HQ Support Units (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [World War II] >> Norm Koger's The Operational Art Of War III



Message

fbastos -> HQ Support Units (6/19/2006 8:04:04 AM)

Hey, I'm giving a shot in the "Barbarossa Tactical 4.1" scenario, from Piero Falotti, and I noticed that the 13th Panzer Div HQ only has 2 support units, per the screenshot below.

As such, I think that this formation is screwed for TOAW III, right? I mean, the formation has a formation supply proficiency of 100%, but because the HQ has 2 support units (and nothing more), its units will not be supplied, is that correct?

Also, the manual says:

"When you set the formation supply distribution efficiency for the formation (including use of the global change functions in the editor) the editor will automatically recalculate the proper number of support squads for all HQ units affected by the change."

so I reckon that I can go to the Editor and do a global change on all formations to have them at 100% supply proficiency... do you think that would fix that?

Regards!
F.


[image]local://upfiles/13478/E81413858B114656B629AAFC5A0CD7BB.gif[/image]



golden delicious -> RE: HQ Support Units (6/19/2006 11:55:53 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: fbastos

As such, I think that this formation is screwed for TOAW III, right? I mean, the formation has a formation supply proficiency of 100%, but because the HQ has 2 support units (and nothing more), its units will not be supplied, is that correct?


Well, they will only receive very little supply.

Took a look at the scenario. This problem does occur in several places, and the designer seems to have intended for formation supply levels to be 100% across the board. So your solution would be the best choice in this case.

I just wonder, if a scenario has this kind of major error (several key formations are affected) which has gone undetected, what other problems might be lurking elsewhere? Frankly, if you really must play Barbarossa at 10km/hex, I'd go for McBride's Drang Nach Osten.



fbastos -> RE: HQ Support Units (6/19/2006 8:44:54 PM)

Yeah, several HQs are that way... perhaps this is on purpose, given that this scenario was designed for ACOW?

I kinda love this scenario, as it has a lot of good research put into it; for example, it is the only scenario that I noticed has the Nachtigall partisans, what is a measure of the level of detail that Falloti put into it. It definitely has some shortcomings, though, like the 2nd Panzer Div should be in the Balkans on Jun-1941 rather than in the soviet front.

But all for all I would love to see this scenario working well on TOAW III.

Appreciate you looking into this, Golden, thank you.

F.



golden delicious -> RE: HQ Support Units (6/20/2006 12:54:57 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: fbastos

Yeah, several HQs are that way... perhaps this is on purpose, given that this scenario was designed for ACOW?


This feature works exactly the same way in COW. I doubt the scenario was deliberately designed this way, since the formations concerned are crippled by it.

quote:

I kinda love this scenario, as it has a lot of good research put into it; for example, it is the only scenario that I noticed has the Nachtigall partisans, what is a measure of the level of detail that Falloti put into it. It definitely has some shortcomings, though, like the 2nd Panzer Div should be in the Balkans on Jun-1941 rather than in the soviet front.


Take a look at these two cases. Which unit is more significant- and therefore more important to get right? As I said, if you want to play Barbarossa at 10km/hex, Drang Nach Osten is probably your best bet.



Pocus -> RE: HQ Support Units (6/21/2006 10:34:32 AM)

What is the bigger eastern front scenario playable against the PO? 



larryfulkerson -> RE: HQ Support Units (6/21/2006 12:51:45 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Pocus
What is the bigger eastern front scenario playable against the PO? 


There is the classic scenario Barbarosa '41. Is that the one you're thinking of?



Pocus -> RE: HQ Support Units (6/21/2006 2:27:37 PM)

Mmmh, no chances to have a scenario which can be played alone during the whole war I suppose?





Menschenfresser -> RE: HQ Support Units (6/21/2006 11:06:21 PM)

If any one's feeling spunky, they could add objectives to FitE and play as the Soviets. Then you'd have what you want.

It probably wouldn't be much of a challenge for anyone but a total noob...and given the size of the scenario, by the time winter fell, you, like your comrads, would no longer be noobs.



Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
0.625