For the Mods - a wish

For the Mods - a wish (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [World War II] >> War In The Pacific - Struggle Against Japan 1941 - 1945 >> After Action Reports

Message

vettim89 -> For the Mods - a wish (7/17/2008 10:50:18 PM)
To the moderators, If ever there comes a time to update the forums software a very nice and perhaps needed enhancement would be to give the owner of an AAR the ability to delete posts from his AAR. Some times AAR's get hijacked and if the owner of the AAR felt it was too far off topic and did not contribute to the narrative being told, it would be nice to have the ability to delete it. Many contributions from other posters provide valuable insight as to what is going on and have great relavance to the campaign and how its unfolding. Unfortunately I have also seen threads that have digressed into non-game related subjects, debates on important subjects that just don't beling in an AAR, and sometimes personal feuds. It would be nice as the owner to be able to clean up our AAR's if we so desired. For the record, I have not had this happen in my own AAR but have seen it in others that I follow closely

whippleofd -> RE: For the Mods - a wish (7/17/2008 10:59:43 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: vettim89 To the moderators, If ever there comes a time to update the forums software a very nice and perhaps needed enhancement would be to give the owner of an AAR the ability to delete posts from his AAR. Some times AAR's get hijacked and if the owner of the AAR felt it was too far off topic and did not contribute to the narrative being told, it would be nice to have the ability to delete it. Many contributions from other posters provide valuable insight as to what is going on and have great relavance to the campaign and how its unfolding. Unfortunately I have also seen threads that have digressed into non-game related subjects, debates on important subjects that just don't beling in an AAR, and sometimes personal feuds. It would be nice as the owner to be able to clean up our AAR's if we so desired. For the record, I have not had this happen in my own AAR but have seen it in others that I follow closely Second! Whipple

Nemo121 -> RE: For the Mods - a wish (7/17/2008 11:18:07 PM)
I think that smacks too much of censorship. I wouldn't agree with everything that is posted to various AARs BUT I think that increasing the ability to censor others' thoughts is too high a price to pay to stop such off-topic posts.... particularly as people's ideas of what is and isn't on-topic do vary. I know the specific exampe you are talking about but I still think the general point over-rides that specific instance. Freedom of speech is too important to chip away at it like this IMO.

Nixuebrig -> RE: For the Mods - a wish (7/17/2008 11:46:21 PM)
I guess to highjack a thread, two persons are needed. Just ignore the posts that don`t fit or give a polite hint that it is not on the topic. If nobody jumps on it, it will be short lived (the highjacking).

VSWG -> RE: For the Mods - a wish (7/17/2008 11:46:30 PM)
I agree with Nemo. First step should be that the AAR writer asks all participants to stop their discussions. If that doesn't work (I bet in most cases it will) he can still contact a mod and ask him to censor or delete the posts.

vettim89 -> RE: For the Mods - a wish (7/18/2008 3:54:59 AM)
My thinking is we have some AAR's that are 30,40,50 even 100 plus pages. Even if you allowed an author to go back say after 10 days and tidy up, it would make it easier for those readers looking at the AAR for the first time to follow the flow better

jwilkerson -> RE: For the Mods - a wish (7/18/2008 5:22:19 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: vettim89 To the moderators, If ever there comes a time to update the forums software a very nice and perhaps needed enhancement would be to give the owner of an AAR the ability to delete posts from his AAR. Some times AAR's get hijacked and if the owner of the AAR felt it was too far off topic and did not contribute to the narrative being told, it would be nice to have the ability to delete it. Many contributions from other posters provide valuable insight as to what is going on and have great relavance to the campaign and how its unfolding. Unfortunately I have also seen threads that have digressed into non-game related subjects, debates on important subjects that just don't beling in an AAR, and sometimes personal feuds. It would be nice as the owner to be able to clean up our AAR's if we so desired. For the record, I have not had this happen in my own AAR but have seen it in others that I follow closely I have intervened in AARs greater than zero times, upon request. But I will say that it causes about as many problems as it solves. Deletion tends to increase the perpetrators resolve to disrupt the AAR, non-deletion tends to accelerate the resignation of the owner to quit the game, or at least to abandon the AAR. In my experience, the situations requiring moderator intervention are rare. And rare enough that they need to be handled as exceptions rather than as rules. If any AAR owner feels that there is objectionable intrusion in his AAR - let me know and I will suppport. I do defintely agree with the concept that an AAE belongs to the owner of that AAR - and persons who persistantly disrupt an AAR are defintely not welcome. Joe

Bogo Mil -> RE: For the Mods - a wish (7/18/2008 6:55:54 PM)
If you delete posts, but not all replies to them, it becomes even more confusing to the reader. I agree that deleting posts is usually not a good idea. Maybe you could give the "owner" of the AAR an option to ban certain users from posting any replies. But this would certainly be quite complicated to implement. I don't think the strain is large enough to justify the effort.

whippleofd -> RE: For the Mods - a wish (7/18/2008 7:27:04 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: jwilkerson quote: ORIGINAL: vettim89 To the moderators, If ever there comes a time to update the forums software a very nice and perhaps needed enhancement would be to give the owner of an AAR the ability to delete posts from his AAR. Some times AAR's get hijacked and if the owner of the AAR felt it was too far off topic and did not contribute to the narrative being told, it would be nice to have the ability to delete it. Many contributions from other posters provide valuable insight as to what is going on and have great relavance to the campaign and how its unfolding. Unfortunately I have also seen threads that have digressed into non-game related subjects, debates on important subjects that just don't beling in an AAR, and sometimes personal feuds. It would be nice as the owner to be able to clean up our AAR's if we so desired. For the record, I have not had this happen in my own AAR but have seen it in others that I follow closely I have intervened in AARs greater than zero times, upon request. But I will say that it causes about as many problems as it solves. Deletion tends to increase the perpetrators resolve to disrupt the AAR, non-deletion tends to accelerate the resignation of the owner to quit the game, or at least to abandon the AAR. In my experience, the situations requiring moderator intervention are rare. And rare enough that they need to be handled as exceptions rather than as rules. If any AAR owner feels that there is objectionable intrusion in his AAR - let me know and I will suppport. I do defintely agree with the concept that an AAE belongs to the owner of that AAR - and persons who persistantly disrupt an AAR are defintely not welcome. Joe Can't ask for better support than that! Whipple

Page: [1]

Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI

0.953125