Dinglir
Posts: 620
Joined: 3/10/2016 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: chaos45 Its really not crazy if you look at the game situation-the German summer offensive was a failure and captured nor isolated any major soviet cities. Basically took much less ground than historical which also resulted in fewer soviet encirclement losses. All those extra soviet manpower points not take added up to a ton of extra manpower in 1941...all those little dot towns of manpower add up when your at 100:1 for manpower adds in 41. I disagree with that one - the Axis advances are actually more or less historical in this game. From north to south: 1) In front of Leningrad, I have taken less terrain than the Axis did historically 2) Between Moscow and Leningrad, the Soviets had advanced (from the north) to just east of Velikie Luki. 3) Southwest of Moscow, the Soviet winter attacks had reached the terrain no more than four or five hexes east of Smolensk. 4) Orel, Kursk and Kharkov were barely in Axis hands at this stage of the war, much like in this game. 5) North of the Sea of Azov, the Axis lines followed the Mius river, exactly as they do right now. You may well argue of whether this is more or less than the historical gains by the Axis, but claiming that it is "much less ground than historical" is, in my humble opinion, wrong. quote:
ORIGINAL: chaos45 Not to be a downer but the German player should just throw in the towel, as this game should lead to a soviet win 43-44. I will not be doing that. I certainly do not share your feeling of utter gloom over the Axis, and I will be surprised if the Soviets manage a win in 43 or early 44. I have no experience with the late war, so I abstain from having opinions of late 44 or 45. But for now, I am actually still playing to win. But even if I fail to do that, there are also the Decisive, the Major and the Minor objectives to play for. For now, I am enjoying the game and learning a lot, so I am planning to continue. I have obviously given HardLuck the same option that he has given me: If he loses interest in the game, he should simply say so, and the game will then end.
_____________________________
To be is to do -- Socrates To do is to be -- Jean-Paul Sartre Do be do be do -- Frank Sinatra
|