Disbanding units that are about to be encircled

Matrix Games Forums

Forums Register Login Photo Gallery Member List Search Calendars FAQ

My Profile Inbox Address Book My Subscription My Forums Log Out

Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - exploit?

View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest

Users viewing this topic: none

Printable Version

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Gary Grigsby's War in the East 2 >> Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - exploit?

Page: [1] 2 next > >>

Message

<< Older Topic Newer Topic >>

Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - exploit? - 3/26/2021 6:35:13 PM

Beethoven1

Posts: 754
Joined: 3/25/2021
Status: offline

On the first Soviet turn of the Grand campaign, I noticed that it is possible to disband at least 1 or 2 of the units that are in the Bialystok/Minsk pocket. The 7th Tank Division in the screenshot attached can be disbanded. It seems this would save an extra 420 tanks from certain doom, including 120 T-34s and 46 KVs.

However, the manual says on Page 250, "Units can only disband if they have enough movement points remaining to move to a rail hex that is connected to the supply grid, and if they are not within three hexes of an enemy unit." But the screenshot shows that the unit can't move to any such rail hex, as far as I can see.

I assume this is not intended/is an exploit? I will not do it for now because it seems unrealistic. I would say the same is true for the fortified regions as well, which can all be disbanded, if those return to the national pool (maybe it would make sense if somehow they would just become partisans, but I assume that is not the case?)

Attachment (1)

Post #: 1

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 6:42:15 PM

Beethoven1

Posts: 754
Joined: 3/25/2021
Status: offline

Looking at it a bit more, I think it is simply letting you disband any division that is not within 3 hexes of an enemy unit (this applies to quite a few other divisions also), but it is not checking if it can move to a rail hex connected to the supply grid. So this lets you disband units that have no realistic way to escape encirclement, as long as they are not within 3 hexes of the enemy.

(in reply to Beethoven1)

Post #: 2

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 7:03:19 PM

Searry

Posts: 848
Joined: 1/24/2014
Status: offline

I'd say the AP is worth more than those tanks.

_____________________________

WITE2 Beta Tester
Axis Bias mod Fanboy
https://www.matrixgames.com/forums/tm.asp?m=5144537

(in reply to Beethoven1)

Post #: 3

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 7:18:29 PM

Beethoven1

Posts: 754
Joined: 3/25/2021
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Searry

I'd say the AP is worth more than those tanks.

They can be disbanded for 0 AP cost.

(in reply to Searry)

Post #: 4

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 7:53:36 PM

Searry

Posts: 848
Joined: 1/24/2014
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Beethoven1

quote:

ORIGINAL: Searry

I'd say the AP is worth more than those tanks.

They can be disbanded for 0 AP cost.

Definitely exploity then. I forgot about this change.

_____________________________

WITE2 Beta Tester
Axis Bias mod Fanboy
https://www.matrixgames.com/forums/tm.asp?m=5144537

(in reply to Beethoven1)

Post #: 5

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 9:12:17 PM

Joel Billings

Posts: 32265
Joined: 9/20/2000
From: Santa Rosa, CA
Status: offline

The unit is not isolated at the point at which your are about to disband it, so it is legal. I agree it's kind of sketchy given the size of the now opened pocket, but the rules that block are being within 3 hexes of an enemy unit and being isolated.

_____________________________

All understanding comes after the fact.
-- Soren Kierkegaard

(in reply to Searry)

Post #: 6

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 9:51:17 PM

Beethoven1

Posts: 754
Joined: 3/25/2021
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Joel Billings

The unit is not isolated at the point at which your are about to disband it, so it is legal. I agree it's kind of sketchy given the size of the now opened pocket, but the rules that block are being within 3 hexes of an enemy unit and being isolated.

My original post was actually understating the issue. It is apparently possible to save essentially the entire pocket by disbanding it. This is because even if a unit does not start more than 3 hexes away from a German unit, if you simply move it 3 units away (into the middle area of the pocket), then it can be disbanded. This despite the fact that there is no rail link out of the partly-formed-pocket and the unit doesn't have enough movement points to move to a rail hex that is linked to the rest of Soviet territory.

I tried this and it was possible to disband every single division except for 1 tank division that didn't have. That is saving many hundreds of thousands of men (and equipment) that historically and realistically would mostly have been captured.

