Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI

Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (Full Version)

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Brother against Brother: The Drawing of the Sword

Message

gwgardner -> Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/1/2015 9:23:35 PM)
Brother Against Brother The break of dawn, August 10, 1861. Thirteen thousand Missouri and Arkansas militiamen - green and ill-equipped, but determined - were encamped along Wilson's Creek, about 12 miles southwest of Springfield, Missouri. Whatever calm and quiet that could possibly have reigned where so many infantry, cavalry, and artillery-men were stirring that morn, was soon to be shattered. The Battle of Wilson's Creek was at hand. [image]local://upfiles/20372/2F9485327E6E4927B929776E2427439C.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/1/2015 9:51:42 PM)
In this After Action Report I will be playing the Wilson's Creek standard scenario. There are more than 20 battle scenarios available to play in Brother Against Brother but I chose this one because it was such an interesting early war clash - sometimes called the Bull Run of the West. Close to six thousand Union troops, including militia from Missouri, Kansas, and Iowa, and some regular army companies under Brig. General Nathaniel Lyon attempted a Manassas type pincer movement against the encampment of 13,000 Missouri and Arkansas State Guard commanded by Major General Sterling Price. The outcome of the battle placed southwest Missouri firmly in Rebel hands for the rest of the war. Here are the scenario options I've chosen: Difficulty '1st Lietenant'. I could have chosen any level from Corporal to Full General, with the higher ranks giving the AI progressively more advantages in cohesion, morale, aggressiveness, and likelihood of executing orders as given. I have the 'end turn activation rule' off. See the manual for more information on this, but it has to do with when the player gets notification that a specific brigade is not able to follow orders that turn (not activated). I personally kind of like to know sooner rather than later. (Now in actuality, difficulty levels below Lt. Colonel don't have such failed activations!) [image]local://upfiles/20372/02B96AE4A09D4B338637457A2DA9F74A.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/1/2015 10:05:39 PM)
My Order of Battle Note that the color bars next to a Division are correlated with the optional appearance of unit colors on the map. This OOB is clickable - taking the player right to the unit on the map. It also can be expanded to give even more information. [image]local://upfiles/20372/E9BB4EADF21C44C291C06F1E8D5639A3.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/1/2015 10:18:33 PM)
Starting positions for my forces north of the Confederate encampment: Well, for the Confederates also, since the existence of the Reb camps along Wilson Creek were generally known. The Union forces did not know the Reb dispositions in detail, but in general. Note the mini-map on these battleground map segments - the lighter highlighted portion of the minimap is centered around which portion of the overall map is being viewed. Note also that I'm displaying the counter or icon view of my forces. This can be easily alternated with the sprite view as will be shown many times later. [image]local://upfiles/20372/A38CF84CAB4A43CBACC5C48090CCA949.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/1/2015 10:22:10 PM)
Brig General Franz Sigel commanded the portion of my force to the south that is attempting to flank the Rebel encampment, and throw heavy lead in there to disrupt the Confederates while they are struck simultaneously by the larger part of my forces to the north. [image]local://upfiles/20372/2501EE46BF154941A14249283D8887F4.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/1/2015 10:27:28 PM)
Here is shown the sprite view of the same general southern portion of the starting positions. Using the 'v' hotkey or by clicking on the units icon on the map, the player can instantly switch between the sprites and the unit icons. The sprites are great for immersion, allowing the player to witness changes of formations and so on, while the icons are often useful to get a quick overall view of things. The player can zoom smoothly for larger or smaller icons and sprites, using the mouse wheel or the zoom hotkeys ctrl + or -. I've zoomed way in here, just to show it can be done. Normally I play more zoomed out, getting a bigger view of the map and the sprites do look even better a bit more zoomed out. I quite like these at this level though. [image]local://upfiles/20372/C425581E21A94CAA885F446D1AEC3525.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/2/2015 3:31:57 PM)
5:00 AM Northern brigades: It's still dark, so visibility is very limited. I know I have approached to within rather close proximity to the enemy encampment in the north, so I'm not going to advance down the main roads anymore until light. I send out my two cavalry units to scout farther down the main roads, but they too can see only a few yards in the dark. No sight of even enemy pickets so far. Sigel's Brigade: Here too it's a matter of waiting for the daylight. I have my artillery situated on high ground overlooking what should be the Rebel encampment. (see previous screenshot for Sigel's position.) [image]local://upfiles/20372/79DFE5A484C64BFE9B1195876B79B533.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/2/2015 6:46:10 PM)
