German medium tank shortage

German medium tank shortage (Full Version)

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Gary Grigsby's War in the East Series

Message

jay102 -> German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 6:49:35 AM)
Turn 4 in game, I decided let the panzer corps to rest and refit. I noticed some of them only has about 50%-70% TOE strength in medium tanks category. I checked the pool which is empty of medium tanks, with a production of 14 panzer IIIj/L42 per turn(the only type in production). With this number it takes a long time to fill the requirements. Is this WAD? Should I use those half strength panzer divisions to continue push forward?

Smirfy -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 9:31:07 AM)
The campaign was going to be over in six weeks ;)

Pawsy -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 9:34:48 AM)
Push forward now <signs order for jay102 dismissal>

karonagames -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 9:34:50 AM)
I'm trying to find the specific reference in the developers forum, but I think it was Trey (el Hefe) who had a source that said 79 new tanks made their way to front line units in the first 6 months of Barbarossa.

vinnie71 -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 9:43:12 AM)
Off the top of my head, the Germans were celebrating the production of 100 tanks a month in early '42 while the Russians were already producing 10 times as much. So great was the discrepancy. Also keep in mind that from these 100 new formations had to be raised and reinforcements sent to Rommel...

pensfanvw -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 10:11:55 AM)
Don't mean to hijack this thread, but I've seen the term WAD used in this and other posts. What is WAD? Al

XAAL. -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 10:13:52 AM)
WAD = Work As Designed.

pensfanvw -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 10:16:22 AM)
Ahh... Thanks XAAL. Al

jomni -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 11:02:30 AM)
I'm playing the Soviets in my Grand Campaign and I can't seem to kill a lot of German tanks. Maybe OP is too aggressive?

Grouchy -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 11:15:05 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Offworlder Off the top of my head, the Germans were celebrating the production of 100 tanks a month in early '42 while the Russians were already producing 10 times as much. So great was the discrepancy. Also keep in mind that from these 100 new formations had to be raised and reinforcements sent to Rommel... Well they produced somewhat more, take for instance the production numbers of Nov'41: PzII: 40 Pz38: 50 PzIII: 206 PzIV: 52

Grouchy -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 11:26:00 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: jay102 Turn 4 in game, I decided let the panzer corps to rest and refit. I noticed some of them only has about 50%-70% TOE strength in medium tanks category. I checked the pool which is empty of medium tanks, with a production of 14 panzer IIIj/L42 per turn(the only type in production). With this number it takes a long time to fill the requirements. Is this WAD? Should I use those half strength panzer divisions to continue push forward? If you think that's bad, then you probally really looking out for the 1941 winter. Here a report of the status of the panzers on the eastern front in feb 1942: 340 operational 1139 repairable 305 total losses 582 replacements

vinnie71 -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 12:05:46 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Grouchy quote: ORIGINAL: Offworlder Off the top of my head, the Germans were celebrating the production of 100 tanks a month in early '42 while the Russians were already producing 10 times as much. So great was the discrepancy. Also keep in mind that from these 100 new formations had to be raised and reinforcements sent to Rommel... Well they produced somewhat more, take for instance the production numbers of Nov'41: PzII: 40 Pz38: 50 PzIII: 206 PzIV: 52 Should have qualified my statement - I was referring to Pz IVs. Pz III got reclassified as lights pretty early in the campaign

MechFO -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 2:01:00 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: jay102 Turn 4 in game, I decided let the panzer corps to rest and refit. I noticed some of them only has about 50%-70% TOE strength in medium tanks category. I checked the pool which is empty of medium tanks, with a production of 14 panzer IIIj/L42 per turn(the only type in production). With this number it takes a long time to fill the requirements. Is this WAD? Should I use those half strength panzer divisions to continue push forward? This seems to be WAD. AFV that are damaged due to movement seem to be handled identically to AFV's damaged from combat. So just by moving your PzDiv's you are steadily losing tanks. I'm in turn 16 now and had 60-70 AFV's destroyed last turn just because I moved half dozen Pz Div's close to their max MP's. This is with low supply and of rail MP's of about 30.

Great_Ajax -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 2:07:51 PM)
Production does not mean that these units make it to the front. Many of these new tanks were being used to build new units in France and Germany and replacements of all types were very slow in getting to the East until the Spring of 42. The Germans had enough of a problem trying to get basic supplies, ammo, and fuel to the front lines with the swindling rolling stock and trucks and across primitive roads, much less brand new tanks. Trey

MechFO -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 2:14:43 PM)
As I understand it, the rebuilding plus the requirements of other fronts is accounted for by the production modifier being 85%(for 41). So max total built that's possible should be: capacity x number of turns in production (when factories are in supply) x modifier. The waters are further muddied by the fact that repaired elements also seem to get count in the "built" column. At least that's the only reason I can come up with why elements are showing up as "built" even though they are not in production. So it doesn't seem to be really possible to count how many were actually built in the factory and how many were damaged elements that got repaired.