Maybe what the German AI did on the first turn in my game is atypical or something, but if this is usual then a Soviet player who knows to click the "disband" button can basically avoid all manpower/equipment losses from the Bialystok/Minsk pocket, at least if I am understanding correctly the effects of "disband."

Here is a screenshot after I disbanded everything that could be disbanded (I could also have disbanded the HQ, but I got confused by the "relocate unit" option).

Attachment (1)

(in reply to Joel Billings)

Post #: 7

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 10:29:45 PM

Joel Billings

Posts: 32265
Joined: 9/20/2000
From: Santa Rosa, CA
Status: offline

The key is not letting the pocket bet opened up again. We've been working on a better first turn AI script that is more secure with this major pocket. We've found some things with the script replay that was making it underperform. Some times it will run fine and make a pocket that is secure, but other times it will fail. Of course there's no guarantee with a script because there is some variability in the first turn combat resolution, but we think we can do better. We hope to get the fix out within a few weeks. In the meantime, if you're just learning against the AI, if you want to make it more difficult on yourself, you can choose not to disband in a case like this. Thanks for the info.

_____________________________

All understanding comes after the fact.
-- Soren Kierkegaard

(in reply to Beethoven1)

Post #: 8

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 10:31:26 PM

Joel Billings

Posts: 32265
Joined: 9/20/2000
From: Santa Rosa, CA
Status: offline

BTW, what level of difficulty is this game set to?

_____________________________

All understanding comes after the fact.
-- Soren Kierkegaard

(in reply to Beethoven1)

Post #: 9

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 10:41:47 PM

CapAndGown

Posts: 3206
Joined: 3/6/2001
From: Virginia, USA
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Joel Billings

The key is not letting the pocket bet opened up again. We've been working on a better first turn AI script that is more secure with this major pocket. We've found some things with the script replay that was making it underperform. Some times it will run fine and make a pocket that is secure, but other times it will fail. Of course there's no guarantee with a script because there is some variability in the first turn combat resolution, but we think we can do better. We hope to get the fix out within a few weeks. In the meantime, if you're just learning against the AI, if you want to make it more difficult on yourself, you can choose not to disband in a case like this. Thanks for the info.

Thank you for your response, but I do not feel that simply making a better AI script is an adequate solution. That would obviously not apply to a human v human match. As Beethoven says, the unit should be able to move to a hex that is connected the friendly rail net. Perhaps a simpler solution would be to simply require all but fort units to be sitting on a such a rail hex in order to disband.

< Message edited by CapAndGown -- 3/26/2021 10:55:52 PM >

(in reply to Joel Billings)

Post #: 10

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 10:43:02 PM

Beethoven1

Posts: 754
Joined: 3/25/2021
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Joel Billings

BTW, what level of difficulty is this game set to?

I gave the AI 110% on everything, and me (Soviets) normal 100% on everything.

Also I didn't try to open up the pocket or anything, this was just how it was at the start of the turn. The AI just cut the rail links, but left a 2 hex gap near the Neman river so that the pocket was not completely "closed." That should not have really made a difference over the longer term since you don't have the movement points to escape in any case, but you can get around that by just disbanding everything. I definitely won't do that because I don't want to disrupt the balance for my first game, but I can see the potential for this to get exploited in multiplayer games with overly min-maxy players.

(in reply to Joel Billings)

Post #: 11

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 10:49:56 PM

Beethoven1

Posts: 754
Joined: 3/25/2021
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: CapAndGown

Thank you for your response, but I do not feel that simply making a better AI script is an adequate solution. That would obviously not apply to a human v human match. As Beethoven says, the unit should be able to move to a hex that is connected the friendly rail net. Perhaps a simpler solution would be to simply require all by fort units to be sitting on a such a rail hex in order to disband.

Yeah, I agree with this. It would be fine (or at least less unbalanced) if you could disband when the rail lines are not cut, but if the rail lines ARE cut, then disbanding to magically escape when you can't move out normally is an exploit.

Basically the check that would be needed is the same sort of check as was used to determine if a factory could be evacuated in WITE 1 - if the rail route out is cut (or in an enemy ZOC), then IMO you should not be able to disband.

IMO the real concern though is probably for multiplayer games. In a single player game I can just police myself and refrain from disbanding, in a multiplayer game (which I would eventually like to try), then I would only want to play if either this were changed or if there were a friendly house rule agreed with my opponent against doing this.