7:00 AM (Time advances more quickly per turn at night. During the daylight, each turn will be 20 minutes.) Daylight makes a big difference. Confederate forces are visible, although not yet identifiable by type, both north and south. All my brigades are currently operating under 'Advance' brigade orders, meaning they can use their full movement allowance, but not approach closer than four hexes (300 yards) to an enemy unit. I will probe with my cavalry, hoping to identify what we're up against with these forward units, then determine how to move up with my main force. [image]local://upfiles/20372/B1840FC92A5145279A5861BCD5CA99F1.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/2/2015 10:07:29 PM)
7:20 My scouts have identified the forward Rebel forces as cavalry pickets. I've moved two brigades up as fast as they can march and put some of them in line, hoping to drive those cavalry off quickly. In addition I sent a ranger company farther south to scout things out. They have spotted Rebel infantry moving up. The Confederate encampment has become a hornet's nest. [image]local://upfiles/20372/11DC6E3C1AD0423EAFCE060EF8E0FB38.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/2/2015 10:11:32 PM)
Anyone not awake by now will have been rudely startled by the bark of Backof's Artillery, in Sigel's brigade down south. First casualties of the battle - Confederate cavalry who happened to have been picketed just in range of the guns. Sigel has committed a blunder, however. He's personally advanced too far beyond his infantry columns, and they're not coming up as quickly as he had wanted. They're out of command range now, and he may have to head back to organize their push forward. [image]local://upfiles/20372/6D1C3262294C4572AE59C3A314113DED.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 3:53:31 AM)
7:40 Since my rangers spotted Reb infantry moving out of camp towards the north, I've decided to send 1st Brigade up onto the hill in front of my current position, while 4th and 2nd Brigades continue to pressure the Reb cavalry to exit the premises. On the southern flank of the Reb position, Gen Sigel has joined his infantry and directed a movement along the road to the west. I appears that the Rebels have pulled back out of the field just to the north of Backof's battery. [image]local://upfiles/20372/DF4ECE17D99548CF8A7DF198F628406A.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 4:12:01 AM)
8:00 Sigel's Brigade continues to move into a better position flanking the Rebs. Backof's artillery battery succeeded in laying waste to a group of Reb supply wagons before they could move away. In the north, 4th Brigade has opened up from its position on the hill to the west of the Reb cavalry, but 1st and 2nd Brigades are mired in low terrain giving them poor vantage to attack the enemy. [note the smoke along the ridge of the hill, where 2nd Brigade has opened up with heavy fire] [image]local://upfiles/20372/EE8991C1A69D4D3383D4617A51B6EA9A.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 4:34:46 AM)
8:20 The Reb cavalry in the north has taken significant casualties (see screenshot for totals thus far), but is not pulling back quickly. It is doing quite well in buying time for the Confederates to organize a counterattack, or at least to setup a defensive line. Sigel's Brigade pushes north, with the southern flank of the enemy no longer in sight. Backof's battery has limbered and will join the rest of the brigade. [image]local://upfiles/20372/74522CC3A4904309A2DA69C22045F1C1.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 4:46:15 AM)
On the northern flank: [image]local://upfiles/20372/2829780F911744F29DE82B3D00440F7A.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 3:36:30 PM)
My poor generalship is no doubt already beginning to color the thoughts of my subordinates. Even I can see some serious problems with my positions on the field. Especially Blair's 3rd Brigade, which took the eastern-most road against the Reb cavalry pickets. See the screenshot, where the small white circles with target crosshairs show my line of sight from Blair's position. Not good. Note also more Reb cavalry attempting to flank Blair's position on the east. I'm going to give 'Withdraw' orders for Blair, let him escape back across the little creek while still maintaining a fighting stance. Then I have the option of holding him there to guard the flank or pull him around to the high ground in reserve. [image]local://upfiles/20372/49BC53B1661F4EAF9C56BB5C86E8C285.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 5:07:02 PM)
9:00 AM In the last half hour or so, the Conf cavalry screen has finally shattered or withdrawn, but now their infantry is pushing hard on my eastern flank, where Blair's brigade is attempting to withdraw to better ground. In the south, Gen. Sigel is working hard to get his entire brigade into proper command and control, and probing north. All he's seen so far are some Conf cavalry. [image]local://upfiles/20372/E9037C1C858A43C6A56D574040E4497F.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 5:18:53 PM)
