Matrix Games Forums

Forums  Register  Login  Photo Gallery  Member List  Search  Calendars  FAQ 

My Profile  Inbox  Address Book  My Subscription  My Forums  Log Out

Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J) vs. Iroquois (A) <No Erkki>

 
View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
Users viewing this topic: none
  Printable Version
All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition >> After Action Reports >> Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J) vs. Iroquois (A) <No Erkki> Page: [1]
Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J) vs.... - 4/12/2014 3:05:48 AM   
cdoarm

 

Posts: 20
Joined: 4/6/2014
Status: offline
...and after a three year absence, so it begins again!

We are using the Reluctant Admiral Mod 6.6 for this scenario. It is an interesting variation which Japan made some choices prior to the war and conducted some reorganizations which make them measurably stronger in the beginning of the war. On the other hand, the Allies have some new toys as well. Barring a disaster, the Japanese will be more viable well into '44.

First turns are exchanged and looking forward to seeing where Errki drops the hammer. Will post later this weekend after the first couple of exchanges.



<Options for game below; some standard house rules, nothing odd>

FOW: on
Advanced weather: on
Allied damage control: on
PDU: on
Historical first turn: off
December 7th surprise: on
Reliable USN torpedoes: off
Realistic R&D: on
No unit withdrawals: off
Reinforcements: fixed for both sides






Attachment (1)
Post #: 1
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/12/2014 3:41:22 AM   
BBfanboy


Posts: 18046
Joined: 8/4/2010
From: Winnipeg, MB
Status: offline
Looking forward to your campaign!
Did you have a different poster name when you were on the forum in the past?

BTW, better tell the Coast Guard that their giant cloaking device is not going to work ... and the Sunoco station wants it back!

_____________________________

No matter how bad a situation is, you can always make it worse. - Chris Hadfield : An Astronaut's Guide To Life On Earth

(in reply to cdoarm)
Post #: 2
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/12/2014 4:06:13 AM   
John 3rd


Posts: 17178
Joined: 9/8/2005
From: La Salle, Colorado
Status: offline
Have a GOOD time! If you have questions regarding the Mod, I shall try to help.

BANZAI!


_____________________________



Member: Treaty, Reluctant Admiral and Between the Storms Mod Team.

Reluctant Admiral Mod:
https://sites.google.com/site/reluctantadmiral/

(in reply to BBfanboy)
Post #: 3
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/14/2014 12:29:56 AM   
cdoarm

 

Posts: 20
Joined: 4/6/2014
Status: offline
07 DECEMBER 1941

The war began with an extremely heavy attack on the Philippines Islands and Malaya. Notable was there was no strike on Pearl Harbor. In at least one significant way, this creates a problem right off the bat.

Philippines Islands: The entire KB conducted a surprise attack on the port of Manila. The losses were 8 Auxillaries, 5 Oiler/Tankers, 3 PGs, 5 PT Boats, 12 AK/AKLs, 2 APs and most significant, 26 Submarines. The remainder of vessels were severely damaged for the most part and I had to scuttle another eight vessels (including 3 submarines). Interestingly, there was no strike on Clark Field though I imagine that is upcoming and have moved fighters to prepare. There were two landings at Laong and Aparri and a parachute landing at Malaybalay. I have begun rearranging forces on the Luzon in order to contain the existing landings.

DEI: There were no attacks and no sighting of submarines, but a nine vessel Cruiser TF was spotted in close proximity to the my Houston TF, which is moving south towards Darwin. High likelihood of a night engagement but am going to try to avoid it.

Pearl Harbor: No strike at PH but spotted a dozen submarines in the waters surrounding the island chain. I have both Carrier TFs linking up IVO Palamyra and won't bring them back to PH until my ASW TFs clear the way. 12 DDs and supporting aviation are committed to the initial effort.

Malaya: The Japanese began their attacks with air strikes on the northern most airfields but no strikes on Singapore proper. There was a landing in force at Khota Baru and expect troops to push west from Patani and Singora. I have begun to redeploy the Army to my first and second defensive lines (Kuala Lumpur and Mersing lines respectively). There was plenty of naval activity with a Dutch submarine scoring the first allied kill of the war, sinking a loaded Japanese AK moving west towards Malaya. A Japanese BB TF heading southward towards Singapore was attacked several times and the Nagato was hit by 3 x500lb bombs with minimum observed damage (one destroyed weapon system and fire, no penetrations). The TF was likely after Force Z but I had moved it northward towards Ceylon. It was attacked by a large flight of x25 Nells/Betties. The Repulse was hit twice with one torpedo a dud and one causing minimum damage - Force Z is moving north best possible speed and will likely be in the engagement envelope one more day.

