RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (Full Version)

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition >> After Action Reports



Message


FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 5:58:30 PM)

August 28-September 1, 1942

Looks like Allies have finally run out of planes in Andamans. By my reckoning, USN/Marines and Canadians should still have reserves, but either there are no available squadrons around, or bigred is reluctant to commit them.

Just about time, as in September Allies get a new burst of replacements, with P-40K entering service. My airforce is quite exhausted already, and my attempts to avoid throwing planes into costly sweeps mostly did not work. Night bombing was rarely effective, and naval bombardments have failed to target airfields.

Otherwise, not much news. A few more Allied transports were sunk by subs around Andamans. I'm successfuly pushing Allies around Canton with a limited force, as bigred still didn't realized the perils of spreading his forces out. I mentioned to him that this is a big mistake, but Chinese still are scattered into several small stacks there... Japaese aviation is bombing Chungking's light industry, but damage accumulates rather slowly. At least it does accumulate, unlike Pearl Harbor, where flak prevented my planes from hitting LI, so I was forced to resort to firebombing.

More in the oncoming monthly report...




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 6:09:49 PM)

Victory Screen at the Beginning of September.

The extent of Allies' army losses is quite imressive, thanks to the carnage in China and destroyed island garrizons at Kona/Lahaina/Trinkat. This is still my main source of VPs, even though since the Battle of Ceilon my points for sunk Allied ships also are fairly impressive. The overall score is only about 2.4:1, though, with no real hope for auto-victory even if I try. I've failed to seize any truly major bases outside of the standard Japanese perimeter so far, and huge air losses also impact the picture.



[image]local://upfiles/33131/9B00CFF7DB7743E99100541DE76FAEDF.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 6:19:03 PM)

Andamans

With Allied aviation seemingly beaten back, and most of the Combined Fleet in place, I'm contemplating proceeding with the invasion of Port Blair in near future. I have 4 full divisions (15th, 33th, 55th, 56th) and elements that amount to about a division more, with strong artillery, 14th Army HQ and Southern Army HQ. Not all troops have 100% preparation though, and probably won't have enough sealift to drop them all in one go. More importantly, with two Allied divisions in place this might be not enough to dislodge the defenders. I hope to make my air successes lasting by knocking Allied airfields, and then soften the defenders by bombing.

Lack of air superiority made me postpone the invasion of Grear Nicobar for now, but it is still on the table as well.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/1514E2D6D03E4F628E68B8100D92C6D9.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 7:26:59 PM)

Southern Pacific Perimeter.

No real action here, but considerable additions to the Japanese defensive line. Tabiteuea-Beru base complex is fairly developed now, and shortly its airfields will be at the max normal size. Forts are level 3 on both islands. Meanwhile, I'm about to drop an Air HQ and a bunch of engineers on Nauru. It's flanked by my other holdings (with search assets available), and therefore is very unlikely to be targeted for a swift surprise invasion in foreseeable future. It's also limited to 30k troops, making it easy to defend late in the game and has passable airfield potential. Betties and Franceses flying from there can reach most places in Gilberts and Marshalls, without eating group limits on the airfields in the immediate vicinity of ongoing invasion, on which my fighters will be based. And of course it covers the ocean stretch between Gilbers and Solomons. A fairly good place for a major airbase, I think. With initial Japanese possessions in Marshalls already well-fortified, I also want to build up Makin and Abemama later, as more air support and engineer units become available, and call it a day.

One might wonder why I'm paying attention to the strategic backwater? Well, it's clear from the recent events, as well as base buildup, that Allies are still paying considerable attention to South Pacific. With all the dot bases here, they don't really need carrier support to advance, if the Allied player puts his mind to it. Whatever islands I choose for my defensive line, they'll be in P-40K/Wildcat range from the next island Allies might build up. While the ideal situation for me will be Allies continuing their attempts to push from Indian direction, as this makes Japanese logistics vastly simpler, and the region is getting better fortified day by day, I can't expect from my opponent to oblige me forever. So, even though the region is sort of a strategic dead end for Allies, after the destruction of their 1942 carrier fleet, there is no point in allowing them to move here on cheap.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/CD312A0E81044DB9BF2641346ECC0AF0.jpg[/image]




crsutton -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 7:59:59 PM)

Looking at your screen shot? What are the blue and red numbers over each dot? Is that air superiorty? Is that a mod or is it in stock?





FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 8:48:03 PM)

That's port/airfield potential of a hex. I'm using the enhanced game map from here:

http://www.matrixgames.com/forums/tm.asp?m=2189709

It's compatible with stock.




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 8:55:59 PM)

Aleutians.

Unlike South Pacific, here Allied defences seem weak. The last recon of Umnak found only 7 units. Allies have no significant air presence, and it looks like a squadron of Wildcats shipped into the region was sunk by one of my subs on the route. Adak is now a powerful base, and I intend to launch an invasion of Umnak as soon as my shipping and KB-2 regroup at Lahaina. A modest combat force of 2 older CAs and 6 DDs is assigned to northern waters, and a Kokutai of Betties patrols the region. More air units can be brought from Home Islands of course. Ideally, I want to take all bases up to Cold Bay, before possibly sendig my infantry back south to storm Oahu, but I'm not sure if this is possible before cold weather hits. Preparation is the problem here

[image]local://upfiles/33131/F4F20F291C1B4E249476D9613EB1969C.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 9:13:56 PM)

Detailed Air Losses.

I forgot to take the screenshot on the first day of the month...

Anyway, as you can see, losses are quite mindblowing. In one month, Allies have lost 696 planes and Japanese 668. Ki-43 losses alone reached 204 aircraft. This has to put a hole in Allied air force. It certainly did in Japanese one, with the help of my misplanning of production. Thankfully, the first major batch of wartime-trained IJN fighter pilots just qualified from units in Home Islands, so now I can be a little bit bolder at using IJN fighters.

Things could have been way worse, but Allies weren't determined enough to concentrate their key assets, primarily 4E bombers and Lightnings, in Burma-Andamans theatre and using them to hit my aviation and shut down airfields by sustained effort. The situation at Trinkat still started to really deteriorate once, but bigred helped me by spreading his 4E efforts among different targets.

I'm somewhat disappointed with Tojo performance. Hopefully it will perform better once I can mass sufficient numbers of them, instead of deploying a little more than chutai's strength in any single combat, at most, but so far they haven't really scored better than old Ki-43s.


[image]local://upfiles/33131/DD73BC5D63074495B6B8EA8470329117.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 9:31:51 PM)

Ace List and Pilot Losses.

I lost almost 300(!) of my pilots this month. I have well over 1000 pilots in on-map training program at the moment, though. In conjunction with putting units in quiet theatres on training, I believe I can sustain losses like this, as long as most of them fall on relatively rapidly trained contingents, like IJAAF fighter pilots - the conclusion that surprised myself once I did the math. Gradual disappearance of the pre-war/early war veteran core that prevents losses from rising even higher is a bigger problem. A few units, like 54th and 59th Sentais, now have very few pilots that aren't recent graduates from the training program. I'm pretty sure, that Allies have lost far, far less pilots, due to fighting over their airfields, if nothing else, and I'm afraid that they are building up the quality of their veteran core, instead.


[image]local://upfiles/33131/1E3499EC48104DEAB4C2504EBFAE3CB0.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 10:32:12 PM)

Industry.

Resource and supply situation is stable. Fuel/oil still declining. I wasn't able to keep the battleline in harbors at all - this result, at least, my bigred was able to achieve. The situation makes me again contemplating leaving Hawaii and Aleutians to Allies and defending within a more compact perimeter. If not right now, then after destroying those garrizons I can.

Of course, an alternate solution will be shutting down some HI. I'm running with a large surplus, as you can see. And can free even more, by reducing armaments production further.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/7E8C68C0B81B44AC9B4E85EB10069567.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 10:49:53 PM)

Aircraft Production.

Ki-49-IIa finally entered service. At last, a decently protected bomber. It is quite competitive with contemporary Allied types, slightly worse Mitchells, but better than many others. And at this time I still can outproduce Allies. One plant will continue making Ki-21, as to avoid even sharper engine crisis, primarily.

I shut down the production of carrier attack planes. I don't foresee extreme losses that will necessitate a bigger reserve. And D4Y/B6N are not that far away now. Of course, I'll restart production if the pools will become too thin.

H8K1 and A6M2 are the next candidates for a pause in production. I'll wait until I have 50 of H8K1s, then will stop the factory, and hopefully this reserve will last until H8K2's availability. As about A6M2, I plan to start upgrading more units to A6M3b soon enough, and this should create a surplus.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/C699549453FA4E6387637B13F0EF53A8.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 10:58:54 PM)

Engine Production.

