firepowerjohan -> RE: Super Dreadnought CV's .. (8/7/2007 11:02:15 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: targul Just did my next turn. Attacked that carrier with two fighters and two tac bombers one of which was a substantard Italian. Each of my planes lost one to three points the carrier after being bombed 4 times lost a total of 1 point. Yep I see how these land based planes perform against the carriers. Same as every game I have seen. Carriers are for sea battles. The air could support coastal hexes. But the carriers bombing past Paris and intercepting air in Germany was just not done in 1940. Now maybe the English just didnt know that there carriers where actually more powerful then land based German air but I would prefer to play the game using the equipment the way it was used instead of second guessing how valuable it should be. Again, I am politely asking you to explain how you get your results and provide some more information on unit stats or screenshots. I asked you how you got your strange 0-1 combat odds fighter vs carrier but your answer does not contain any odds but now only strange casualty examples that cannot be double checked. If there is a bug we should deal with it ASAP. I have asked around to some experienced players and they do not find any way to proof that carriers are stronger than air so if that can be shown I will be the first one to check it out. I have provided own examples of full unit stats, odds and outcome of the battles we are discussing on this topic. I do not know what else can be asked of me as support of this matter if you do not give enough data so that the results can be retried and double checked. Example: Carrier white effectiveness (72), no tech, no experience Fighter white effectiveness (83), no tech, no experience Carrier vs Figher odds 2:3 outcome Carrier lost 2 strength, figher lost 1 strength
|
|
|
|