After the Old Grudges Never Die release and the You Brexit, You Fix it announcement, we received a lot of feedback about the concept behind the Command LIVE project.
The idea to recreate fictional - although very realistic, in the CMANO pattern - scenarios, inspired by our daily reality, is truly fascinating and challenging at the same time. The amount elements to take in consideration for each decision could be overwhelming.
Luckily, Warfare Sims doesn’t fear this challenge, and we have at least 3 more scenarios (plus the upcoming You Brexit, You Fix it one) in the Pipeline!
It's time for you to raise your voices and you will be heard!
Do you have any geopolitical situation you would see covered in the Command LIVE series? What are in your opinion the next-gen wars?
Share your thoughts here!
< Message edited by Sunburn -- 12/17/2016 11:55:44 AM >
Although I'm working on such a scenario for ages now, I'd like to see a realistic modern day United States vs. Venezuela scenario with the potential of other nations (China) being drawn into the conflict.
For an air/sea scenario: ------------------------- The fighting over disputed island in the South China Sea between Beijing and Washington and the rest of the nations around the South China Sea.
For an air/land scenario: -------------------------- One of the many NATO military exercise goes wrong along the Russia Border and the Russia army react....
US air campaign against ISIS in Iraq and Syria, some special forces insertions and Russia in the area running their own air ops and possible conflicting objectives and escalating tensions between the two air forces.
Over the next 2 years, Ukraine-NATO cooperation increases significantly. In 2018, Russia, unable to fully support the DPR, has to decide between abandoning them or fully invading Eastern Ukraine to solidify that territory. They choose the latter, and as a diversion for NATO, Russia amasses troops on the Baltic borders. However, 2 days before the planned Russian invasion of Ukraine, there is a small firefight between NATO and Russian units on the border of Latvia. As a response, NATO announces that they will militarily support Ukraine in the event of an invasion. 2 days later, Russian air forces meet Ukrainian air forces and NATO advance aircraft in combat. Scenario can last up to a week, both sides receiving reinforcements as the scenario progresses.
If you want to link it to You Brexit You Fix It, you could say that the alliance was formed as a result of the Baltic war that was portrayed in that scenario.
< Message edited by Excroat3 -- 7/29/2016 10:54:34 PM >
Posts: 250
Joined: 12/7/2015 From: San Francisco, CA Status: offline
Does it have to be current events?
If so, I would love a fictional scenario where the Japanese rewrite their constitution and start countering China. Indonesia turns to an oligarchy and spins up its military to invade Malaysia. Australia comes in on the side of the phillipines during a China incursion. Vietnam and China go at it in the South China Sea.
An American Intervention in Syria after the Ghouta chemical attack (2013) - providing different degrees of interventions (= subscenarios) (the "Zero" alternative we have we already seen).
"In March 2010, the U.S. Geological Survey estimated a mean of 1.7 billion barrels of recoverable oil and a mean of 34.5 trillion cubic meters of recoverable gas in the Levant Basin in the eastern Mediterranean, which includes the territorial waters of Lebanon, Israel, Syria and Cyprus."
Real world: Since at least 2000 there have been increasing oil & gas field discoveries in the Eastern Med. http://menasborders.blogspot.co.uk/2011/01/noble-energys-new-find-draws-attention.html A number of these fields are close to and in some cases straddle already disputed maritime EEZ borders. Over the past 4 or 5 years there have been a number of claim and accusations.
At present Egypt seems to have it's claims fairly well established following a massive discovery in 2015, but there were past accusations from some that Israel were drilling illegally it Egyptian territory.
Add to all that the complicating factor that these drilling rigs are international commercial/civilian drilling platforms, most not owned/operated by the country who claims the EEZ
Given the past and ongoing real world EEZ border disputes and the current mayhem in the region it shouldn't be too hard to come up with a scenario where somebody starts shooting! Of course it all depends on if you believe a country would ever go to war over something as trivial as oil!