I failed to order the expansion of Nakajima Ha-34 plant in time. But, thankfully, Mitshubishi Ha-45 just became available, so I repurposed one of the plants that just switched from research to production, and now it will help to mitigate the imminent shortage.

While I'm at it, I must not forget to expand the production of Mitshubishi Ha-33 by about 100 units before 1943. A6M4 and Dinah III are going to demand this engine.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/E8EF298464F44E098016955DCA5635D5.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 11:28:42 PM)

Aircraft Research.

Well, a lot of changes here, unfortunately for me. You see, I finally got to actually testing performance of late-war planes in Downfall. The results condemned many of my earlier research decisions.

1)First, all Japanese 2E fighters built around big guns happened to suck as bomber destroyers. Ki-83 was the only 2E fighter to perform on par with 4x20mm 1E fighters against heavy bomber menace. And they are more expensive as well! So, my hope of using Ki-102b as a late-war protector of the homeland proved to be illusory, prompting rearranging of priorities.

2)Then, advanced late-war nightfigters demonstrated practically no difference in performance compared to everything else. In fact, against B-29s all of the were equally ineffectual. As a result, I decided - taking into account, that IJNAF gets a considerable number of dedicated night fighter units, and IJAAF gets very few - to cancel most of nightfigter research in favor of concentrating on A6M8-S Zero, which at least is cheaper, can actually catch B-29 (for the off-chance this can do some good) and can be used as a day fighter in a pinch. IJAAF retained one factory researching Ki-45 KAId, that will eventually produce this fighter to fill the few units that can accept it. I'll get a some Ki-46-III KAI with arriving units, so if the latter, against expectations, proves to be meaningfully different (in the direction of greater efficiency), I'll just switch production. At least Ki-45 KAId has 2x20mm cannons in addition to the 37mm abomination, so maybe it will be able to shot down something.

3)A7M3-J proved to be rather ineffective. Well, not strictly ineffective, it simply doesn't consistently do better than 4x20mm armed fighters against Allied bombers. I canceled its research. Considering that the number of barrels apparently trump the calibre with the current devices stats, I should concentrate on bringing A7M3 (6x20mm) if I want to prevail against 4E horde.

4)Ki-61 family did surprisingly well, certainly better than their stats suggested to me. So - considering that its pinnacle upgrade boasts 4x20mm in Scen 70 (making its crippling service rating somewhat justified) - I'm going to put some effort into accelerating its successive models, in hope of using them as bomber interceptors.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/B6FA1CF540E349458C3E63A9F0CDD41D.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/1/2011 11:31:59 PM)

Ship Production.

Musashi finally left the docks. A big relief. I was even forced to temporarily halt Ikoma (again) recently, to avoid naval shipbuilding points shortage. I remain committed to accelerating Unryus, though.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/366E72EDDDDC4A1FB83AF4E71463E1B8.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/6/2011 7:24:59 PM)

September 2-8, 1942


The Failure of Air Campaign Against Andamans: Long story short, I don't have nearly enough bombers to inflict significant damage on both main Allied airfields in one day (heavy flak presence that forces my bombers to 25k complicates things), Allied plane losses on ground are dropped to miniscule proportions now, possibly due to removal of group overstacking, and even against weak returning CAP my losses skyrocket every time I try to send bombers - mainly losses among escorting airgroups. Night bombing is nothing more than nuisance, even though large formations of Sallies and Helens - on relatively rare days when any night attackers sortie - can pretty much ignore older Allied fighters that fly night CAP there.

Considering that from September on Allied airforce will become progressively stronger, there is not much point in continuing. I'll only bleed myself. This also means that my attritional approach entirely failed, and I should have just parked carriers between Andamans and Ceilon to prevent any resupply from the beginning.

In better news, I forgot one more division prepared for Port Blair. Overall I have 12th, 21th, 33rd, 55th, 56th, 40th Brigade, a couple of engineer and arty units. Well, this seems more promising. Allies seem to have much less troops at Port Blair than at Little Andaman, and Indian troops or 1st Burma Division should inferior to US forces. Not enough AKs to lift them all at once, though. All Japanese battleships but Fuso and Hyuga are present at the theatre, so I can but a bunch of heavy hitters in the invasion force itself. All CVs from the Big Six, except Zuikaku, plus Zuiho are available for cover. I'm mainly waiting for repairs on Hiryu to finish, preparation is near 100% for all of the core units.