Thoughts: The loss of the Submarine Fleet at Manila is a more significant loss than if Erkki had launched on PH. I have 49 subs still in action with another 60 arriving in the next year (I will get 300+ subs before the end of the war) so numerically the loss is not decisive; but does cripple the initial strategy. In RA 6.6, the Japs need to make a strong push into the DEI and early. The best tool to slow the steamroller is the US Sub Fleet and that has been eliminated. I have a fleet of warships massing off northern Australia centered on the CVL Charlotte, but once the Japs get a significant airfield in the DEI, the utility of this fleet will quickly wane as the danger to it rises. It will take a few turns to find out the pace of Erkki's advance and what his escort carriers are up to. In the meantime, massing fleets at Ceylon, Northern Australia and Pearl Harbor and moving vulnerable assets out of the kill zones at a number of collection points - it will take the better part of the month getting everyone to their initial positions to implement convoy plan.

(in reply to John 3rd)
Post #: 4
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/14/2014 1:53:34 AM   
Cribtop


Posts: 3890
Joined: 8/10/2008
From: Lone Star Nation
Status: offline
Good luck!

_____________________________


(in reply to cdoarm)
Post #: 5
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/16/2014 3:47:41 AM   
cdoarm

 

Posts: 20
Joined: 4/6/2014
Status: offline
09 DECEMBER 1941

The pace of Japanese attacks have started to pick up with major landings in Malaya and the Philippines Islands.

Philippines Islands: Japanese Escort Carriers appear to be hanging out off the east coast of Mindinado and they have been taking a toll on the small freighters and transports trying to flee the PI. The air battle heated up and have lost roughly 45 aircraft of all types, primarily fighters due to hits on Clark Field and in air to air combat. The only really effective air attacks I have managed have been the single B-17D squadron out of Cagaygan which conducted an air attack against Pelilu and damaged some aircraft on the ground. Nearest I can tell, Erkki has about 7000 troops ashore at Laong, Apari and San Fernando (this landing was contested by a PI Division which held firm - it is being reinforced from the south). The best bit of news is that I have 8 PTs boats and the two Hong Kong DDs off the north coast of the PI and they have caused the aborting of at least two landings and have sunk sunk 2 PBs and heavily damaged two AKs. The two DDs were destroyed by a cruiser TF.

DEI: There have been no landings yet though navy search has detected inbound TFs off the north coast of Borneo and the northeast coast of New Guniea. The Houston TF managed to escape the Cruiser Ambush on the 8th but the CL Marblehead and escorting DDs were not no so lucky. The Marblehead was quickly sunk with no hits on the Cruisers. I have sortied the Charlotte to link up with the Houston near Java in order to strike if any of his forces make their way further south.

China: China has been relatively quiet save for Hong Kong which is in the process of getting reduced. I have intentionally left some of the weaker Chinese units forward in order to focus the IJA while I start the laborious process of moving the Chinese formations behind rivers and in mountains and begin fortifying. I don't detect alot of Japanese movements yet but I am sure they will come.

Thoughts: So far it hasn't been too terrible a position yet. I have lost approximately 70 ships but besides the 26 submarines on day one and the Marblehead, everything has been the small ships in the PI which given Erkki committed the entire carrier fleet to striking the PI, were never going to survive anyways. I am happy with the naval engagements off the north coast of the PI and the delays of getting forces ashore. I need at least five more days to get at least initial defensive line in north of Manila and these delays help. The air battle right now stands at 85 allied to 40 Japanese. I will accept 2:1 at this stage of the game. Right now, I believe that I will see another wave of landings in the PI and the first landings in Borneo in the coming days. I probably have about one week before the long range bombers start making the waters of the DEI much more difficult to transit so I have moving some assets out and being cautious with the Charlotte.

(in reply to Cribtop)
Post #: 6
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/25/2014 2:10:56 AM   
cdoarm

 

Posts: 20
Joined: 4/6/2014
Status: offline
20 DECEMBER 1941

1st wave of Japanese advances appears to be complete with the second likely to occur in the next ten days.

West Coast: After several days of preparations, the first massive convoy of over sixty-five ships has departed San Francisco. The Saratoga CV TF leads the way followed by convoy transporting approximately 20,000 troops and over 100 aircraft to Pearl Harbor for onward movement.