Klydon -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 3:25:05 PM)
The German production numbers are fairly chaotic as the factories often counted rebuilds as new production. Panzer IV production was very low for the first several years of the war because it was considered a "support tank" to the panzer III. Only upon meeting the T-34 and KV-1 did the Germans have a "oh s**t" moment and started looking at alternatives. Remember the Panzer IV started the campaign with the short 75. After the winter during the spring mud, the Germans had about a panzer divisions worth of tanks (less than 200) available for employment on the entire Eastern Front. That they got as many tanks made available for operations by the time of the summer offensive is fairly remarkable. I believe they invaded with around 3300 tanks and started the summer offensive with about the same number (over 3000), but the big difference was there were far fewer panzer II's. Hitler had a meeting with the AGC generals the first part of August in part to discuss plans of diverting PG 2 and 3. Both Guderian and Hoth reported their panzer strength at around 50% of ToE and the biggest issue was tank engines. Hitler mentioned that 400 engines would be sent to the front. Guderian objected since he could have used 400 engines alone. Hitler mentioned that engine production was needed for new tank production and new formations. There was a note about not raising new formations and just sending anything produced to the front as replacements as suggested by Halder. Hitler, ever interested in numbers, shot this down when it was probably the right thing to do.

dwesolick -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 3:25:30 PM)
Yep, and it doesn't seem to get much better as time goes on. I'm in April 42 and my pool of medium tanks is zero (or 1 or 2) in every category. Fortunately most of my pzdivs are in pretty good shape, though none at full TOE. However, on the bright side, I do have around 3 million (give or take) FW-190s!![;)]

Montbrun -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 4:07:19 PM)
At this time, the "mittler" Panzer-Kompanien were only authorized 10 x Pz.IVs (KStN 1175 - 2 x Platoons of 4 Pz.IVs each + 2 x Pz.IVs and 5 x Pz.IIs in the HQ Platoon). That would be a total of 20 x Pz.IVs per 2-battalion Panzer-Regiment. This didn't change until early-1943, when all Pz.IIIs and Pz.IVs were redesignated as "mittler," and all Panzer Companies in the Panzer Divisions were reclassified as "mittler." I don't think this is reflected in the Panzer Division ToEs in the game (ie we show too many Pz.IVs in the Panzer Division ToEs until January, 1943), so, if production is close to historical for 1941-early 1943, it's going to appear that there is a shortage of Pz.IVs, or the shortages will appear to be worse than they really were. Brad

Grouchy -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 4:24:41 PM)
Think you made a mistake, a 'mittlere panzerkompanie'� K.St.N 1175 v. 1.11.1941 is authorized to have 14 PzKpfwIV's: Kp. Tr. 2x PzKpfwIV le. Zug 4x PzKpfwII 1. Zug 4x PzKpfwIV 2. Zug 4x PzKpfwIV 3. Zug 4x PzKpfwIV And you can find another one back in K.St. N. 1178 v. 1.2.1941 (staffel einer panzer-abteilung). Not all units did recieve the necessary panzers (or were authorized by orders) to establish that 3.zug.

Montbrun -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 5:44:48 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Grouchy Think you made a mistake, a 'mittlere panzerkompanie'� K.St.N 1175 v. 1.11.1941 is authorized to have 14 PzKpfwIV's: Kp. Tr. 2x PzKpfwIV le. Zug 4x PzKpfwII 1. Zug 4x PzKpfwIV 2. Zug 4x PzKpfwIV 3. Zug 4x PzKpfwIV And you can find another one back in K.St. N. 1178 v. 1.2.1941 (staffel einer panzer-abteilung). Not all units did recieve the necessary panzers (or were authorized by orders) to establish that 3.zug. No mistake - there's a notation for KStN 1175, that there will be no third platoon without special authorization. Field returns verify this. You're also using a KStN dated later than the relevent one. Brad

sross -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 6:57:02 PM)
On a side note, I was looking in the production area for the Axis and did not see PzIVG or H listed. Maybe I missed them?

ComradeP -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 7:07:33 PM)
They're part of the Panzer IV upgrade tree, equipment that's part of an upgrade tree isn't listed, only the equipment in that tree that's currently being produced.

sross -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 7:56:58 PM)
Figured it was something like that. Thanks.

Grouchy -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 7:58:41 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Brad Hunter No mistake - there's a notation for KStN 1175, that there will be no third platoon without special authorization. Field returns verify this. You're also using a KStN dated later than the relevent one. Brad Ahaa checked it, the KStN 1175 (Sd) v 1.2.1941 which authorized theoretically for 14 PzKpfwIV's. Although no unit was authorized to form the 3.Zug or issued the 4 PzKpfwIV's needed for it in 1941.

Montbrun -> RE: German medium tank shortage (12/31/2010 8:48:08 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Grouchy quote: ORIGINAL: Brad Hunter No mistake - there's a notation for KStN 1175, that there will be no third platoon without special authorization. Field returns verify this. You're also using a KStN dated later than the relevent one. Brad Ahaa checked it, the KStN 1175 (Sd) v 1.2.1941 which authorized theoretically for 14 PzKpfwIV's. Although no unit was authorized to form the 3.Zug or issued the 4 PzKpfwIV's needed for it in 1941. Exactly! the KStN dated 02/01/41 is the one that was in effect on 06/22/41. Brad

Page: [1]

Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI

1.71875