Hopefully, this will force some reaction out of my opponent. The wisest thing for him will be to turtle and to trust in terrain and fortifications, but while Yubari almost certainly would take such course of action, I doubt that bigred will be similarly prudent.


On The Other Side of the Pacific: The invasion force has sailed for Umnak Island. Three divisions might be an overkill, but I've learned to dread the defensive power of US forces in good terrain during the Hawaian campaign. Unfortunately, I committed another oversight, not properly reconning bases past Umnak. I could have parceled some forces for them. Now, if they gave strong garrizons, I might be forced to invade with underprepared troops, to take them before the start of winter in November. I'm moving a Dinah unit to Adak, to rectify this mistake.

Alternatively, I might pull away from the region just before winter and be satisfied with destruction of the modest amount of Allied troops, ships and planes, in return for a couple of Japanese xAKs and auxilaries sunk in the campaign. This will mean leaving Allies built-up Adak. But it's not like this will be meaningful, considering their construction capabilities by the time the invasion through Aleutians will be a possibility. On the negative side, this will significantly increase Allied sub threat, this is the main argument against for me. On the positive side, less extended and more logistically sound perimeter. In fact, it's logistical difficulties, primarily fuel expenditure, that made me rather disenchanted about the idea of extending the perimeter to Aleutians and Hawaii. If not for the hope of taking Pearl, that Allies won't be able to relieve for many more months now, in early 1943, after the defenders are out of supply, and destroying a ton of units there, I would have pulled the forces to the "standard" perimeter by now.




BigBadWolf -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/7/2011 11:38:45 PM)

I was looking at your shipyard plans and I was wondering isn't it better to accelerate those three improved Shokakus to 1942, when you can really do some damage with them, instead of Unryus to 1943?




John 3rd -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/8/2011 1:22:52 AM)

I bring the 3rd Sho-Kai forward so I get #2 and #3 together in early-mid 1942. Getting those Unryu's up into 1943 would only help to strengthen the Japanese hand for the 'decisive' battle!




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/8/2011 11:41:21 AM)

Allied carrier fleet is incapable of contesting even the present Japanese force until well into 1943 anyway. I simply don't need more carriers in 1942. They will only serve to guzzle more fuel. My offensive operations at the moment are (severely) limited by logistical difficulties (i.e., dwindling oil/fuel stockpiles, and getting fuel across the Pacific) and deficit of ground troops, rather than by carrier airpower. It's not like I intend to assault San Francisco or Ceilon, probably the only places where even one of KBs can meet sufficient LBA resistance. Well, making a raid on Ceilon to kill Allied shipping and cut the supply line to Andamans in its source, is tempting, theoretically I now have plenty time to retrain my carrier squadrons even after large losses... but I guess this plan contradicts my standard principle of KB preservation to proceed with it. And port attacks by carrier planes so far were quite underwhelming in this game, so, even after seeing examples to the contrary, I don't want to gamble with my elite aircrews.




BigBadWolf -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/8/2011 1:40:10 PM)

I was thinking about an idea I had few days ago and your situation seems perfect for its implementation. It is doable, I'm just not sure if it's worth the trouble. How's your pool of trained naval pilots? Dump all of your carrier elite ( exp >70, primary skill >70) to reserve, fill carriers with trained pilots and let them run amok around India for a month or so. Attack shipping, ports, fly sweeps over enemy bases, the whole shebang. You will burn a lot of fuel and will probably lose a lot of planes and pilots, but those who survive should be on par with the best you have right now. And you will cause a lot of grief to your opponent.

anyway, just a thought..




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/11/2011 3:45:20 PM)

I'm not having enough time for regular updates at the moment, but...

Autumn Offensive in China

Is not proceeding smoothly. Wuchow was taken by the Japanese vanguard, but almost all industry there got destroyed, and I failed to demolish most of Chinese forces in the south while they were on open plan. I've dropped 3rd and 4th Raiding Regiments on Liuchow, seeing as Chinese have only 2 units there. The initial attack came at 3:1 and reduced forts to 0, but the second attack failed. Seeing as 3 days were not enough for Chinese reinforcements to arrive, I should have rested my paratroopers on the second day... I'm not going to lose these regiments, as fragments remained at Canton, and they were of mediocre experience to begin with, but a considerable number of squads and devices will be lost for nothing.

