OK, really daft refit question (Full Version)

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Gary Grigsby's War in the East Series



Message

MishaTX -> OK, really daft refit question (8/13/2015 6:40:55 AM)

So I've read a lot of AARs, and I've read the entire refit section of the manual, all one or two paragraphs of it, but I still don't get the game logic of withdrawing refitting units all the way to Germany or Poland as it seems to me, from what I can find in the manual, that they refit just as well in a friendly rail hex just behind the front.

I know my old eyes must be missing something, but it seems to me that I'm just burning rail points by sending them to Berlin on leave instead (although I'm sure that REAL troops would appreciate the difference).



heliodorus04 -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/13/2015 8:18:36 AM)

Better minds than mine will correct me if I'm wrong, but if I remember right, the distance from front is optimal at 10 hexes or more (and maximized at 10 with no benefit from being in Berlin versus say 11 hexes. Key point also is that you want to be on a rail hex to optimize).

Going into refit while on a front line next to an enemy does very little good compared to the above conditions.



morvael -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/13/2015 8:23:02 AM)

Maybe you mean people withdrawing units to occupied Poland/Germany during First Winter to protect them from morale loss?



Gabriel B. -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/13/2015 9:07:50 AM)

It does, but even that is not the best choice .

select a big city behind the front (it will shield 2 mobile divisions from blizzard ) and in the spring your rail lines would be free to transport infantry, not armor that takes up a lot of rail capacity.

the map has also a lot of built up areas with population >= 4. Use them , at most you will lose 1-2 morale points garisoning them.



MishaTX -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/13/2015 5:21:05 PM)

More than 10 hexes? I must have missed that in the manual too but, then again, that is quite likely with me [;)]

And you're right, morvael, that makes more sense. They were most likely going for a twofer. Refit AND "anti-freeze".

Thanks all. Saved the Reichsbahn a lot of wear and tear there [:)]



MishaTX -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/25/2015 5:45:06 AM)

Another question re: refit: So if I'm reading the manual right, there are absolutely no penalties to placing a formation on Refit (by penalties I mean lower CV, MP, etc) compared to just leaving it as "ready"? Of course excepting the fact that it'll be sucking replacements that would otherwise have gone to another formation.



Blubel -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/25/2015 8:19:13 AM)

Yes. Only problem ist, you can't set it on reserve at the same time.



morvael -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/25/2015 8:28:11 AM)

Slower fort building.
No bonus during replacements if adjacent to enemy.
...so on the frontlines it's useless.



MishaTX -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/25/2015 6:04:26 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: morvael

Slower fort building.
No bonus during replacements if adjacent to enemy.
...so on the frontlines it's useless.


As it should be, thanks. But I don't need to be paranoid about putting a formation on Refit, thinking that I've rendered it useless for a turn in case I suddenly need it for something other than sitting around. I can still use it if I have to, only now the Refit status won't help it (nor should it. Hard to R&R if you're locked in battle with 3 Mech Corps [:)] )

Thanks!



chaos45 -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/25/2015 8:17:54 PM)

Morvael- lower fort building while in refit mode?

Didnt realize this how significant is your ability to fortify reduced while in refit mode?



Sorta -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/26/2015 1:24:29 AM)

Didn't know this - so more daft questions please. Very useful.



loki100 -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/26/2015 5:40:54 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sorta

Didn't know this - so more daft questions please. Very useful.


me neither, just goes to show that as far as this game goes there are no daft questions, just missing answers ... [8D]



MishaTX -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/26/2015 6:04:12 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: loki100


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sorta

Didn't know this - so more daft questions please. Very useful.


me neither, just goes to show that as far as this game goes there are no daft questions, just missing answers ... [8D]


Hey, I aim to please, so I'll keep them coming [;)]

Especially with a bunch as friendly as this forum is.

And the lower fortification rate while refitting bit was, to be sure, interesting. Quite reasonable as I wouldn't consider digging trenches and chopping down trees particularly conducive to refitting unless digging trenches was a whole lot more relaxing in the 40s than when I was doing my time for my country, but considering how attractive a notion it is in the game to have your units building a new fortified line while refitting... Back to the drawing board for me.



morvael -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/26/2015 7:20:30 AM)

Multiplied by current TOE%. So at 50% TOE you will have half construction points on refit as compared to no refit.



chaos45 -> RE: OK, really daft refit question (8/26/2015 11:18:22 AM)

Good to know, not a massive issue when units are at 90%+ ToE but means that units that arent close to full ToE and get thrown into the line on refit mode to fill up quickly arent worth much for fortifying.



Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
1