Rocket attacks? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Gary Grigsby's Eagle Day to Bombing the Reich



Message

ool -> Rocket attacks? (7/26/2010 2:29:38 AM)

Just about to begin BTR. Question came to mind in regards to a flaw in the original BTR. Namely German twin engined fighters attacking with rockets were erroneously subjected to defensive fire from the B17's. Reading the records of these attacks the German fighters would launch from outside .50 cal range. Therefore they would avoid defensive fire from the bombers. Has this been corrected in this version?

Also can anyone suggest a plan for engine/parts production paths for German fighter development and existing production?

Thanks in advance for any replies.



Erkki -> RE: Rocket attacks? (7/26/2010 1:53:31 PM)

I think so. Sometimes, only sometimes, they take some returning fire(I think), but nearly always just single damaged ones.



Derfel -> RE: Rocket attacks? (7/26/2010 6:24:09 PM)

The production plan depends on what you want to acheive and how fast.

I have tried to hit a balance with fighter vs. fighter- and fighter vs. bomber-production.

The Ta152C is a good choice for fighter vs. fighter, as it has a good mobility in the high altitudes, good weapons and a decent manauverability and durability.

A good fighter vs. bomber can be the Go229, but be prepared to invest a LOT of engines and time to get it operational. A solution is to keep the Me110R2/R3 in production. and keep it out of harms way :)



ool -> RE: Rocket attacks? (8/3/2010 5:03:34 PM)

Any of the development team going to give me a definitive answer to my question about the error re: twin engined Luftwaffe getting defensive fire while launching their rocket attacks?



Rob Brennan UK -> RE: Rocket attacks? (8/3/2010 6:18:24 PM)

Initial rocket attacks are (in my experience) immune to defensive fire, after the initial attack, smaller groups 'might' close to fire rockets and be subject to defense fire but their attacks seem to be a lot harder hitting.

Hope this helps

EDIT -- It's not just the 2E ones, the 1E FW Sturm units and 190F/G have an identical attack profile. Even if you set them to bounce over direct attack they will shoot rockets on approach.



Hard Sarge -> RE: Rocket attacks? (8/3/2010 7:16:33 PM)

sorry first time I seen the post

from what I understand, the rocket attack is not just a rocket attack, it is also the gun run following the firing of the rockets

also, where have you ever seen they were able to just lob the rockets in with out taking return fire, the 110 jockys hated the things (also that was the idea with the 50mm armmed models, you had to get too close to fire the 20mm/30mm's and the 110's were getting a little long in the tooth by then)



Rob Brennan UK -> RE: Rocket attacks? (8/3/2010 10:50:17 PM)

hi HS

I consistently see a unit firing rockets and taking no return damage at all, ok that doesnt mean that there is no return fire just very little effect. let me give an imagined example.

1) 30 410's approach an allied 4E heavy raid.
2) They 'seem' to launch rockets before the 'squares' quite merge, giving the impression that its a long range attack.
3) against a bomber box of say 20 planes then 20 410's launch leaving 10 still with ordinance.
4) 5 heavies are damaged and then 5 410's seem to peel off and attack again with rockets and then usually cannons.
5) at some later stage measured in game minutes the remaining 5 will launch rockets again and will definately recieve return fire with about 50% damaged and occasionally one going down in flames. In return for a 'usually' better attack than the initial 20 planes. thus giving the impression its closer range and more accurate for both sides.

I can't recall ever seeing a cannon run immediately after an initial rocket attack ,even on direct bomber. There are usually several other actions inbetween the rocket and cannon attacks.

this is ofc just my impresion.

TTFN











ool -> RE: Rocket attacks? (8/4/2010 8:46:36 PM)

Actually it is a deadly catch 22 situation that the Germans used to employ. If the box of B17's kept tightly together to max defensive fire power the twin engined fighters would launch rockets well outside .50 cal range. To avoid rockets the box would loosen and the distance between bombers would greatly increase to allow maneuverability to avoid the rockets. If this happened the single engine fighters high above would bounce the scattered B17's. So the bomber jocks were caught between the devil and the deep blue sea. Rockets or 109's/190's while scattered. Either way after the choice had been made and the rockets launched and the single fighters went in would the twin engined rocket launching planes go in. Source Adolf Galland's First and the Last. As well as excerpts from the Leftwaffe Diaries.



Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
1.859375