Central Pacific: IJN conducted an invasion of Wake Island which was complete surprise (no detection of inbounds) and was quickly overrun. Midway and the Phoenix/Line Islands are being fortified with troops, patrol craft and being made into advance sub bases to support Sub Zone 1 & 2. The Lexington/Enterprise TF has put out to sea and decision is being made between two raid plans: COA 1 – Ambitious raid on convoy routes from Home Islands or COA 2 – More limited raid on Wake Island.

South Pacific: KB was tracked from Truk heading SE to support a successful landing on Tulagi. Landed USAAF base forces reinforced with NZ battalions at Espirtu Santo and Efate. Eventually plan on moving B17E squadrons in Brisbane (18 AC) to ES to begin bombing operations on Tulagi.

Southwest Pacific: Australia is in very weak position with negligible air and sea power to contest any advance. Australians have several brigades but doesn’t make any sense to pay PP cost and transport them northward without any significant air/sea support. IJ has landed at Manus and Weewak and expect a push into Rabual within a week. Squadron of French subs is guarding the north approaches of Rabual and squadron of A24s is at Port Moseby in order to put up some resistance. Noumea is being established as advance sub base for Sub Zone 3.

DEI: The second most active theater behind the Philippines. IJ has landed at Ternate and Manado. Ternate fell easily but the Manado invasion was understrength and the Dutch are still resisting. Kendari and Ambon have been reinforced with A24s and Gull/Sparrow BNs. The A24s were very effective at the Ternate landing scoring several hits on AKs during the landing. The IJN CVL/CVEs have been ranging south of Mindanao but have yet to contribute significantly. The Allies have put together a CV/CA Fleet built around the CVL Charlotte and Dutch/US Cruisers. The first counterattack attacked north through the Makassar Strait with the IJ Carriers were confirmed Pelilu and sank/damaged 2 AKs IVO Zamboaga. The second counterattack went up the west coast of Borneo in order to catch IJ BBs/CAs off Singkawang. Japanese Zeroes were out in force and shot down all 12 Charlotte SBDs. The Allied fleet is moving back to Java to repair/refuel and evaluate next move, possibly attempting to cover expected Japanese moves against Sumatra.

Philippines: The IJ main effort has fallen heavy on the PI but the forces are currently holding. IJ airpower has decimated USAAF/PI fighter cover and B17s operating on Luzon. PBYs have been relocated into the center islands and have scored notable hits IVO Legaspi (4 AK/APs sunk/damaged). The Japanese landings have occurred on the north, east and south of Luzon but all are currently blocked by significant concentrations of USA/PI troops. Mauban has the largest concentration with 13K IJA vs. 8K allied forces. The most significant check was at San Fernando where PI Troops supported by US armor destroyed the Kanno Detachment. IJ is landing more forces at all beach heads and eventually one of the allied positions will break (San Fernando position will be my guess), probably before the end of the year.

Malaya and SE Asia: IJ advance through Malaysia is starting to pick up steam with recent landing at Kuantuan and IJ advance towards Kuala Lumpur. First defensive line north of Kuala Lumpur can probably handle the initial thrust but the Kuantuan landing will likely unhinged this line. The second defensive line at Mersing is being prepared. Sea Traffic is still viable out of Singapore as IJN Nells/Bettys haven’t been spotted in the area for several turns (IJA level bombers are carrying the load at Malaysia). Air operations are becoming increasingly expensive with 1:2.5 losses typical but Singapore has only been lightly hit and LBs/TBs have scored several hits on vessels at Kuantuan landings. Off the north coast of Borneo, Dutch submarines have scored two notable successes with the O19 hitting the CA Takao with one torpedo and the KXV putting one torpedo into the CM Adzuma. The IJA conducted a paratroop assault on Port Blair (and lost several Transport aircraft in the process) and established a patrol aircraft base. A RN Bombardment TF (PoW and Repulse) conducted a raid on Port Blair and severely damaged the airfield and the Air Support Company (250+ casualties), rendering it useless for the time being. Burma is being reinforced with particular emphasis on the coast.

China: IJA offensive has been very successful and have conducted rapid advance to Changsa but are now checked by large buildup of Chinese forces. The supply cost of maintaining the force there will be huge but it will be necessary cost. Chinese counterattack at Ichang seized the city causing 5K plus casualties on both sides. Several minor actions have occurred with the Chinese typically taking the worst of engagements.

