quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot

In most scenarios, in the GC, and I believe historically, an Air HQ was located at Kwajalein. Roi-Namur, which is at the other end of the atoll 1 hex way, is better suited for expanding an AF for basing Japanese medium bombers (Bettys and Nells). The Air HQ's usually have a command radius of 1. My questions relate to the extent which the Air HQ at Kwajalein exerts influence on the Roi-Namur base:

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot
1. Does the command radius of "1" extend into adjacent hexes or just the hex in which it is located? Does it extend from Kwajalein to Roi-Namur to help by allowing more aircraft to fly and allowing more air units to be based there, coordinating aircraft
replacement/upgrades and supporting more groups at a base?

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot
2. Can the Air HQ at Kwajalein provide torpedoes to Bettys and Nells at Roi-Namur?

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot
3. Is it better to relocate the Air HQ to Roi-Namur or leave it at Kwajalein? I have always relocated the Air HQ's to Roi-Namur because it looked like the only way to provide the bombers with torpedoes. How do others deal with this situation?

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot

In most scenarios, in the GC, and I believe historically, an Air HQ was located at Kwajalein. Roi-Namur, which is at the other end of the atoll 1 hex way, is better suited for expanding an AF for basing Japanese medium bombers (Bettys and Nells). The Air HQ's usually have a command radius of 1. My questions relate to the extent which the Air HQ at Kwajalein exerts influence on the Roi-Namur base:

1. Does the command radius of "1" extend into adjacent hexes or just the hex in which it is located? Does it extend from Kwajalein to Roi-Namur to help by allowing more aircraft to fly and allowing more air units to be based there, coordinating aircraft
replacement/upgrades and supporting more groups at a base?

2. Can the Air HQ at Kwajalein provide torpedoes to Bettys and Nells at Roi-Namur?

3. Is it better to relocate the Air HQ to Roi-Namur or leave it at Kwajalein? I have always relocated the Air HQ's to Roi-Namur because it looked like the only way to provide the bombers with torpedoes. How do others deal with this situation?

quote:

ORIGINAL: PaxMondo

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot
1. Does the command radius of "1" extend into adjacent hexes or just the hex in which it is located? Does it extend from Kwajalein to Roi-Namur to help by allowing more aircraft to fly and allowing more air units to be based there, coordinating aircraft
replacement/upgrades and supporting more groups at a base?

The first hex is the hex that it lives in, so command radius 1 is only for that hex.

quote:

ORIGINAL: PaxMondo

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot
2. Can the Air HQ at Kwajalein provide torpedoes to Bettys and Nells at Roi-Namur?

I don't beleive they can.

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot

In most scenarios, in the GC, and I believe historically, an Air HQ was located at Kwajalein. Roi-Namur, which is at the other end of the atoll 1 hex way, is better suited for expanding an AF for basing Japanese medium bombers (Bettys and Nells). The Air HQ's usually have a command radius of 1. My questions relate to the extent which the Air HQ at Kwajalein exerts influence on the Roi-Namur base:

1. Does the command radius of "1" extend into adjacent hexes or just the hex in which it is located? Does it extend from Kwajalein to Roi-Namur to help by allowing more aircraft to fly and allowing more air units to be based there, coordinating aircraft
replacement/upgrades and supporting more groups at a base?

2. Can the Air HQ at Kwajalein provide torpedoes to Bettys and Nells at Roi-Namur?

3. Is it better to relocate the Air HQ to Roi-Namur or leave it at Kwajalein? I have always relocated the Air HQ's to Roi-Namur because it looked like the only way to provide the bombers with torpedoes. How do others deal with this situation?

Recommend you read the newbie FAQ. Good stuff here:

http://www.matrixgames.com/forums/tm.asp?m=2260137

I also recommend you read the post history of Alfred:

http://www.matrixgames.com/forums/showprofile.asp?memid=22406


He's a crotchety guy that probably spends his days yelling "GET OFF MY LAWN!", but his posts generally have good info in them. I know he posted on the details of how this works within the last 6 months, but I can't find it. (search on this forum sucks and the google search is not much better tonight - cannot seem to find the post I am thinking of. )

1. Supposedly, yes. See section 8 of the above link: "Command Radius 1 = One hex from the HQ.i.e. Hex HQ is in and all 6 Hexes around."

2. From memory of the post I have given up finding: Yes. Air groups in Command Radius of the HQ can supply torpedoes. Assuming appropriate supply, etc.

3. IMO, yes. While my understanding is that the HQ will provide torpedoes, the Aviation Support doesn't extend out in hexes afaik. I have seen suggestions where naval support had some effect upon things like port loading within their command radius. I have not seen anything suggesting Av Support extended beyond the base. So, why put aviation support where they have no, or fewer planes to repair?

