as all commanders during the Civil War have made complaints about this actually happening on one battlefield or another.

All in both are great games. You can't go wrong with GGWBTS.

MJ

(in reply to WriterJWA)

Post #: 3

RE: Considering buying ... need comparison! - 10/19/2011 3:44:00 AM

laramieela

Posts: 43
Joined: 10/17/2005
Status: offline

Jay, Did you buy WBtS? You post is old enough I kind of feel like I am too late to add anything new. I was worried that the game was 'so old.' I am in a perpetual search for the 'perfect' strategic level Civil War game. This one is very close to that goal. I would like some simplicity, however, the leader rules are prime, and the game functions so very well.
It is a joy.

(in reply to michael1776)

Post #: 4

RE: Considering buying ... need comparison! - 10/31/2011 12:57:24 AM

WriterJWA

Posts: 73
Joined: 6/24/2009
From: Atlanta
Status: offline

I have bought it and I like it... though I have a few questions about how things work in the game. I'm glad I bought it!!

_____________________________

(in reply to laramieela)

Post #: 5

RE: Considering buying ... need comparison! - 10/31/2011 2:29:01 AM

laramieela

Posts: 43
Joined: 10/17/2005
Status: offline

What questions do you have? I may not be the most expert player of this game, but others will chime in if I am not sure.

(in reply to WriterJWA)

Post #: 6

RE: Considering buying ... need comparison! - 10/31/2011 3:10:53 AM

WriterJWA

Posts: 73
Joined: 6/24/2009
From: Atlanta
Status: offline

I just put up a post for some of the stuff I was having problems with:

http://www.matrixgames.com/forums/tm.asp?m=2940434

_____________________________

(in reply to laramieela)

Post #: 7

Page: [1]

All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [American Civil War] >> Gary Grigsby's War Between the States >> Considering buying ... need comparison!

Page: [1]