tyrion22
Posts: 52
Joined: 5/9/2012 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: PDiFolco Melee targeting is broken imho, - attacker should not be able to target SMCs - attacker should be forced to divide attacks as much as possible, ie only be able to target a unit twice if it has already been targeted once... This and spotting rules are the 2 things which should be changed... If you don't like the spotting rules, why do you play the game? It's the heart of the game, and what seperates it from other squad level games. It's what makes this particular squad level board game work, even though you have perfect information. Sure, they could implement regular fog-of-war rules instead for the computer game, but squad level games that do that are a dime a dozen already, so why bother? Let this one be the one true implementation of a board game we have. :) As for the melee rules, I think they work fine as they are. If you bring a valuable hero, you take a risk. In real life you would have to divide your attacks, but letting the attacker choose is a reasonable abstraction, and makes the game more interesting and less fiddly, IMO.
|