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey
2. From memory of the post I have given up finding: Yes. Air groups in Command Radius of the HQ can supply torpedoes. Assuming appropriate supply, etc.

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot

Thank you for your responses.

I am still left with a question: Does command radius of "1" mean an HQ exerts influence in only the hex in which it is located or does it exert influence on the adjacent 6 hexes as well.

quote:

ORIGINAL: szmike

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey
2. From memory of the post I have given up finding: Yes. Air groups in Command Radius of the HQ can supply torpedoes. Assuming appropriate supply, etc.

But not through water hexes, unless neighbouring. So Air HQ in Kwajalein will supply torpedoes for Roi-Namur base, but assuming it had a radius of say 9, it wouldn't supply torpedoes to any other island in range.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Chickenboy

quote:

ORIGINAL: OPilot

Thank you for your responses.

I am still left with a question: Does command radius of "1" mean an HQ exerts influence in only the hex in which it is located or does it exert influence on the adjacent 6 hexes as well.

Command radius of 1 means HQ exerts influence on its hex and those hexes (6) adjacent to ("1 hex away from") it.

ETA: Think of it like setting your CAP to "0" hex range. CAP will fly in the hex of their air base and nowhere else-not adjacent hexes. Similar vein for command radius.

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey

quote:

ORIGINAL: szmike

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey
2. From memory of the post I have given up finding: Yes. Air groups in Command Radius of the HQ can supply torpedoes. Assuming appropriate supply, etc.

But not through water hexes, unless neighbouring. So Air HQ in Kwajalein will supply torpedoes for Roi-Namur base, but assuming it had a radius of say 9, it wouldn't supply torpedoes to any other island in range.

Really? I seem to recall reading that you just had to be in range as the crow flies... do you have a manual page or reference post where that was noted?

quote:

ORIGINAL: szmike

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey

quote:

ORIGINAL: szmike

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey
2. From memory of the post I have given up finding: Yes. Air groups in Command Radius of the HQ can supply torpedoes. Assuming appropriate supply, etc.

But not through water hexes, unless neighbouring. So Air HQ in Kwajalein will supply torpedoes for Roi-Namur base, but assuming it had a radius of say 9, it wouldn't supply torpedoes to any other island in range.

Really? I seem to recall reading that you just had to be in range as the crow flies... do you have a manual page or reference post where that was noted?

Just my experience. I was as surprised, when my torpedoes weren't supplied to an island in range of HQ full of them. The only explanation that occurred to me was that. See attached screenshot, my other squadron in Hilo has got torpedoes supplied from PH.

[image]local://upfiles/32706/215E708A331144A09EA04CB6B9CD3C42.jpg[/image]

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey


1. Supposedly, yes. See section 8 of the above link: "Command Radius 1 = One hex from the HQ.i.e. Hex HQ is in and all 6 Hexes around."

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey

quote:

ORIGINAL: szmike

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey
2. From memory of the post I have given up finding: Yes. Air groups in Command Radius of the HQ can supply torpedoes. Assuming appropriate supply, etc.

But not through water hexes, unless neighbouring. So Air HQ in Kwajalein will supply torpedoes for Roi-Namur base, but assuming it had a radius of say 9, it wouldn't supply torpedoes to any other island in range.

Really? I seem to recall reading that you just had to be in range as the crow flies... do you have a manual page or reference post where that was noted?

quote:

ORIGINAL: BBfanboy

quote:

ORIGINAL: szmike

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey

quote:

ORIGINAL: szmike

quote:

ORIGINAL: InfiniteMonkey
2. From memory of the post I have given up finding: Yes. Air groups in Command Radius of the HQ can supply torpedoes. Assuming appropriate supply, etc.

But not through water hexes, unless neighbouring. So Air HQ in Kwajalein will supply torpedoes for Roi-Namur base, but assuming it had a radius of say 9, it wouldn't supply torpedoes to any other island in range.

Really? I seem to recall reading that you just had to be in range as the crow flies... do you have a manual page or reference post where that was noted?

Just my experience. I was as surprised, when my torpedoes weren't supplied to an island in range of HQ full of them. The only explanation that occurred to me was that. See attached screenshot, my other squadron in Hilo has got torpedoes supplied from PH.

[image]local://upfiles/32706/215E708A331144A09EA04CB6B9CD3C42.jpg[/image]

What is the supply situation at VP-51's base? I think you need the minimum 2X supply to draw torpedoes, and each torp is 10 supply points.