Further Thoughts: Erkki seems to like doing simultaneous invasions with the thrusts into the DEI consisting of several landings on the same day or close together. I suspect that a second way is getting ready to occur with the objectives being Rabual/Lae, Celebes, and possibly Sumatra. I have been somewhat surprised by the leisurely pace in the PIs and Malaysia but he appears to be picking up the pace in both (think he might have under resourced those invasions but judging by amounts of traffic at PI/Malysian beachheads, he is addressing that deficiency). He has been playing conservatively with his carriers in my opinion, covering existing invasions rather than ranging in front of them. My initial plan of attrition on his AKs/APs while retaining as much Fleet power as possible still seems sound.

My losses to date have been 133 Allied ships to 8 IJN. The losses are not nearly as bad given that the majority of them (114) occurred in the first three days and consistent of the merchant vessels, auxillaries, and subs in the PI. The IJN has lost 8 but have likely scored significant hits on twice that number. I have lost 318 to 160 IJ losses. The majority of my losses have been P40 B/Es in the PI (70+) and Buffalos at Singapore while the majority of the IJ losses have been Nells/Betties over the PI.






Attachment (1)

(in reply to cdoarm)
Post #: 7
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/25/2014 4:16:38 PM   
ny59giants


Posts: 9869
Joined: 1/10/2005
Status: offline
I'm in mid-May 42 playing this mod as Allies, so I know some things you are dealing with.
I would take CVL Charlotte out of battle range while you send her DBs to Soerabaja to upgrade from SBD-1 to -2s. The added range will help. Getting Hermes repaired and joined with her is a good thing, IMO.
A-24 Banshee - I kept the least experienced in training for NavB once their morale got to 99 at Darwin. The other two can do well against merchants, but not warships.
Shift PBYs from USA to Hawaii via Dutch Harbor and Midway before they head to SoPac and further. Got to get them to see whats out there so you can run or attack.
Getting fuel from USA to SoPac, NZ, and Oz is a major effort for the first few months. Spend the time to get this working right.

_____________________________


(in reply to cdoarm)
Post #: 8
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/26/2014 1:59:42 AM   
cdoarm

 

Posts: 20
Joined: 4/6/2014
Status: offline
I fully agree with you on the Fuel/Oil/Resource problem and the effort required. I got massive amounts of ships moving to the West Coast and Abadan now to start the convoy system. Australia starts off in the whole right off the bat and it is going to be two months before I can get them into gear.

Thanks for the advice on the PBYs. They have already made the trip to Pearl Harbor and have been redeploying them to Midway, Johnston, Line and Phoenix Islands to secure part of the convoy route. Will likely use B17Es in SOCPAC until I can get more PBYs online for naval searching.

(in reply to ny59giants)
Post #: 9
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/27/2014 1:36:31 PM   
cdoarm

 

Posts: 20
Joined: 4/6/2014
Status: offline
23 DECEMBER 1941

DEI: Called it. The expected IJ invasion of Sumatra is underway at Palemberg. Multiple TFs coming across IVO Sinikwang enroute west-southwest. Moving ASW TF out of the way back to Singapore but possible that the 3 PG group may be intercepted prior to getting there. The Charlotte CVL is south of Java heading back to Darwin and won't be part of this action (considering withdrawing it from DEI - lots of minor damage including some engine damage from two high speed sorties not to mention the DB losses). I have 5 Dutch Subs in the area (including O19 - my best Dutch sub) and expect to get a few engagements. Dutch air out of Java already has engaged the previous turn and hasn't scored a single hit so not expecting much out of them. Still significant number of bombers and torpedo bombers out of Singapore and hopefully they can get a strike in.

< Message edited by Iroquois -- 4/28/2014 11:27:30 PM >

(in reply to cdoarm)
Post #: 10
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 4/28/2014 10:31:02 PM   
cdoarm

 

Posts: 20
Joined: 4/6/2014
Status: offline
24 DECEMBER 1941

China: Finally had a needed victory on the Chinese front. The IJA offensive towards Changsa was like a tidal wave and previously unstoppable. The Chinese finally managed to stop them. The supply situation is going to be terrible but think I will get a few days of peace there till Erkki tries again. Now time to pay some more attention to rapidly developing situation at the north end of the front.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ground combat at Changsha (82,52)

Japanese Deliberate attack

Attacking force 45620 troops, 532 guns, 74 vehicles, Assault Value = 1343

Defending force 91407 troops, 540 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 2514

Japanese engineers reduce fortifications to 3

Japanese adjusted assault: 348

Allied adjusted defense: 6121

Japanese assault odds: 1 to 17 (fort level 3)