Events around Liuchow revealed, that there are a lot of Chinese forces around the western end of their MRL. Breaking through them directly might be quite problematic. So, it's time to adjust the plans. My armored spearhead, reinforced by an infantry division and some lesser unit will attack to the west of Wuchow, to clear weak Chinese forces across the river and pull bigred's attention to the west. Meanwhile my main force, which you can see on the map, will push directly to the north from Kukong. There are only 2 recently-trashed units in the forest hex on the northern road from Kukong, and after that the terrain will be increasingly advantageous for Japanese. There is a huge Chinese army around Changsha, up to 40 units, so they will undoubtely reinforce the center once my movement is spotted. I'll try to make the initial push with a limited force and to make some misdirectionary attacks south of Changsha, to make bigred keep guessing. The most diffuicult part will be river crossing into the base hex... but I hope Japanese aviation will be able to seriously disrupt any Chinese stack fighting in the open.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/FB26CCC7A48141F0B5E77F51C43F8E23.jpg[/image]




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/11/2011 3:52:58 PM)

Research Note

Ki-44-IIb accelerated to 5/43 at some time before 11.09. Well, it looks like the acceleration is proceeding reliably. I'm thinking about switching the research to Ki-44-IIc once Ki-44-IIb advances to 4/43. I want to try IIb too, at least it has centerline 12.7mm guns (instead of wing-mounted ones on IIa), but what I really want is IIc, so once there is no danger of running into the sometimes-postulated inability of accelerating a plane before its preceding model in the upgrade tree, I'll try switching research factories to it.




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/12/2011 1:37:01 PM)

A Small Update

Liuchow fell to paratroopers after all. They might not be able to resist Chinese reinforcements, though.

I launched some more day air raids against Little Andaman, to hurt Allied aviation a bit more before the Port Blair invasion which will commence in a few days. Also, I hoped bigred grew complacent after my aviation backed off. He did. I managed to destroy almost a dozen planes on ground without opposition first and then exchange fighters 2:1. Tojos now did better. Hurricanes suffer from the lack of top speed against them. A sufficient gap here makes evading attacks much easier.

Bigred is serious about taking Port Hedland, bringing more armor to bear. Not enough to get sufficient odds (lack of supply hurts Allies there), but enough to inflict greater casualties on the defenders. I thought carefully about whether I want to commit reinforcements to this battle, and decided that I don't. In fact, I'll probably evacuate more than fragments from units there, to preserve experienced squads. Andamans and far Pacific pin down too much of my forces for a serious effort in Australia right now, and I see just reinforcing Hedland well enough to kick out the current attacking force as too perilous, without naval commitment. And soon enough Japanese will get a bunch of garrizon and construction units, that will be sent to Eastern DEI before Allies can do anything serious from Australia. I hope for the Andamans situation to resolve as well by that time.




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/13/2011 6:59:11 PM)

Up to September 16, 1942

Aleutians: Umnak Island is invaded, we're going to overrun the garrizon within the next 2-3 turns, and so on. A big xAP was lost to CD guns and a fast AO to a sub attack, suddenly making the whole operation quite costly. I'm going to use the current presence of KB-2 to stage the evacuation of Aleutians after Americans on Umnak surrender.

China: Liuchow held against the first Chinese assault, somehow.

Andamans: The first wave of the Port Blair invasion (I can't lift all the troops) has loaded at Georgetown and about to sail into battle, covered by 2/3rds of the Combined Fleet.

Flying Fortresses tried to hit Trinkat again, but over two days were repulsed with outright loss of 9 planes to about 8 Japanese fighters in the air and on ground. Flak took down 4 of the attackers. I have 88 medium flak guns on Trinkat, including 4 100mm and 24 88mm, and looks like they are doing a good job.




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/13/2011 7:14:33 PM)

On abandoning Aleutians...

If anyone remembers, initally I wanted Aleutians to deny Allies forward sub bases. But after witnessing what E-class ships can do, and observing the effectiveness of air ASW I decided that they are not worth the bother, unless I can take the whole island chain. And I can't. Or at least it will be too expensive. I also don't have enough ground forces to garrizon the entire region properly, or to maintain a serious air campaign. So, I won't hold onto Aleutians, but will use the freed forces to reinforce Curiles, half of which are already nicely fortified, and to start building up Ryukyus.