< Message edited by Beethoven1 -- 3/26/2021 10:52:28 PM >

(in reply to CapAndGown)

Post #: 12

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 11:09:42 PM

FriedrichII

Posts: 90
Joined: 3/16/2021
From: Germany
Status: offline

Do you think the AI could also exploit this and get out of the pocket?

(in reply to Beethoven1)

Post #: 13

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/26/2021 11:14:31 PM

timmyab

Posts: 2044
Joined: 12/14/2010
From: Bristol, UK
Status: offline

Probably needs some kind of extra condition before a unit can disband. Such as must be on or within so many hexes of a rail connected depot....and 3 hexes from nearest enemy. Also depot should be connected to a national supply source, not a port.

< Message edited by timmyab -- 3/26/2021 11:16:27 PM >

(in reply to Beethoven1)

Post #: 14

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 12:34:15 AM

Infierno

Posts: 102
Joined: 4/30/2017
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: CapAndGown

Perhaps a simpler solution would be to simply require all but fort units to be sitting on a such a rail hex in order to disband.

This seems like a harsh countermeasure to a niche problem to me. Agreed though that they need to be at least near a rail connected to supply.

_____________________________

If the rule you followed brought you to this, of what use was the rule?

(in reply to CapAndGown)

Post #: 15

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 12:58:34 AM

juv95hrn

Posts: 242
Joined: 6/28/2005
Status: offline

Disbanding now cost no AP, but the manual says each disband should cost one. Apparently the manual is correct, and the game is bugged, so the disbanding would come at a price.

Then you would get useful manpower, but it has to go into new units that need to train, and the tanks are mostly bad. Its not as bad as experienced divisions being able to teleport out (or like SUs in WITE1). Even with this, it would be better if the script always closed this pocket, but I doubt it will ruin the campaign considering an average of 3 million Soviet losses the first year, right?

One another note though....

What would be best to do with the HQs in a situation similar to this. Good to know for later in the war. Especially for a head-to-head game.

- Should you move them as far as possible then Relocate them to a safe location, eating relocation attrition potentially many times?

or

- Should you move them as far as possible and let German spearheads displace them for you, eating probably only one dislocation attrition?

or

- Should you disband them as well?

Support units can still teleport to STAVKA, if I understand it correctly, as long as a non-ZOC gap exists, no matter how isolated they might be.

Thanks!

(in reply to Infierno)

Post #: 16

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 1:03:19 AM

CapAndGown

Posts: 3206
Joined: 3/6/2001
From: Virginia, USA
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Infierno

quote:

ORIGINAL: CapAndGown

Perhaps a simpler solution would be to simply require all but fort units to be sitting on a such a rail hex in order to disband.

This seems like a harsh countermeasure to a niche problem to me. Agreed though that they need to be at least near a rail connected to supply.

Hardly a niche problem. I don't know how many times I have seen pockets broken in my H2H games in WitE. For instance: http://www.matrixgames.com/forums/fb.asp?m=4892000

< Message edited by CapAndGown -- 3/27/2021 1:05:26 AM >

(in reply to Infierno)

Post #: 17

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 1:30:01 AM

Sammy5IsAlive

Posts: 514
Joined: 8/4/2014
Status: offline

This looks like a bug to me - going of the screenshots all of the rail lines into the pocket have been cut so you are being allowed to disband when the rules say this shouldn't be possible. If you still have the save file it might be interesting to see a slightly more zoomed out view with the rail damage view applied so we can see where the game thinks the working Soviet rail is?

(in reply to juv95hrn)

Post #: 18

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 2:30:39 AM

Jim D Burns

Posts: 4013
Joined: 2/25/2002
From: Salida, CA.
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: CapAndGown
to simply require all but fort units to be sitting on a such a rail hex in order to disband.

I disagree, the unit should be able to trace a rail route to a national supply source, simply sitting on a rail isn't enough. If the rail isn't connected to the national pools disbanding should be prohibited. Then ignore the rail hex requirement and simply check that the unit can reach a rail route within x number of hexes. X being perhaps equal to or less than half the units available movement at turn start.

Jim

< Message edited by Jim D Burns -- 3/27/2021 6:12:52 AM >

(in reply to CapAndGown)

Post #: 19

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 4:37:36 AM

Zemke

Posts: 642
Joined: 1/14/2003
From: Oklahoma
Status: offline

If a unit could not move out of the pocket or move to a rail link connected to a National Supply source, then how could the disbanded men and equipment make it out of the pocket to the pool? Oh and they have no supply while they are moving to leave the pocket to the pool. This IMO is a major bug or oversight.