Combat modifiers
Defender: terrain(+), forts(+), leaders(+), experience(-)
Attacker:

Japanese ground losses:
6654 casualties reported
Squads: 48 destroyed, 811 disabled
Non Combat: 2 destroyed, 81 disabled
Engineers: 2 destroyed, 74 disabled
Vehicles lost 17 (10 destroyed, 7 disabled)

Allied ground losses:
313 casualties reported
Squads: 1 destroyed, 18 disabled
Non Combat: 0 destroyed, 11 disabled
Engineers: 2 destroyed, 16 disabled

Assaulting units:
18th Ind.Mixed Brigade
39th Division
8th Armored Car Co
3rd Division
6th Division
58th Infantry Regiment
11th Army
51st Ind.Mtn.Gun Battalion
22nd AA Regiment
15th Ind.Medium Field Artillery Regiment
8th Ind. Engineer Regiment
52nd Ind.Mtn.Gun Battalion
2nd Ind. Mountain Gun Regiment
1st Mortar Battalion
14th Medium Field Artillery Regiment
2nd Ind. Engineer Regiment
51st Road Const Co

Defending units:
6th Construction Regiment
87th Chinese Corps
99th Chinese Corps
78th Chinese Corps
53rd Chinese Corps
37th Chinese Corps
26th Chinese Corps
72nd Chinese Corps
44th Chinese Corps
20th Chinese Corps
79th Chinese Corps
74th Chinese Corps
58th Chinese Corps
5th Construction Regiment
27th Group Army
29th Group Army
19th Group Army
9th War Area
17th Chinese Base Force
30th Group Army
41st AA Regiment


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

< Message edited by Iroquois -- 4/29/2014 12:29:53 AM >

(in reply to cdoarm)
Post #: 11
RE: Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J)... - 5/5/2014 1:49:40 AM   
cdoarm

 

Posts: 20
Joined: 4/6/2014
Status: offline
30 DECEMBER 1941

Japanese Forces are in the middle of their second massive push into the DEI. The Allied collapse in Malaya and Philippines begins.

North Pacific: New units flowing into Anchorage and expect another ten days of consolidation before transfer to the Aleutians. Engineers are already present at Adak Island and building Airfield. Pace of construction in the Aleutians will increase in January ’42.

West Coast: Quiet given the first major convoy is away. The wave of US Army reinforcements assigned to homeland defense has been dispersed to suitable positions and those forces identified for overseas duty have been moved to San Francisco and Seattle. Yorktown CV has arrived and will move to San Francisco to await repairing Battleships and the next major convoy to Pearl.

Central Pacific: Relatively quiet. US CVs and BBs raided Wake Island and inflicted moderate damage. Raid TF is in the process of returning to Pearl Harbor where the two US CVs will be joined by the Saratoga. There will be a short refit period and then I will begin a general fleet movement towards Australia (CVs, BBs and supporting units) into order to check the Japanese advance, which has become to pick up steam. Sub bases at Midway and Canton have been established and subs have already begun to operate from them. Japanese subs are pretty thick in the waters and despite intensive ASW efforts, only managed to sink one sub. On the other hand, I have been managing the convoy paths into PH bringing each TF in on a different approach (the Saratoga CV TF hit the IJN sub screen and went due south and came in from the south). It has added a couple of days of transit on each TF but I have only lost one AK around PH.

South Pacific: I have begun to build up Efate, Espirtu Santu and New Calidonia (Noumea). There has been some IJN sub activity around Suva but otherwise there hasn’t been any serious activity beyond a Japanese landing at Tarawa.

Southwest Pacific: Japanese have landed and seized Rabual and Kaviang which proved to be a costly landing when the A24s damaged two heavy cruisers. Japanese CVs were spotted operating IVO Truk and points southeast but otherwise they haven’t moved further south. Sub activity has increased around Horn Island and off Gilli Gilli and there has been several sub engagements but thankfully, about half of the Japanese torpedoes have been duds (including 2 against the CL Perth!). Reinforcements from PH (planes and troops) are about three weeks out so if the Japanese make a huge push for Port Moseby in that timeframe, I won’t be able to stop it (nor would I seriously contest it). The Charlotte CVL and US/Dutch CA/CL TF which was operating in the DEI is transferring to this area (currently transiting the straits) and after a short refit/repair shift in Brisbane/Sydney will be ready to join Australian/NZ Navy. This will have to do until the US Fleet transfers to Australia in late January 42.