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/13/2011 9:06:49 PM)

Also, BigBadWold, I thought about your idea, and I might proceed with it later, depending on how the events unfold. For now carrier airgroups are needed to safeguard the repeated landings at Port Blair. Allies are already moving on Burma and I must storm the island fast.

On Air Attrition

The most successful for Japanese daily air combat result in September so far amounted to 16-20 Allied fighters shot down. At the moment, I need to destroy 10 per day just to take care of their reinforcements. Just doesn't seem possible (without hurting my airforce worse), unless bigred takes the bait and gets his squadrons squashed against KB-1.

That's without taking into account Allied 4Es, which obviously are a big factor. Bigred so far has failed to deploy them in a decisive manner (i.e., with 50 or more planes in a raid, repeatedly hitting the key airfields), yet they are more successful than most of Allied fighters at destroying my planes... Neither bombing them back nor flak concentration really neutralizes this menace, only mitigates it somewhat at best.




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/14/2011 11:13:18 AM)

September 16-17, 1942

Aleutians: Umnak Island fell after the second attack:

Ground combat at Umnak Island (169,51)

Japanese Deliberate attack
Attacking force 30580 troops, 416 guns, 164 vehicles, Assault Value = 1101
Defending force 6477 troops, 291 guns, 138 vehicles, Assault Value = 128
Japanese engineers reduce fortifications to 2
Japanese adjusted assault: 1105
Allied adjusted defense: 217
Japanese assault odds: 5 to 1 (fort level 2)
Japanese forces CAPTURE Umnak Island !!!

Allied aircraft
no flights

Allied aircraft losses
No Allied losses

Combat modifiers
Defender: terrain(+), forts(+), leaders(-), experience(-)
Attacker: disruption(-)

Japanese ground losses:
938 casualties reported
Squads: 8 destroyed, 56 disabled
Non Combat: 2 destroyed, 41 disabled
Engineers: 1 destroyed, 16 disabled
Guns lost 4 (1 destroyed, 3 disabled)

Allied ground losses:
6552 casualties reported
Squads: 162 destroyed, 0 disabled
Non Combat: 625 destroyed, 0 disabled
Engineers: 0 destroyed, 0 disabled
Guns lost 305 (305 destroyed, 0 disabled)
Vehicles lost 139 (139 destroyed, 0 disabled)
Units destroyed 7

Assaulting units:
16th Division
38th Division
18th Division
25th Army
23rd Medium Field Artillery Regiment

Defending units:
58th (Sep) Infantry Regiment
1/153rd Infantry Battalion
206th Coast AA Regiment
30th Coast AA Regiment
5th Marine Defense Battalion
154th FA Bn Field Artillery Battalion
31st Aviation Base Force

Hopefully, not all of the Allied units had fragments pulled (KB-2 fighters managed to intercept and shot down a couple of transport Catalinas over Umnak), but either way, that's a decent number of squads and devices gone.

However, despite clear superiority and preparation of over 70%, three divisions that executed the assault took considerable losses and are heavily disabled. Any further operations with them are out of question for several weeks, so, even though certain Allied bases west of Umnak look like ripe targets for conquest, I still believe it's the time to reload the troops and get hell out of dodge.

A number of Allied fighters and divebombers was destroyed for very little Zero losses, when they tried supporting Allied troops on Umnak. While strategically inconsequential, this is still good.


Andamans: The Japanese armada is about to land at Port Blair. Andamans are bristling with fighters, but I'm bringing about 300 land-bases fighters of my own to support the operation, by flying sweeps and LRCAP, and escorting bombers that will strike Allied airfields, so air superiority should be mine. I'm a bit concerned that the initial wave does not include enough infantry, but rough terrain should help them in case Allies try to counterattack the landing force.




janh -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/15/2011 9:26:29 AM)

Nice job with Unmak.  Probably the divs could still handle an island or two more up in the chain, though you better reconned them first. 

On the other hand, staying there is not quite so important as long as you dominate the central pacific, and you might as well rest them and think about the Pearl operation.  I believe taking Pearl is still vital to making the Hawai'ian chain an unsinkable carrier, and the losses might be well worth it.

Same for the Adamans.  Perhaps those divisions should be first used in a well focused efforts there, and then the whole force be send back to Hawai'i.  Takes a lot of time, but at this stage you have the initiative and time, and there is little more important to do with those assets.  By the time BigRed will have the naval assets to commit to a new amphibious operation against you, whether in the Kuriles, whether Hawai'i, or in SEPac, or by the time he could mount another offensive against Adamans or Burma, your LCU and LBA will have gone through a full rest and refit and be ready again.

