Alexandra
Posts: 546
Joined: 12/7/2000
From: USA
Status: offline
|
Again, I'm going to say that a MC: Stalingrad would be a bad idea, from either side.
From the German side:
1. Your core is dead, from before the first scenario. No *unit* that made in into the Kessel gout unit. Individuals from units may have but not the whole unit.
2. Repetition: There is a Stalingrad campaign, and it's a decent one, though I stopped playing it in the city, mostly because each scen became the same. The syyle Russian defense, the same 'suprises', etc. It got to the point where I knew what each VH would be guarded by, how they'd be deployed, etc. There is a great danger of that happening in an MC: Stalingrad.
3. Streetfighting: Se below.
From the Russian Side:
1. The first four months: The first four months of the campiagn was a typical mobile campaign - one which the Soviet's lost. The campaign flow ability doesn't allow a true 'you're supposed to lose' option and if it did, it still wouldn't be fun.
2. You're dead: The average Russian unit, in 62nd and 64th Armies, suffered 300 percent turnover. What that means is the unit went into combat, died, was reformed, went back in, died, was reformed, went back, died, was reformed.
That's the average. Some of the assault units had 800 or 900 percent turnover.
3. Streetfighing: See below.
The biggest flaw to an MC Stalingrad, is SP itself.
It does *not* represent infantry casualities and replacement well. That's an engine flaw and is not Matrix's fault.
However, what that does is make a true Stalingrad campaign foolish. In irl, if a company goes from 100 men to 25, the next day it's at 25, maybe a few more.
In SP: That company is back to 100 5 minutes later, assuming 1 man is left per squad and most players manage that.
I'd love to see a Russian oriented MC, but there are better options with Kurks and it's counter offensive being one, and, as I've said before Operation Bagration being another. If it's gonna be the last MC, though, why not do fall '44 to April '45 - the end of the war - and for fun, toss in an option to keep driving into those other Allies!
Alex
_____________________________
"Tonight a dynasty is born." Ricky Proehl, then of the Saint Louis Rams. He was right! Go Pats! Winners of Super Bowls 36, 38 and 39.
|
Printable Version
MC Stalingrad Suggestion: - 
- 
- 
New Messages
No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages
Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages
Locked w/o New Messages
Post New Thread