After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [World War II] >> Uncommon Valor - Campaign for the South Pacific



Message


denisonh -> After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface (8/17/2006 4:32:15 PM)

Boston Globe
August 17, 2006
Pg. 1

After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface

By Ralph Ranalli, Globe Staff

There was no distress call, no indication of enemy depth charges exploding or bulkheads breached, just a dead silence that stretched from a few days into 60 years.

The USS Grunion disappeared in July 1942, leaving 70 American families grieving and the three sons of skipper Mannert L. ``Jim" Abele, without a father. Abele's boys -- ages 5, 9, and 12 and living in Newton when their father disappeared -- grew up and built their own lives. But, they dwelt on the fate of their father. At 2 a.m. yesterday, a grainy sonar picture e-mailed via satellite appeared in Bruce Abele's inbox, appearing to finally show what they had been searching for much of their adult lives: the outline of an oblong object believed to be the Grunion deep in frigid Alaskan waters.

If the discovery is confirmed, it would signify a triumph of luck and perseverance and put to rest a quest for clues, financed by the personal fortune of one of the Abele sons, that has spanned decades.

``It's big, very big," 76-year-old Bruce Abele, the eldest of the three sons, said yesterday. ``This mystery has been a part of my consciousness for as long as I can remember."

The Grunion, one of the Gato-class attack submarines commissioned in the early part of World War II, was on its maiden operational voyage when it disappeared while patrolling the seas between Alaska's tip and Japan, according to a Navy website.

The submarine made several transmissions in July 1942, reporting it had sunk three Japanese destroyers. On July 30, it reported heavy antisubmarine activity nearby and said it had 10 remaining torpedoes. It was never heard from again. Warplanes searching for wreckage never found any evidence of the sub's fate.

For years, the sons -- Bruce, Brad, and John, who is founder of Boston Scientific Corp. -- have pored over Navy documents, any shipping records of the area they could locate, and contacted others interested in the Grunion's fate. John Abele, a billionaire, has paid for much of the search. He declined to say how much he's spent.

The effort wasn't made any easier by the brutal seas around the Aleutian Islands, widely considered some of the most dangerous in the world, with winds that can howl at 100 miles per hour, waves taller than a house, and ocean depths of 1,800 feet and greater. Any search mission would have to know where to look, since a long scouting voyage would be dangerous and expensive.

A break came in 2002, when a Japanese man, Yutaka Iwasaki, posted a translation of an article in an obscure Japanese shipping journal on one of several websites dedicated to the Grunion. The article, written by a military officer on board an armed Japanese merchant ship, the Kano Maru, described an exchange of cannon fire and torpedoes with an American submarine in an area where the Grunion would have been patrolling.

Iwasaki's involvement changed everything, John Abele said yesterday. Not only did the brothers have a place to look for their father's submarine, but they also had newfound friends from the other side of the war. They were so inspired by the cooperation they received from Iwasaki and others in Japan that they decided to expand the search to find two Japanese sub-chasers, SC-25 and SC-27, that were sunk by the Grunion and to find the Arare, a Japanese destroyer that went down in the same area.

``This has been a very emotional thing for a lot of us," John Abele said.

After four years of research, the brothers finally decided they could make a good enough guess at probable locations to start looking, with John Abele deciding to fund the search himself.

After a discussion with renowned Titanic explorer Robert Ballard, who declined to take on the exploration, the brothers hired a Seattle ocean surveying firm, Williams and Associates. They also chartered a crab fishing boat, the Aquila, skippered by a seasoned veteran of the dangerous waters, Kale Garcia. The family is represented on the boat by Peter Lowney, a former Newton resident and crab boat crewman who is chronicling the search with a pair of high-resolution video cameras and sending back frequent updates.

The search, with sonar equipment capable of returning high-quality images, began two weeks ago. The boat traversed a grid, seeing nothing but sonar images of the ocean floor.

Then they saw on the screen a smooth, oblong object with features that could be a tower and periscope mast.

With no other submarines they know of reported sunk in the area, they concluded it must be the Grunion.

John Abele said that the brothers will fly to Alaska next week on his private jet to tour the area and meet with the survey crew. They said they will probably return to the site next year and send an unmanned, remote-control device beneath the waves to get a closer look at the object and take pictures.

Jack Green, a historian at the Naval Historical Center in Washington, D.C., said yesterday the Navy has been aware of the Abeles' quest for the Grunion. Green said the Navy rarely helps with such searches and is unlikely to aid in theirs unless the brothers provide more proof than a sonar image.

``But this is very, very exciting," he said. ``We'll be very excited to see what they come up with."

While photographs could finally solve the puzzle of what actually happened to the Grunion, John Abele said the brothers' motivations are much more personal.

``We're doing this as much from a desire for connection with my father as to learn the answer to a mystery," he said.