I think now is your best chance to trade losses for gains at a good ratio.  And any place you can take and make a island-fortress will gain you lots of time in the long haul.  Hawaii, Adamans, Line Islands, Noumea are all very suitable to create big headaches for the allies if secured by good LCUs, LBA and built up with air, port, fort and supplies. Those are places the allies must take back to secure vital convoy routes, and avoid having to detach large escorts against sub and surface raiders or bombers. 








FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/15/2011 12:12:26 PM)

I don't think it is possible to go for another island without demolishing troops during the landing so much, that they will take at least half a year of total rest to recover[:(]. Disablements during low-preparation langing are monstrous when the amphibious bonus is not a factor. Even troops with preparation of over 50% can sometimes be half-disabled during unloading, as I learned when playing as Allies...

And I want these division to take Pearl later. For the same reason I'm not hauling them across the Pacific. I already burned more than enough fuel for Christmas and Umnak adventures.


Anyway...

September 18, 1942: Port Blair, We've Returned!

Andamans: The first wave at Port Blair has unloaded in one day, without ship losses. DD Hagikaze was rammed by my sole remaining LSD when dodging a PT boat and is out of action, one more DD and two AKs were damaged by coastal guns. Japanese sank 4 PT boats and the Dutch sub O19. The preparation naval bombardment was relatively effective and helped Japanese LBA to dominate the air battle that raged for most of the day. Bigred has learned from Allied aviation's misadventures at Aleuitians and launched no air attacks. Perhaps he learned a wrong lesson, though, as I feared skibombing 4Es, which did not materialize. So, carrier aviation took a very little part in the ensuing brutal fighting, which, nevertheless, ended in a costly Japanese victory. I've lost one of my premier aces today, but two more pilots have achieved the ace status in return. Bombers pushed through and plastered the airfield, at least.

[image]local://upfiles/33131/51022E988C134EC2AC82D4BDA2F2BA4C.jpg[/image]

Fire exchange revealed a large, but manageable Allied force at Port Blair. I fear forts might be at level 5-6, but with 6 divisions and ample artillery (which might require 3 landing waves, alas) Japanese should be able to crack this nut.

Ground combat at Port Blair (46,58)
Allied Bombardment attack
Attacking force 16745 troops, 242 guns, 169 vehicles, Assault Value = 857
Defending force 21141 troops, 324 guns, 272 vehicles, Assault Value = 720

Japanese ground losses:
19 casualties reported
Squads: 0 destroyed, 2 disabled
Non Combat: 0 destroyed, 0 disabled
Engineers: 0 destroyed, 0 disabled

Allied ground losses:
32 casualties reported
Squads: 1 destroyed, 0 disabled
Non Combat: 0 destroyed, 3 disabled
Engineers: 0 destroyed, 0 disabled

Assaulting units:
16th Light Cavalry Regiment
3rd Indian Coastal Artillery Regiment
39th Indian Division
7th Armoured Brigade
17th Indian Division
1st Madras Construction Battalion
2nd Ceylon H AA Regiment
8th Medium Regiment
Burma Corps
1st Bombay Construction Battalion
RAF 221 Group Wing
RAF 222 Group Wing
6th Medium Regiment
24th Indian Construction Battalion
221 Group RAF
Pathan Construction Battalion
22nd Light AA Regiment
RAF 221 Group Base Force /1

Defending units:
56th Div /8
40th Bde /5
27th Electric Engr Rgt /2
Southern Army /5
2nd FA Rgt /3
18th Medium FA Rgt /1
15th Ind.Art.Mortar Bn /1
3rd Medium FA Rgt /2
2nd Ind.Hvy.Art. Bn /2
1st Medium FA Rgt /2

7th Armoured Brigade worries me a bit. Indian divisions should not be as much of a problem, though, as they really lack firepower compared to Americans. First-line Japanese divisions are armed way better. Compared to the initial post-landing bombardment at Lahaina I see 20% less guns and only half as many vehicles on the enemy side, so, considering that my force at Port Blair, once it is concentrated, will be considerably bigger and better supported, I think victory can be achieved within a reasonable timeframe.


Aleutians: Another AO was sunk by a sub attack! Good thing I have some fast tankers capable of AO conversion accelerated...

Liberators tried to hit Umnak, but this time Zeros from KB-2 did a good job against them.




