Moltrey
Posts: 297
Joined: 4/11/2010 From: Virginia Status: offline
|
Skacee: I have reloaded WITP:AE and used your base enhancement mod with the first (original) fonts, indicators, etc. While testing the mod I noticed a few things that I want to provide some constructive criticism on. 1) Mapicons: Not sure if it is something I did, but the base Naval anchor and all the ship symbols on the map itself in-game are WHITE, not a nationality-specific color. So all the ships are colorless based on a quick glance around. I ended up using some of the ALT Mapicon files to change it, but I believe you meant to use the default color schemes for the Nations, like Dutch being an orange and French light blue, etc. When I go into the ART folder and look at the mapicon files, the ground units are colored, but the upper symbols and anchor are not. 2) Ocean (Deep vs. Shallow): This is a nitpick, but the difference btw the two is not quite enough to help my eyes "pick out" the difference at a glance. I wouldn't want a drastic difference, but a bit more seems in order. Same goes for some of the ocean labels, just a bit too faint. 3) Base Name Locations: Here I just think you need another run thru the locations in-game to double check how the location looks and what things are blocked, distance from the actual base, etc. Nothing is bad, but might use some tweaking here and there. 4) Terrain Graphics: Overall I really like the more muted green scheme a lot. But perhaps a bit more to delineate between types of terrain in-game. For instance, swamps don't stand out much. I know it is another layer in Photoshop, but maybe a black ink "weed" pattern or something? 5) Game Start and Setup Screens: I understand the look you are going for here. The Pacific map in the background and basic labels. But I find my eyes get "lost" in the muted color patterns and everything blends together too much. I wouldn't want anything real bright of course. Perhaps some lower shadows on the labels and a much more defined "switch" graphic to change the side you are playing. I would like to see another pass by you on this one. Please don't take this the wrong way, I REALLY like the stuff you are coming up with and the willingness to improve things. Thanks for listening.
< Message edited by Moltrey -- 10/12/2021 6:13:14 PM >
|