Here's a portion of the latest turn battle report as a small example of the kind of info available for players who want all the details. Reports are available on individual fire actions, end turn summaries and totals, accumulated detail reports for the last five turns, and game history graphs. [image]local://upfiles/20372/54660B711A7D4572BAD69C6DC1E79EC4.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 5:27:36 PM)
I admit to not being much of a detail-oriented player, so I opt for the simpler on-map casualty report available with a simple click on the casualties icon toggle. The large blue and red numbers show casualties for that regiment for this turn only. [image]local://upfiles/20372/4EFD1C623BAF4548996C1F1BED55AAD2.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/3/2015 5:28:27 PM)
9:40 The Confederates continue to move units into position south and east of the high ground, where my forces are firmly in control. Long-range firing continues, but little damage done overall. One side or the other is going to have to make an advance. The pesky Conf McCowan's Cavalry has fled in panic north of my lines. That's troublesome, but by all indications they are in no shape to fight right now. (right-clicking on an identified enemy unit brings up info on it) [image]local://upfiles/20372/7A2A830779EE4918BC7DC98492796762.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/4/2015 1:17:04 AM)
Gen Sigel has finally gotten his entire brigade north of Terrell's Creek. He will now advance quickly (I hope) to again harass the enemy's southern flank. [image]local://upfiles/20372/02D9F42E740A4B5BA19E05403A22F787.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/4/2015 4:20:32 AM)
10:00 Things are heating up as six regiments of Reb infantry are moving against my hilltop position. I had withdrawn Blair's Brigade but now it looks like an opportunity to flank the northern end of the Reb attack. [image]local://upfiles/20372/A61240D1760343AD88DC1668D03E2E51.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/4/2015 4:26:25 AM)
Sigel's Brigade is approaching a cavalry screen guarding the southern approach to the Reb position. They will have to be driven off before Sigel can attempt a crossing of the creek. [image]local://upfiles/20372/9F7775CE633A41368F8553CADDF2CF42.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/4/2015 2:40:51 PM)
The flank attack I'm contemplating seems right to me. See the screenshot, where the limit of 3rd (Blair's) Brigade line of sight shows that neither side is aware of the other in terms of visibility. [This is of course a situation where a table-top general can do what no real general could. I already ordered 3rd Brigade to withdraw. It did so partially. Is it too far-fetched to think that General Lyon, in overall command, seeing the development of the Rebel assault, would countermand his previous order, and push Blair forward? Well, I'm going to do what I sometimes do in games, cast the dice. Even, the order goes out to advance. Odd, Lyon was not able to get the countermand through in time. Bummer, odds it is. So no surprise flank attack.] [image]local://upfiles/20372/0F496C1636F1470EBC4D01C85D3C0BFE.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/4/2015 3:30:23 PM)
10:20 Sigels Brigade is deploying against some Reb infantry (just arrived to guard the creek crossing) and the cavalry that has been watching Sigel's approach for the last hour. [image]local://upfiles/20372/839AA382AB4648538FB5FEB46816AC36.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/4/2015 3:38:12 PM)
On and around what is now called 'Bloody Hill,' the fierce fighting continues. [image]local://upfiles/20372/67416ABA6EF2412B8B472B2375ABF368.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/4/2015 4:05:45 PM)
11:00 AM [image]local://upfiles/20372/14E89451AEAA4966B163C8C7187B1536.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/4/2015 4:06:34 PM)
The southern flank: [image]local://upfiles/20372/5B3D66EEAE1349D0B095FCD25CBDBC70.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/5/2015 4:03:21 AM)
11:20 [image]local://upfiles/20372/0A2E808C301341088D1B633433ACED1D.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/5/2015 4:05:42 AM)
12:00 Zooming all the way out we can now see the entire battlefield as of noon. Ominously, one of my supply wagon trains is empty now of ammunition and ordinance. The other is down by more than half. When both are empty, it is going to come down to ammo on hand for each unit. [image]local://upfiles/20372/E442046E3D6641118213CE9DB8B3295A.jpg[/image]

gwgardner -> RE: Wilson's Creek AAR, Union player vs Conf AI (4/5/2015 4:40:25 AM)
12:40 On the northern and western flank of the Reb force, Union forces are in occupation critical ground commanding the area (the 'victory hexes' designated in this scenario). With supplies running low, and the troops having been on the march and advancing since dawn, Gen Lyon has ordered a defensive stance. If the Rebs can mount a major push, the Union force may even be unable to sustain a defense. Blair's brigade was to have come forward to throw new weight into the line, and one regiment and a battery have done so, but another has to hold back to guard against marauding Reb cavalry. [image]local://upfiles/20372/0CC7BDA83255425E95D21D0BC1611943.jpg[/image]

Page: [1] 2 next > >>

Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI

2.71875