Extraneous
Matrix Elite Guard

Posts: 1810
Joined: 6/14/2008 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: warspite1 quote:
ORIGINAL: Extraneous quote:
ORIGINAL: warspite1 Kiss my bottom Yamato - fancy comparing war histories? - How 'bout ships sunk or major battles contested? no? Strike 1 - well what about hitting enemy battleships from range? No? Strike 2 - Okay, well let's try taking one for the team (well over thirty actually + mines, bombs and glider bombs) and still surviving to fight another day? Strike 3 Victory to the Grand Old Lady me thinks To be fair and since Yamato was commissioned December 18, 1941 you would have to compare the ships form that date forward. How about damage taken in a single attack? Strike 1 Warspite What was the longest range hit by Warspite? October 25, 1944 Yamato hit an American ship with her first savo at 20 miles Largest scale model of the warship. Strike 2 Warspite warspite1 To be fair, when she was commissioned has nothing to do with it. A ships history is what it is in the time allotted to her so no, you do not have to accept comparison from that day forward. If you do then USS Enterprises' combat record was no better than that of USS (insert name of any aircraft carrier commissioned right at the end of the war). Lets face it Extraneous, whichever way you slice it, whatever calculations you use, whatever rules you apply, the answer is exactly the same: HMS Warspite is the bestest battleship ever. FACT. And I'm not even biased Movies and tv series for Yamato (October 6, 1974 to April 7, 2012). None for Warspite "Mirror, Mirror, on the Wall Who's the Baddest of Them All?" Just yankin your chain Japanese Warship Names (again) Yamato: A province, contains Nara and points south. Also, an ancient name for Japan. Musashi: A province, includes Tokyo.
_____________________________
University of Science Music and Culture (USMC) class of 71 and 72 ~ Extraneous (AKA Mziln)
|