Slitherine

quote:

ORIGINAL: btd64

Para, No need to send files. I have a set that I'm using to make the fixes. What I can't figure out is how you did the torpedoes upgrade so I can reverse it. That is one edge that people have been on. Well, I have something to do, later....GP

quote:

ORIGINAL: cavalry

Thanks for all the action... what version am I then playing? Its going to take more than a few adjustments....What about the MS Morane FR fighter - its stats seem impossible... they should have defeated Germany in 1940 with this - its better than any Jap fighter as far as I can see. I am losing about 8/1 even with my best pilots

Here are some other big issues

To many bases in DEI making too much supply
No Jap ship radar until 43???
Way overpowered Chinese Corps and it seems too much supply in China - This is now at standstill like WW1
DEI impossible to move into as allied air trashes all bases. Esp droves of B17...Nothing can tackle them. No Jap plane capable of taking on any allied bombers - I have stopped flying my planes almost everywhere in May 42 - I am getting shredded. But I see no sign of better planes. - Reduce effectiveness and volumes of allied planes until 43?
Missing FP on many jap ships
Too many allied land reinforcement early on its seems- My siege of Singapore has had to be called off there is no way to take it.
Let Japan have a run for all 42 - the scn is boring. But could be great.
Almost no Jap ASW - first decent upgrades Nov 42. Even they are not great.

Please understand the allies have auto victory pts already and its May 42 not May 44.

quote:

ORIGINAL: cavalry

Please note we have abandoned our game in May 42 by my agreement as Japan. I have given the iPlayer my password. There is just no way from Japan to progress in this game as it stands. They would never have attacked I cannot believe the historical context. In fact it could be the other way round. This mod feels more like 1950 in terms of the development of the bases and other general matters. That need not be a killer there are some good ideas that could be put in.



One thing that would be interesting in a new mod would be to have the jet fighters available earlier for both siides. I have never played the game where any jets have been available..

The other issues in this game are
Allied submarines are way too powerful at the beginning if Russia is active you are dead. We did have a house rule that Russia would only come into the game at the end of 42. Realistically with events on the Eastern front Russia would in theory not really have become active until late 1944

Japan basically has almost no antisubmarine warfare ships at all of any use and many of the destroyers have no antisubmarine at all. This means by mid 42 is risky to take the carriers out of port.

Allied four engine bombers are available in large quantities at the beginning of the war and Japan has nothing to stop them with.

Allied fighters at the beginning of the war are far superior to anything Japan has especially the French fighters and P38 . On the other hand Japan has the best quality pilots I've ever seen in a scenario but in the obsolete aircraft they are just dying in droves... By mid 42 I was not flying virtually any of my best pilots on any significant missions.Okay there are a lot of factories to crush in the DEI and it looks tempting to try and do but I made no progress into the DTI at all. Once the bases have garrisons and they generate their own supply the sieges become like World War I.

Singapore should have no supply generation the Japanese basically defeated it by turning off the water supply which came from the mainland. Both Singapore and Manila in this game are almost impossible to take if the allies have any significant forces available. I had to take around 10 divisions out of China et cetera just to try and besiege Manila

The Japanese four engine bomber is interesting and adds some new dimensions to the game but as it has no armour it cannot be used anywhere where it will meet fighters. The game designer sure that this, would have had a armour rating of zero. The second version in 43 does have armour but that's no good. I managed to build around 100 of these by mid 42 but they could only be used against rear area bases under siege.

Japan has a lot of land units but the quality of them seems terrible. They are incapable of taking on even the low grade allied units. What is interesting is all the extra little units that come on once you capture a base et cetera. That is a very good point of this game.

The Japanese navy is very large and interesting to use but without any antisubmarine capability it will suffer (And has in our game)enormous attrition quickly. I cannot believe in the world shown by this scenario that Japan would not have prepared more for the large number of submarines present.

Allied reinforcements need to be delayed around six months in general. This would tempt Japan to attack in real-life I suppose.

It is true that Russia has a large volume of oil and could be an alternative to the DEI and maybe I would have tried that but the problem is I do not believe the Japanese land units are capable of offensive operations. I see just a large number of sieges developing. I'm not sure I really want to play a game based around land sieges anyway. Especially as this game system has an odd and fickle way of handling land combat.

In this game in general Russian land units are overrated anyway. They should have very low morale and experience all the way through until mid-1943 I would have thought. Pilots are also overrated and should be lowered in experience. This is just my personal opinion on historical reading and other games. Including those designed by matrix wite.

Those are some of my key points. I would suggest that designers consider looking at some of the replays from other games in progress to really get the feel of the problems.

We are awaiting the outcome of a revised scenario before deciding whether or not to restart.

I would say in the meantime that my game of RA, feels realistic and very interesting though we do have an issue in that game with the high availability of advanced Japanese fighters early on. That said it is still making for a very interesting scenario.

quote:

ORIGINAL: BillBrown

When Brian does publish his FP mod, I am an Allied player with experience with this mod that would like to start a game if there
are any Japanese players who are willing. I normally do not play with any house rules, but there are a few first turn rules
I would like to discuss and will entertain any house rules you might want.

quote:

ORIGINAL: btd64

quote:

ORIGINAL: BillBrown

When Brian does publish his FP mod, I am an Allied player with experience with this mod that would like to start a game if there
are any Japanese players who are willing. I normally do not play with any house rules, but there are a few first turn rules
I would like to discuss and will entertain any house rules you might want.

I recommend one other HR. Pay PP's to cross national boundaries....GP

quote:

ORIGINAL: BillBrown

quote:

ORIGINAL: btd64

quote:

ORIGINAL: BillBrown

When Brian does publish his FP mod, I am an Allied player with experience with this mod that would like to start a game if there
are any Japanese players who are willing. I normally do not play with any house rules, but there are a few first turn rules
I would like to discuss and will entertain any house rules you might want.

I recommend one other HR. Pay PP's to cross national boundaries....GP

I don't even like that one to be honest.

quote:

ORIGINAL: cavalry

Just to say game is now in progress and in mid Jan 42.
all seems ok and its much better in general than last time.

The PP reduction is having a big effect on Japan and again neither Manila nor Singapore look takeable - I cannot even take Clark field yet. I do hope the supply in both these places was reduced especially Singapore - otherwise it will never fall and as I said before the Japanese turned the water off and that was it in real life.