_____________________________

"Actions Speak Louder than Words"

(in reply to Jim D Burns)

Post #: 20

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 4:37:50 AM

Zemke

Posts: 642
Joined: 1/14/2003
From: Oklahoma
Status: offline

"Actions Speak Louder than Words"

(in reply to Jim D Burns)

Post #: 21

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 7:57:34 AM

guctony

Posts: 669
Joined: 6/27/2009
Status: offline

Well we can consider the case in France in 1944. when large portion of German units run away from southwest France by themselves without any organization. Normally there is no game mechanic to mimic this case. I believe. Yes They lost almost all their equipment but they were reorganized to divisions once they reach to front line. This reserve saved the day for the Germans in 1944 September.

_____________________________

"Unless a nation's life faces peril, war is murder."
"Sovereignty is not given, it is taken."
"After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
Mustafa Kemal

(in reply to Zemke)

Post #: 22

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 8:02:51 AM

CapAndGown

Posts: 3206
Joined: 3/6/2001
From: Virginia, USA
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Jim D Burns

quote:

ORIGINAL: CapAndGown
to simply require all but fort units to be sitting on a such a rail hex in order to disband.

I disagree, the unit should be able to trace a rail route to a national supply source, simply sitting on a rail isn't enough. If the rail isn't connected to the national pools disbanding should be prohibited. Then ignore the rail hex requirement and simply check that the unit can reach a rail route within x number of hexes. X being perhaps equal to or less than half the units available movement at turn start.

Jim

You do not disagree with me. You agree with what I said. Read the post again. I say a unit should be able to reach the rail net or be sitting on a hex of the rail net. Obviously I do not consider hexes with no connection to the functioning rail net (i.e. trace a path to the national supply source) to be valid. I was supporting Beethoven's point, not opposing it.

(in reply to Jim D Burns)

Post #: 23

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 8:10:24 AM

guctony

Posts: 669
Joined: 6/27/2009
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: guctony

Well we can consider the case in France in 1944. when large portion of German units run away from southwest France by themselves without any organization. Normally there is no game mechanic to mimic this case. I believe. Yes They lost almost all their equipment but they were reorganized to divisions once they reach to front line. This reserve saved the day for the Germans in 1944 September.

Having said that one way to discourage Disbanding can be adding additional VP cost to disbanding until a certain date or disbanding only brings manpower and a low percentage of equipment back to Pools up to a certain date.

Limiting disband to a horizontal map hex lines is another option also.

Worst case a House rule will fix it. We cant expect everything to be handled by Game engine.

< Message edited by guctony -- 3/27/2021 8:11:03 AM >

_____________________________

"Unless a nation's life faces peril, war is murder."
"Sovereignty is not given, it is taken."
"After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
Mustafa Kemal

(in reply to guctony)

Post #: 24

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 8:16:14 AM

CapAndGown

Posts: 3206
Joined: 3/6/2001
From: Virginia, USA
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: guctony

quote:

ORIGINAL: guctony

Well we can consider the case in France in 1944. when large portion of German units run away from southwest France by themselves without any organization. Normally there is no game mechanic to mimic this case. I believe. Yes They lost almost all their equipment but they were reorganized to divisions once they reach to front line. This reserve saved the day for the Germans in 1944 September.

Having said that one way to discourage Disbanding can be adding additional VP cost to disbanding until a certain date or disbanding only brings manpower and a low percentage of equipment back to Pools up to a certain date.

Limiting disband to a horizontal map hex lines is another option also.

Worst case a House rule will fix it. We cant expect everything to be handled by Game engine.

It worked fine in WitE 1. From 18.5.1 of the updated WitE 1 manual: "Units can only disband if they have enough movement points remaining to move to a rail hex that is connected to the supply grid, and if they are not within three hexes of an enemy unit."

(in reply to guctony)

Post #: 25

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 8:41:55 AM

guctony

Posts: 669
Joined: 6/27/2009
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: CapAndGown

quote:

ORIGINAL: guctony

quote:

ORIGINAL: guctony

Well we can consider the case in France in 1944. when large portion of German units run away from southwest France by themselves without any organization. Normally there is no game mechanic to mimic this case. I believe. Yes They lost almost all their equipment but they were reorganized to divisions once they reach to front line. This reserve saved the day for the Germans in 1944 September.