Mike Wethington -> RE: After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface (8/17/2006 5:59:17 PM)

Fascinating how stuff like this and the recent ruling on the Houston wreck are starting to surface in the news.

I still remember, from decades ago, the National Geographic on Return To Truk Lagoon with it's stunning photos of the sunken ships, now reefs.

I can't recall 100% but hasn't someone tried something similar to this for the Juneau and the rest of the Savo Island ships?




Moondawggie -> RE: After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface (8/17/2006 6:33:47 PM)

Excellent post! Thanks!




british exil -> RE: After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface (8/18/2006 2:15:27 PM)


Hi Mike
In response to your question about the sunkenw wrecks off of savo,
there is a book with pictures. "The Lost Ships of Guadalcanal"
It disscusses the sea battles that took place there in great detail. The mistakes that the navies made but also the problems that they faced.
Well worth reading. I think so at least.
As I live in Germany I only have an ordering number for the german copy. But if I remeber correct the author could be a Robert Ballard , he also did a book on the Bismark. sorry





Mike Wethington -> RE: After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface (8/18/2006 4:32:25 PM)

Thanks, I'll check it out via Amazon and buy locally at the best little bookstore in Texas, Bookpeople.

Didn't Balliard also find the wrecks of the Yorktown and the Hiryu off Midway recently (2 years ago?) I remember something about the USN not allowing him to publish part of his findings because they didn't want people diving on the Yorktown (apparently it wasn't torpedoed by the US DD in very deep water {under 500'}.




Mike Wethington -> RE: After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface (8/18/2006 5:05:44 PM)

More sub victims surface:

From the Narooma News (Australia) yesterday:

The Iron Knight: identity discovered
By Stan Gorton
Thursday, 17 August 2006

THE deep waters off Bermagui continue to give up some their secrets with specialist divers in recent months positively identifying the shipwreck of the Iron Knight.
While trawlers have for decades known about the shipwreck located due east off Bermagui, the Iron Knight has now been formerly declared a protected site with relatives of the lost sailors able to lay flowers at the site of sinking.

The ship was transporting iron ore and associated materials up the coast on February 8, 1943 when its convoy was attacked by a Japanese submarine with torpedoes hitting the ship.

The Iron Knight sank quickly in 125 metres of water with 36 of its 50 crew not able to escape a watery grave.

While the divers deserve the credit for identifying the shipwreck, local charter operator Keith Appleby said trawlers have for decades known of shipwrecks lying on the flat bottom that on occasion have snagged their nets.

"The divers might complain about the nets wrapped around these ships, but if it wasn't for the nets, they wouldn't know where these shipwrecks are," Mr Appleby said.

"In some cases, their fathers and grandfathers have steered clear of these wrecks."

While trawlers know of the rough location, pinning down their exact location is quite difficult with Mr Appleby taking three hours to cover a grid pattern of 0.5 nautical miles.

Mr Appleby has been called upon to take divers out to formally identify these shipwrecks and he was again on hand to take the divers out to the Iron Knight.

The Sydney project

It takes a special kind of diver to brave more than 100 metres of water to identify Australia's maritime history.

Four minutes down, 15 minutes on the wreck at 125 metres down and four hours slowly decompressing on the way up.

Among these intrepid explorers is Baghdad-born IT engineer and diver Samir Alhafith, who together with the other divers from the elite club known as the Sydney project, first dived on what was believed to be the Iron Knight on May 27.

Later when it was realised the relatives of lost sailors wanted to hold a ceremony and have the shipwreck formally protected, the Sydney Project divers planned another dive just to make sure they had the right ship.

Six bottom divers and three support divers returned and on June 18, Mr Appleby took them due east from Bermagui to just this side of 12-mile reef.

The following is how Mr Alhafith described his "perfect dive" on the Sydney Project website.

"Descending to 125 meters, on average, should take approximately six minutes, but on this day it took only four minutes.

"Landing on the bridge and remembering the layout of the fishing net from the first dive I was able to determine which way was the stern.

"I wanted to be on the stern to look for two of the three items that would tell us the identity of this wreck. Fist item was the single prop, and second was the 4-inch stern gun. The third object was the bell on the bow, and that wasn't going to be in the direction of the Stern!

"Swimming along the starboard side of the wreck towards the stern, I could see in the distance the outline of the gun and my heart started to pump a little faster.

"The stern section of the wreck is picture perfect and totally intact, with railings and a gun all standing proud. Dropping along the rudder to the single prop confirmed the two parts of the wreck we came to find. The stern was the exact shape historical records of the time depicted and there was no doubt we are on the right ship.

"Coming back up to the gun I checked my time and still had a good eight minutes, I was having the time of the my life and doing what must be one the best wreck dives in NSW waters. Swimming back along the walkway on the port side next to the massive cargo hold, I dropped into the hold and looked back towards the bridge.

"The sight is one that I will not forget for a long time, the ambient light was enough to see everything clearly, the bridge was standing high with the massive nets above it suspended by buoys, and fish in a tight ball hovering over the entire bridge, their silver body's reflecting my video lights.

