traskott
Posts: 1546
Joined: 6/23/2008 From: Valladolid, Spain Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: ADB123 quote:
ORIGINAL: geofflambert Can you even hit an LCT with a torpedo? Wouldn't it just pass underneath? I'm seeing that they only had a draft of 3 to 4 feet, and I believe torpedoes were generally set to 6 feet or more. I don't know to what depths they could be reset to on the fly, however. LCTs were not very well armed so there would be no excuse (that I can think of) to not surface and shell. On the other hand, who sends out LCTs without an escort? I did some digging and totalling: In this particular Scenario 2 match it is January 22, 1943, and my opponent does have his problems with finding escorts for his TFs… here are the Allied ship losses, F.O.W. included, but I have seen many of these go down for good… DDs: USN – 19, Dutch – 4, British – 6, Australian – 2 DEs: Indian – 2 APDs: USN – 5 AMs: USN – 5, Dutch – 4, British – 4, Australian – 16 DMs: USN – 2 PCs: USN - 3 PGs: USN – 4, Dutch – 1, British – 1 KVs: Canada – 1, British – 2 Plus lots and lots and lots of MLs, AMcs, MTBs, PTs, HDMLs, YMS, CMs And there is the Big Stuff: CVL: British – 1 CVE: USN – 2 BBs: British 7, USN – 1 CAs: USN – 6, British – 3, Australian – 2 CLs: USN – 2, NZ – 2, Dutch – 4, British – 5, Australian – 3 CLAAs: USN – 1, Dutch – 1 Subs: USN – 22, Dutch – 4, British – 1 Misc stuff: AE: USN – 1, AVP: USN – 4, Dutch – 1, AMC: Indian – 1, British – 2, Australian – 1, AG: Dutch – 1, 4 AOs, 13 TKs, 19 xAPs, 7 APs, 92 xAKs/xAKLs, 3 AKs, 1 AKV In comparison, here are the Japanese losses: DDs: 2, APDs: 2, Subs: 11, SSX: 5, AMC: 2, DMS: 5, SC: 1, PB: 7, E: 3, TK: 2, xAK/xAKL: 12, xAP: 12 Sorry but I can't see heavy losses here. The only painful are the 16 aussie AMs, and the 19 DDs which is not a high number.. I have played as allied and suffered double losses of DDs and manage to keep all my convoys escorted.
|