mandt -> (5/14/2003 12:32:54 AM)
|
[QUOTE]Originally posted by LargeSlowTarget [B]I really don't want to criticize you, since overall I like your mods very much, but your barge and PT art sizes are less then close to the original size. Sure, the ship arts are not exactly to scale, but still they show the hierarchy - a CL looks bigger than a DD, a SC looks smaller than a DD. But your PT and barge arts are too large in comparison with other ship classes higher up in the hierarchy - especially when compared to the SC art. PTs displaced less than 60 tons, the SCs were in the 250-300 tons range. I know I'm nitpicking, but I find it an odd picture when I see my mixed SC/PT forces in combat with barges and the actual biggest ships in the engagement are depicted as the smallest! But it's just irritating, not more. And since your new arts are more detailed, I'll use them nevertheless. But still it would be nice if you could try to make them smaller. Anyway, the one ship art that really needs some revision IMO is the CLAA Atlanta/Oakland art. Those ships looked beautiful, elegant and almost fragile (well, they were), but the UV art doesn't do justice to this. Edit: It's 3 o' clock in the morning and I can't sleep because of my failed invasion of Luganville, that's why I'm grumbling... [/B][/QUOTE] Large, you're a man unto my own heart. It was similar feelings that got me started on these mods in the first place. Funny thing about that Elco, I hesitated poating it cuz I'm not entirely happy with the final results. I just know I can come up with a better piece of work. Like I said above, I'll take another look at it. I'm considering increasing the resolution of the art to allow for a smaller graphic that would still retain good detail. What I don't want is a smaller piece of art, that's more to scale with the SC but looks like no more than a little gray blob. Those Atlanta class cruisers were beautiful ships. Are you using the original art from the game, or did you download the new arts from Spooky's site? I don't know if there's any difference. I just want to be sure we're on the same page. I'll take a look at that one too. Thanks again for the feedback. Keep it coming.
|
|
|
|