If there was a shooting match between Lebanon & Israel then Israel should easily win, although the Lebanese Hezbollah manned/conrolled mobile C-802 missile launchers might cause some upset (as with INS Hanit 2006) Maybe Lebanon grant drilling/exploration rights to Russian oil/gas companies. Russia may then feel justified in protecting it's assets (and strengthening it's influence in the region) by moving naval units a little further South. As for Turkey ... I doubt even Turkey knows how that's going to turn out.
I did start a scenario on this subject with Israel/Lebanon/Egypt ...... but it ended up as just another stalled project!
Emboldened Iran vs Israel and/or US. Let's say using their new toys they decide to stir the pot in the Gulf. Alternatively, intelligence surfaces that the nuclear program was never cancelled.
Russians decide to use a tactical nuclear strike in the Baltic against a NATO naval task force to 'escalate to de-escalate' and force NATO to the negotiating table before an Amercan counteroffensive into the occupied Baltic states.
Along the theme of 'Old Grudges' I would consider the current mid-East "Cold War" between Iran and Saudi Arabia interesting material with a lot of hypothetical branches.
The current "Cold War" could go hot if Iran intervened directly in a coup in Bahrain or if an assassination of a key diplomat was traced back to its source.
There are a number of regional powers who would immediately get caught up in such a war. It is also possible the major powers would find themselves drawn in, sort of a mini-WWI.
_____________________________
You and the rest, you forgot the first rule of the fanatic: When you become obsessed with the enemy, you become the enemy. Jeffrey Sinclair, "Infection", Babylon 5
After the failed coup in Turkey the US refuses to extradite the man they think organised it due to insufficient evidence. Turkey decide to force the US President's hand by banning anti IS flights from Incerlik and blockading the airfield. Local NATO commander secures the airbase but the Turks place mobile AD units around it with orders to shoot down any aircraft coming or going. NATO have to break the blockade
Indo-Pakistani war in the near future. Threat of Pakistani nukes falling into the hands of the likes of ISIS causes India to react militarily. Draws in China, Russia, Iran and the US. Plenty of deep water and superpower bases nearby. Lots of nice hardware too. Muslim <> Communist <> the rest. Very messy.
How about a smaller scale scenario where terrorists manage to steal a small submarine and are attempting to set explosives to destroy the Channel Tunnel? Unfortunately the only units in the area are either helicopters deployed from a nearby airfield (could be French and English) or patrol boats attempting to scramble before the terrorists can achieve their goal. I imagine to make it difficult the amount of civilian traffic would be very high and the hostile submarine would be traveling slow and from a random location each time the scenario is run.
Posts: 176
Joined: 11/5/2013 From: United States Status: offline
quote:
ORIGINAL: kevinkin
Can a scenario be designed that will penalize the destruction of civilians and their assets?
Yes. A simple event that subtracts points whenever a unit on that side (In this case the side(s) would be Civilian) is destroyed. A ton of scenarios have something like this implemented. You can vary from x points for every unit lost, or do specific point loss by type of civilian casualty.
Many years ago Tom Clancy wrote the book "SSN" about a conflict with China about the Spratley Islands. And now this almost a reality. Seems to me that the South China Sea should be an excellent focus for a new scenario.
Posts: 2787
Joined: 5/26/2000 From: NSW, Australia Status: offline
quote:
ORIGINAL: Bert Blitzkrieg
Many years ago Tom Clancy wrote the book "SSN" about a conflict with China about the Spratley Islands. And now this almost a reality. Seems to me that the South China Sea should be an excellent focus for a new scenario.
You could make a number of scenarios from this with differing escalation levels as no one is sure where this will end up....
_____________________________
Cheers, Reg.
(One day I will learn to spell - or check before posting....) Uh oh, Firefox has a spell checker!! What excuse can I use now!!!
Trump is elected and critical liberals and hi-tech businesses leave for Canada. Trump calls for extradition of 'traitors' back to homeland to make an example but Canada refuses. Ordered to 'show some flag' USN decides to blockade Eastern Seaboard Harbors. Canada calls for help from a Br-exited UK.