Having said that one way to discourage Disbanding can be adding additional VP cost to disbanding until a certain date or disbanding only brings manpower and a low percentage of equipment back to Pools up to a certain date.

Limiting disband to a horizontal map hex lines is another option also.

Worst case a House rule will fix it. We cant expect everything to be handled by Game engine.

It worked fine in WitE 1. From 18.5.1 of the updated WitE 1 manual: "Units can only disband if they have enough movement points remaining to move to a rail hex that is connected to the supply grid, and if they are not within three hexes of an enemy unit."

Well that's a fix but not really addressing the issue at hand. That is units inside an Envelope without any rail connection. Its not logical to assume Units will disband in an envelope with full TOE.

< Message edited by guctony -- 3/27/2021 8:42:47 AM >

_____________________________

"Unless a nation's life faces peril, war is murder."
"Sovereignty is not given, it is taken."
"After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
Mustafa Kemal

(in reply to CapAndGown)

Post #: 26

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 8:54:52 AM

CapAndGown

Posts: 3206
Joined: 3/6/2001
From: Virginia, USA
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: guctony

quote:

ORIGINAL: CapAndGown

quote:

ORIGINAL: guctony

quote:

ORIGINAL: guctony

Well we can consider the case in France in 1944. when large portion of German units run away from southwest France by themselves without any organization. Normally there is no game mechanic to mimic this case. I believe. Yes They lost almost all their equipment but they were reorganized to divisions once they reach to front line. This reserve saved the day for the Germans in 1944 September.

Having said that one way to discourage Disbanding can be adding additional VP cost to disbanding until a certain date or disbanding only brings manpower and a low percentage of equipment back to Pools up to a certain date.

Limiting disband to a horizontal map hex lines is another option also.

Worst case a House rule will fix it. We cant expect everything to be handled by Game engine.

It worked fine in WitE 1. From 18.5.1 of the updated WitE 1 manual: "Units can only disband if they have enough movement points remaining to move to a rail hex that is connected to the supply grid, and if they are not within three hexes of an enemy unit."

Well that's a fix but not really addressing the issue at hand. That is units inside an Envelope without any rail connection. Its not logical to assume Units will disband in an envelope with full TOE.

It is precisely the issue at hand, which is saving the manpower and equipment of pocketed units by disbanding them.

(in reply to guctony)

Post #: 27

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 10:10:36 AM

sillyflower

Posts: 3509
Joined: 8/4/2010
From: Back in Blighty
Status: offline

I don't know much about #2 yet, but can I suggest 2 possible solutions which I assume would be very easy to implement:

1 an isolated unit cannot disband or
2 a unit that has moved cannot disband that turn

_____________________________

web exchange

Post: I am always fearful that when I put this game down on the table and people see the box-art they will think I am some kind of neo-Nazi

Reply: They already know you're a gamer. What other shame can possibly compare?

(in reply to CapAndGown)

Post #: 28

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 10:31:55 AM

821Bobo

Posts: 2311
Joined: 2/8/2011
From: Slovakia
Status: offline

Isolated units cannot disband. In that screenshot the pocket was never closed. Question is if they should be able to disband if units dont have rail connection to supply network. Also those units around Bialystok have access to functional rail and depots, just not to the entire network. This is probably the reason that disband is allowed.
Also disbanded units will not come back so doubt it is worth losing permanently 20 counters, Soviets will miss them in late 41. Of course can be rebuild manually but all AP will be spend just for that.

(in reply to sillyflower)

Post #: 29

RE: Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - e... - 3/27/2021 10:40:02 AM

sillyflower

Posts: 3509
Joined: 8/4/2010
From: Back in Blighty
Status: offline

Tx Bobo, and GL vs HLYA - someone has to beat him :)

_____________________________

(in reply to 821Bobo)

Post #: 30

Page: [1] 2 next > >>

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Gary Grigsby's War in the East 2 >> Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - exploit?

Page: [1] 2 next > >>

Jump to:

New Messages	No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages	Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages	Locked w/o New Messages

Post New Thread

Reply to Message

Post New Poll

Submit Vote

Delete My Own Post

Delete My Own Thread

Rate Posts

1.188

Slitherine

Disbanding units that are about to be encircled - exploit?