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/19/2011 10:03:54 PM)

September 19-24, 1942

Andamans: During preparation of the second wave's landing at Port Blair we had a couple of successful air engagements. B-17s have tried to bomb Georgetown, but KB-1 CAP tore them a new one, with over 15 losses in a day for no hits. Then I launched another large air attack at Port Blair, and Allied CAP did not fly that day, so about a dozen of Allied planes were destroyed on ground without loss. The biggest battle took place on 24th, as the invasion convoy started to approach. Losses for the day are 110 Allied planes for 54 Japanese (this time Allies tried to launch a few strikes, but although an element of Beauforts made it to Shokaku, they only dropped bombs and missed). Massed strikes with a great number of units with a few days of rest between them appear more effective than trying to keep up the pressure by rotating sweeping units...

The Japanese fleet still took a couple of hits, though. On 23th my TF that covered Trinkat somehow reacted to the north of Little Andaman, for no particular reason... maybe Admiral Nishimura subconsciously longed to repeat his real-world ill fate. It got attacked by Allied air, with destroyers heavily strafed by Airacobras (this amounted to relatively light Sys damage) and Yamato getting a torpedo hit from a Beaufort. However, all the torpedo did was 4 non-major flotation damage. Well, can't say there is no RL precedent for that... On 24th one of S-subs put a torpedo into Akagi, this time causing 30 Flot, while a Dutch sub missed Soryu. Well, that's why I was reluctant to send carriers there...

We'll be landing the second wave on the next day, hopefully. Allied artillery bombards Japanese positions around Port Blair every day, but my troops somehow got forts right after the landing, and they have a decent number of heavy tubes, so the fire duel was one-sided in my favor, for once. I'm starting to appreciate post-patch artillery a bit more... too bad that Japanese do not really get any heavy artillery units besides those they start with. In fact, it should be noted, that while their late-war ground reinforcements are fairly numerous, starting from about November of 1943, their firepower, with a few exceptions, is horrible. JFBs should treasure those first-line divisions and heavy howitzer regiments they start with.


Aleutians: Hiyo got damaged by a single sub torpedo, but damage was very minor... Othwerwise evacuation proceeds without loss. KB-2s fighters managed to put more hurt on Liberators that tried to pretend they are invincible, albeit not without cost.


China: Chinese took Liuchow back. I admit, I was way too complacent there. I should have an unrestricted brigade ready to be airlifted to Liuchow... I didn't, and, for once, Japanese were forced to run from Chinese. Defeated units retreated in the southern direction, so they should reach Japanese lines without problem.

Meanwhile, my breakthrough in the center proceeds as planned. Chinese won't be able to contain my force in the rough terrain. I've read recently that you really must take Chinese MRL from Changsha to Nanning, to get fuel and resources flowing overland from Indochina... Don't know if it is true, but certainly I'm in the position to try.


On Troop Evacuation
I just realized that it works in a really stupid way. First you need to order your patrol boat/transport unit to transport some troops from the base they are sitting in. And only then the "Pick Up Troops" options appear, allowing you to perform air evacuation from endangered bases, without putting your air units in the harm's way...




FatR -> RE: Ocean of Blood. FatR (J) vs. yubari (A) - no yubari, please. (2/20/2011 9:40:49 AM)

September 25, 1942

Andamans: A lot of sub attacks this day, including a dud hit on Shokaku. No actual damage, though. Landing went reasonably well, although the amphibious TF will need to stay for another day, so this might easily change. And minesweepers, included in it, get shot to pieces in a separate combat, when they tried to sweep mines, despite having a ton of surface combatants in the same TF. Two of them will likely sink. It really looks like one is better off deploying his DMS stictly defensively.

Allied aviation took a break. Japanese 2E bombers hit the airfield at Port Blair again, but destroyed only a handful of planes.

I-122 was ran over by an Allied convoy near Madras and sunk, but managed to torpedo a xAK after being forced to the surface.


Burma: 7th Indian Division appeared at Schwebo, and Chinese tried to storm Lashio, which is held by a Thai division and three tank regiments. Against level 4 forts they failed, but I didn't enjoy seeing over 60 Allied 2E bombers trying to support them, even though they failed to hit anything in the jungle.


Eastern DEI: Port Hedland was finally overran, just as my fast transport evacuation TF was passing Timor...




Page: <<   < prev  13 14 [15] 16 17   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
2.1875