"At this stage with only five minutes of bottom time left I made my way inside the bridge and for a hairy moment I got under the net into a fairly tight spot without being able to turn around, to exit you need to reverse and hope not to get caught in the dangerous embrace of the now derelict fishing net. I was searching and hoping to find a big enough passage to enter inside the lower decks.

"With too much debris blocking the way forward, I had to make the reverse out of this tight spot, and in the process silt kicked up around me, I was happy to see the clear water over and around me. Checking the time I could see only two minutes left before ascending to start the long four hours decompression.

"With water so clear I felt I had to capture the final seconds on the wreck on video, then started the long ascent up the shot line with Paul. At 85 metres I looked up and saw Dave (Apperley) at the 20-meter stop and one of our support divers on the surface.

"I nudged Paul (Garske) and told him to look up, and then I pointed below to show him that we could still see the wreck. We were in a depth where you could see both the bottom and the surface and this all in 125 meters depth! This truly was one of those spectacular dives and quite possibly the perfect dive."

Formal recognition

The Commonwealth Government on August 4 declared the wreck a protected site under the Historic Shipwrecks Act after the NSW Heritage Office deemed it worthy of protection.

State maritime archaeologist Tim Smith said office was involved throughout the dive and identification process, as well as supplying funds to assist the coming together of sailors' relatives who ventured out to the wreck site July 29 to lay wreaths for those lost at sea.

Families are being asked to compile their records and memories to allow a better interpretation of the site, Mr Smith said.

The divers also came along for the ceremony, and while they had to abort the dive due to strong currents, they were touched by the moving ceremony.

"What came next was amazing and finally we were able to meet people that gave us a real prospective of what these rusting hulks really represent," Mr Alahfith wrote of the experience.

"It finally put the human factor on them and trivial objects now meant a lot more. This is the grave of 36 brave men and we were about to hear their story. But the most spectacular encounter for us is to hear the story from the last living survivor of the sinking John Stone.

"I wanted to locate more relatives that would be interested to know that the final resting place of their loved ones has been found. With the help Margaret Masson in Newcastle we were able to find a large number of relatives. What was important for us was to give them the chance to pay their respects onsite, and everyone wanted to be there when we were to go back to the wreck on 29th July."

Merchant mariner

One person excited to hear about the identification of the Iron Knight is retired sailor Bill Beazley, who served as a merchant marine from 1949 to 1960.

Mr Beazley, who now calls Dalmeny home, spent several years working as an able seaman aboard the Iron Knight's sister ship the Iron King, which continued to transport the same cargo of iron ore, stone and coal long after World War II.

The vessel's regular run saw them steaming with their raw materials from the iron ore mines in Whyalla, South Australia to the smelters of Port Kembla and Newcastle.

The run was known as the "black and tan run" because of the colour of the material.

The sinking of the Iron Knight earned the vessel the dubious nickname of "Iron Fright" with Mr Beazley explaining the crews were always worried about getting trapped in the complex passageways and cabins.

"The quarters were like a rabbit warren, they were pretty tight," Mr Beazley said.

At 6000 or 7000 tonnes of displacement these cargo ships were a lot smaller than today's massive freighters, but the ship's heavy load of iron ore and associated materials would have seen it sink like a rock after being torpedoed, he said.

According to survivor John Stone who spoke to the ABC's Stateline program, the Iron Knight went down in two minutes allowing only 14 of the 50 crew to escape.

Other shipwrecks

The identification of the Iron Knight brings the number of known shipwrecks off the Bermagui coast to five.

Mr Appleby said the first to be dived on back on the 1990s was the Lady Darling that lies in relatively shallow water of 30 metres south of Montague Island where it hit a submerged reef.

Then there is the Bega that in 1908 sunk in 76 metres of water south of Bermagui near Bunga Head, which has also been dived on by the Sydney Project.

The Liberty ship the William Dawes lies even deeper in 135 metres southeast of Bermagui after it too was torpedoed by the Japanese.

The crew from the Sydney Project were planning to dive on this shipwreck when they changed plans to dive again on the Iron Knight to confirm its identity before the relatives' ceremony.

The last of the shipwrecks is that of the Wear that sank in 120 metres of water after a collision with another ship northeast of Montague Island.

Mr Appleby is now on the trial of another wartime victim, the Liberty ship Robert J Walker that sunk north of Batemans Bay after have the dubious distinction of being the only ship torpedoed by a German submarine off the Australian coast.

Marine archaeologists believe the ship was sunk the legendary U-862.




british exil -> RE: After Six Decades, A Submarine's Fate May Surface (8/18/2006 5:29:18 PM)

Not sure about the Hiryu. Couldn't find any info from the net,but still impressive to read about what the men did back then.
Both the Jap. and Allied troops. Hard to believe what they all went through.




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
0.609375