undercovergeek -> RE: Turn 85 - 02/03/1942 (2/9/2010 12:35:52 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Q-Ball Very Interesting AAR! I would have stuck with Pearl and not abandoned it. Once you commit that many forces to that ambitious an objective, you have to go all-in. Not doing so is a dispersion of effort. You needed more engineers, but over time, I think you could have done it. The loss of all those ground units at Pearl would be almost as bad a loss as the port itself for the Allies. But if you must move on, the only thing you can do is to try and create a killing zone situation; sooner or later the Allies will have to get some ships in there, be ready to make some kills. But I predict that the Allies can do this using CV support, if they are willing to sacrifice some transports, which they should be. It will take a long time, but once he gets supplies and fresh air units to Pearl, he can pummell all your bases into submission and take them all back. Having the Allies expend effort in Hawaii isn't a bad thing, but on the flip side you sacrificed progress in other areas for the sake of Hawaii. Hey Q-Ball glad youre still here! I wanted Pearl to be a smash and grab - i think it has to be. Unload overwhelming numbers, take the place, garrison and leave - the SoPac 'schedule' is so busy i havent got the time for a war of attrition here, it would have been weeks more to get more combat engineers and im still terrified of the fearsome AV adjustments i suffered - 2500 down to 950 while Yanks went from 750 to 4000!!! What were combat engineers going to do with this?
|
|
|
|