DEI: The expected invasion of Palemberg came and essentially it was a walkover. The Charlotte CVL TF conducted its second raid about three days in advance of the invasion but after a disastrous encounter between the Charlotte’s DBs and Oscar CAP over Singkawang (lost/damaged 12 DBs) and subsequent chase and evasion from IJN BB TF, the Charlotte was withdrawn. Dutch subs managed a few unsuccessful engagements and the Dutch Air Force was completely ineffective, losing over two dozen AC for two minor hits. 4 TKs (3 of which had been damaged earlier) were destroyed and Palemberg was taken. The Japanese did lose the CL Kuma and a pair of APs to mines at Palemberg but that was the extent of damage. I have moved out all significant naval assets (except for subs) from the western DEI given the heavy IJN presence (including CVs and BBs) and have moved all Dutch Army units to the beaches of Java in order to make the initial landings as costly as possible. The IJN hasn’t made any significant moves in the eastern DEI in the past ten days and have transferred some surviving B17 units from the PI to Darwin and have A24s at key points. There are two small DD TFs ready to check any advances. Previous landings in the region have been very light on escorts so I think I may have opportunity to spring a surprise, at least until Java falls and then all bets are off.

Philippines: Disaster has struck and the lines have been broken. The defensive line at San Fernando and Lingayen was rapidly broken in 3 days of fighting that routed the PI units at a loss of 6000 casualties. Forces at Mauben, Lucena and Bayombong are in the process of being pulled back and while I expect the get the first two back to Manila, I don’t have high hopes that I will be able to get the 8,000 troops at Bayombong back to Manila prior to being cut off. The Air squadrons in the PI have pretty much been chased from the air and have pulled B17 and PBYs out. The IJA has pretty much taken all the significant points on Mindanao and Palawan. I expect that Luzon will be completely taken over by the end of January 42 at this current rate and then the rest of the PI will be picked off at Erkki’s leiasure.

Malaya and SE Asia: More bad news as the IJA breaks the defensive line at Kuala Lumpur with surprising ease. The loss of KL makes the stronger position at Temuloh untenable and in the process of withdrawing the second line at Mersing and depending on the rate of IJA advance, may bypass to the third line at Johore Bahru. I expect that the rate of collapse will be slower in Malaysia than in the PI but the next couple of days will be critical in staying ahead of the IJA advance. The Japanese Air Forces have been keeping up a pretty steady stream of air attacks in the Singapore region and I have begun to evacuate Allied air out. The surviving Blenheims and Hudsons have been evacuated to Burma and I have evacuated fighters to Sumatra where I have AKs on standby to get them out. In Burma, the first IJA advance has reached Moulmein where I have the 1st Burma Division, checking the advance. I am building a second line east of Rangoon just in case Moulmein becomes untenable. Burma’s fate will largely hinge on those forces in Malaysia but for the time being, the situation there is stable.

China: The good news was the IJA was turned back sharply at the first battle of Changsa with over 8000 casualties, pretty much the only point which there has been good news. The IJA has been pushing hard in the north and south and have cut off some Chinese forces in the coastal plains. I am in the process of moving a third of the forces at Changsa towards the southern front, the area which is most in need.

Further Thoughts: It appears that I have miscalculated my positions in Malaysia and the PI. Rather than turtling up in Manila or Singapore, I made an attempt to actively defend and now may lose the PI/Malaysia quicker than I would otherwise. The armies committed to those efforts, once released, will be used in Burma/India and other locations. It is not all bad news. The IJN CVs have been hanging back, covering invasions but have not been ranging forward causing havoc. I have a moderately strong position in the eastern DEI and southern Burma. Both will crumble under sustained pressure but for the time being, they will hold.

Losses on the sea have been 167 to 11. The number isn’t particularly eye raising (besides the initial sub losses at Manila). The only fleet unit lost has been the CL Marblehead and none damaged. The vast majority of the ships lost have been the tiny tramp freighters and passenger ships in the PI and DEI. I am not really worried about it.

Air Losses have been eye raising, 499 to 227. Given that I tried to fight in the PI and Malaysia, 499 is probably about right. If January’s losses match Decembers, than I will begin to worry. I expect to lose another chunk when IJN/A invades Java, but otherwise I plan on being a bit more careful with the air.

(in reply to cdoarm)
Post #: 12
Page:   [1]
All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition >> After Action Reports >> Human Sacrifice (Reluctant Admiral 6.6) - Erkki (J) vs. Iroquois (A) <No Erkki> Page: [1]
Jump to:





New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts


Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI

0.719