Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [World War II] >> Uncommon Valor - Campaign for the South Pacific



Message

m5000.2006 -> Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (12/3/2007 2:18:05 AM)

hi

Does UV have something that WitP doesn't? Or does WitP include UV?

If I'm planning to buy WitP, does it make sense to buy UV too?

regards



tocaff -> RE: Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (12/3/2007 2:41:04 AM)

UV is the daddy of WITP as both use the same engine.  UV is a smaller scale (focused) and WITP is the whole enchilada.  There are features in WITP that UV doesn't have.



Canoerebel -> RE: Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (12/3/2007 4:18:20 AM)

UV covers the Solomons and Coral Sea from 5/1/42 to 12/31/43.  WitP covers the entire Pacific/Indian theaters (the campaign scenarios, that is) from 12/7/41 to 3/31/46.  (There are scenarios of more limited scope and time).  Thus, WitP is a much more massive game and takes much more time to play.  But most of us former UV players find it much more satisfying.  The scale give sthe player much more ability to create nifty strategy and to be surprised by your opponent's nifty strategy. 




Ike99 -> RE: Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (12/3/2007 6:32:41 AM)

quote:

hi

Does UV have something that WitP doesn't? Or does WitP include UV?

If I'm planning to buy WitP, does it make sense to buy UV too?

regards


Yeah, UV has fonts large enough that you donŽt get a headache after looking at them for more than 5 minutes.

UV also gives you a good chance to finish a game, in this decade.

WITP is more like work than anything. Save some money and get UV. YouŽll get more enjoyment out of it. WITP is a game that I believe is more admired than actually played.





Mart777 -> RE: Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (12/3/2007 11:57:35 PM)

I would have to agree with Ike99 on this, I too own both. The only draw back of UV being the fact that once you experience the added features of WITP you wish you had them in UV.

Which game I would recommend if really pushed would be WITP, with UV you miss the extra control. UV is a game you can play for a few hours, WITP is more of a major commitment.

The ultimate experience is and will always be WITP against another human player. The issues around time required to play can be nullified if you PBEM anyway. WITP is without doubt the better game but really it all comes down to player commitment, you get out what you put in.

Now my confession, I play UV more than WITP it fits better in to the time I can commit to play. I don't keep track of my orders or note down ideas for attacks or movement of forces so when I return to WITP I often find myself lost and restart. Playing the shorter scenarios is the solution to my problem but if you got the whole Pacific War you want to play the whole Pacific War.

Take from this what you will, seems like the ramblings of an idiot to me, the better game is WITP but don't buy it just to fill a corner of your hard drive. Play it and you will be rewarded with years of enjoyment.[;)]





Ike99 -> RE: Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (12/4/2007 1:02:07 AM)

quote:

Now my confession, I play UV more than WITP it fits better in to the time I can commit to play. I don't keep track of my orders or note down ideas for attacks or movement of forces so when I return to WITP I often find myself lost and restart.


Well there you have it m5000.2006.

You can buy a game for $30 that youŽll actually play and finish.

OR

Spend $75 for another that 99.9% chance you wonŽt do either. [:D][:D][:D]

But really. DonŽt believe if you buy UV youŽll be let down or something because you wonŽt. Honestly I think you should try UV first anyways to see if you even like the game and itŽs engine. If you do, then IŽd take the plunge into WITP.



Nomad -> RE: Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (12/4/2007 4:12:16 AM)

I am playing both games. I like UV because of its size and scale. It is much easier and as pointed out, you can finish a game where in WitP you would probably be about one forth of the way through a game. UV stands on its own very well and is an interesting game to play. I too find WitP to be work at times. Lots of work.



BB56 -> RE: Uncommon Valor vs War in the Pacific (12/5/2007 7:06:37 PM)

I started on UV and moved to WITP after it came out and have finshed 2 games against the Japanese AI and have started a 3rd.   I'm also going to go back to playing UV, just for a change of pace.

So, I'd buy UV first and if you like it but want more, then buy WITP.  Just my 2 cents worth.



Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
1.515625