Dropping fuel/supplies on HQs (Full Version)

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Gary Grigsby's War in the East Series



Message


Kielec -> Dropping fuel/supplies on HQs (10/7/2018 10:18:10 PM)

I cannot find the air-dropped supplies/fuel in HQ dumps. Tried many times - failed 100%.

An air-drop goes OK, X supplies, Y ammo, or whatever # tons of fuel delivered. Check the HQ dumps? No joy. Nothing's there.

Why?




MarauderPL -> RE: Dropping fuel/supplies on HQs (10/8/2018 8:04:16 AM)

It's been changed, now you drop to units, not to HQs. Stuff droppped to HQs stays for the HQ unit to use, doesnt get transferred to combat units.




jzardos -> RE: Dropping fuel/supplies on HQs (10/8/2018 7:02:43 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: MarauderPL

It's been changed, now you drop to units, not to HQs. Stuff droppped to HQs stays for the HQ unit to use, doesnt get transferred to combat units.


So with this logic, dropping on HQs would distribute to the units under it's command? I need more explainaion here if it's better to drop on an HQ of units (say in a pocket) or each unit in the pocket and not their parent HQ(s).




thedoctorking -> RE: Dropping fuel/supplies on HQs (10/9/2018 12:36:37 AM)

Drop on the units. If you drop on the HQ, the supplies will be in the HQ's stockpile and will keep it (and attached SU) supplied, but won't be passed on to subordinate units.




Aufklaerungs -> RE: Dropping fuel/supplies on HQs (10/9/2018 2:42:08 AM)

That may be correct, but as a rule, makes little sense. HQ unit acquires resupply from railhead and distributes to subordinates normally using inherent HQ supply lift capacity. Dumps are for holding overflow that will also flow to the units (unless Corps HQ is in the black market business) .
Material used to support HQ support activities is accountable inventory property never held in supply or fuel dumps. Corps CDR would be court-martialed if caught keeping a segregated supply of expendables for HQ units exclusive use. In an airdrop, he does not have to travel to a railhead/depot, only has to travel within scatter range of the drop zone hex. No plausible reason for not distributing. Besides, that's certainly the technique used when airlifting supplies. HQ location is a more certain location than units' dynamic location due to fluid combat realities; AD flak threat is always presumed to be greater toward the forward edge of the battle space; HQ trains are always in the rear a safe distance from the FEBA. Best solution would be HQ acquires resupply on turn x and distributes to subordinates on T x+1 (following turn). I've been playing under the assumption that units receive supply from HQ on the turn following HQ acquisition from railheads. Regardless, HQ receives air drops to resupply combat units and if rules don't allow they need to be fixed.




MarauderPL -> RE: Dropping fuel/supplies on HQs (10/9/2018 7:43:49 AM)

It was changed to prevent some kind of exploit, I don't remember what was it exactly. I'm not 100% sure, but I have a recollection that it was changed back and forth a few times already. In general the supply rules are a form of abstraction and game mechanics, not direct modelling of real life airlift logistics. With 1 week turns, i-go-u-go system and the use of MP some compromise needs to be made - I think it is actually quite realistic and works not that badly.
Dropping to units gives you more flexibility - you can stack up fuel on a few units of your choice instead of spreading it across the whole corps.




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
0.6879883