MP Quitters (Full Version)

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Strategic Command Series >> Strategic Command WWII: World at War



Message

ThunderLizard11 -> MP Quitters (9/19/2019 2:33:11 PM)

I've found that a lot of players just quit their MP matches without even a comment as to why. This is really annoying after spending 40-50 turns getting to a point where the game is getting interesting and then the opponent resigns or just doesn't take any more turns. One good thing about the AI is that it won't quit on you.



pjg100 -> RE: MP Quitters (9/19/2019 3:50:24 PM)

Yes, I've been ghosted once or twice. Perhaps we should open a thread where players can post the names of those who quit in such a manner?



sveint -> RE: MP Quitters (9/19/2019 10:12:42 PM)

Welcome to the online world. I've played entire matches without exchanging a word.

You don't need a list of "bad" players, that is too judgemental. Instead a list of good PBEM partners is a good idea.

PS Either of you two looking for another game?



pjg100 -> RE: MP Quitters (9/20/2019 1:10:44 AM)

Thanks, I'm taking a break from MP, too much work too little time. I'm looking forward to another ARR from you at some point though!



sveint -> RE: MP Quitters (9/20/2019 3:11:21 AM)

I'd be happy to do a 1.05 AAR but I'd need an opponent who agrees. Not everyone wants to showcase their playstyle (nor continue the game even if losing).



EarlyDoors -> RE: MP Quitters (9/20/2019 10:15:37 AM)

Needs a PBEM ladder or league table



Christolos -> RE: MP Quitters (9/21/2019 1:52:52 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: sveint

Welcome to the online world. I've played entire matches without exchanging a word.

You don't need a list of "bad" players, that is too judgemental. Instead a list of good PBEM partners is a good idea.

PS Either of you two looking for another game?


I agree that we don't necessarily need a list of rude players who quit without notice (it has happened to me too...), and while chatting in game or with PM messages/e-mail messages is not required to enjoy the game, I personally think and feel that it helps in terms of building a friendly relationship that not only has value at a personal level, but also at a community level which helps to support and ensure that great games like this continue to be improved and developed.

A list of players people recommend, on the other hand, may not be a bad idea! [:)]
I could personally think of a few right now...

Cheers,

C



taffjones -> RE: MP Quitters (9/21/2019 2:47:22 AM)

I have had someone resign after I have played turn 1, OK I had some very good dice rolls in that game but WTF no PM message [:@]

Then tonight I excepted a challenge and had to deal with some family issue before I could play turn 1 (as the Axis) relogged in to find my opponent had resigned?
Again no message or PM.

But I think a message/ conversation system like they had in PC2 would be a massive improvement to the game.

At the moment it is frustrating the limit on the length of message/chat you have in game, It is not long enough for more experienced players to give feedback and help to newer players,
and more experienced players to discuss different tactics.

I think if this was improved it would really help build the community who play the game and help stop the sudden resigning of games by some players (who may have given up hope and are not getting praise for what they have done well in a game even if they are losing)

I am no computer expert so have no idea how easy it would be to improve this part of the game, but I am sure it would be worth the effort as more players would stay playing the game and encourage people they know to take it up.



Mercutio -> RE: MP Quitters (9/21/2019 10:57:32 AM)

Well, on the bright side, quitting early is better than sinking hours into a game and they quit in 41!

I think shaming is probably not the way to go, but recommending is pretty solid.



ThunderLizard11 -> RE: MP Quitters (9/21/2019 6:25:08 PM)

That's what happened in one of my recent PBEM games. Got into early '42 after a lot of turns and poof player resigns with no comment. Game was still balanced at that point.



amandkm -> RE: MP Quitters (9/23/2019 5:54:44 PM)

It would be nice to be able to communicate without having to commit to doing a turn. I've had to open the game, then spend five to ten minutes letting a turn advance before being able to resign. I do try to send a note when I resign, but it would be a lot easier.

Or at the least, allow a note to be posted when you are resigning. As it stands, when somebody resigns, it just goes 'poof'. If there was a way to at least say, "Wow, you really outfoxed me in the North Atlantic, I can't see how I can pull this out!" It might help



calcwerc -> RE: MP Quitters (9/23/2019 9:31:36 PM)

Being rather new to this game, I did resign without further notice in my first PBEM. I played against an expert player, taking Warsaw at turn one and as he did Seelöwe in July or August 1940, killed RAF and took London, I thought it was clear that the game was won by him and didnt see it as rude to quit. However, and this is my point, I wasnt aware at that point that there was a game chat. I took several games to find out that, and I might be dumb, but so are others. Please take that into consideration.



amandkm -> RE: MP Quitters (9/23/2019 10:34:34 PM)

I wasn't trying to cast shade on anyone. Most of us are still learning the game as we go. I was making the suggestion/request that at some point, perhaps the Devs could look at beefing up the Chat a bit, is all.



calcwerc -> RE: MP Quitters (9/23/2019 11:35:45 PM)

Well, it wasnt directed at you actually, but to the topic, which was the suggestion to make a list of players who quit without getting notice. I agree with your suggestions, of course, that a better chat function in the game would be helpful and most welcome.



fireston -> RE: MP Quitters (9/28/2019 1:45:50 AM)

I do want to throw something out there, i recently had some issues involving the hurricane where I had no way of messaging many of the people i was playing against, my only recourse was to post a message here on the forums and make some decisions as to the State of the Game where I felt resigning was better to give my opponent the win/resign rather than drag it out as i had to evacuate. Also its a bit of a pain in the butt to load up the game, type out the message and then resign. I would prefer the following:
1) Wins and losses kept
2) Larger text box maybe even its own "click" section in the game where its like a mini email back and forth. It sucks after two sentences its stops. I mean I could write less in the box but then I get too lazy to quit:)
3)PBE Ladder
4) Email option when you mouse over your opponents names that allows you to send the email via the forums.
5) When setting up the game the option is 1 turn every 24 hours/72 hours, one week. I really think this option would be good for allowing players to play to their level of engagement. We had this with ONline Axis and Allies, and the standard etiquette was, if it was a 24 hour turn rule, you gave the person in extra day to play, and if they didn't close the game out and collect your win. Same with 3 days, you give an extra day and move on.

How feasible these options are I have no idea, but I also don't favor shaming or calling players out. Everyone learns this game at different levels and speeds. I can relate to the player above who said, "I didn't even know you could talk to the other player!"



ThunderLizard11 -> RE: MP Quitters (10/7/2019 6:48:55 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: fireston

I do want to throw something out there, i recently had some issues involving the hurricane where I had no way of messaging many of the people i was playing against, my only recourse was to post a message here on the forums and make some decisions as to the State of the Game where I felt resigning was better to give my opponent the win/resign rather than drag it out as i had to evacuate. Also its a bit of a pain in the butt to load up the game, type out the message and then resign. I would prefer the following:
1) Wins and losses kept
2) Larger text box maybe even its own "click" section in the game where its like a mini email back and forth. It sucks after two sentences its stops. I mean I could write less in the box but then I get too lazy to quit:)
3)PBE Ladder
4) Email option when you mouse over your opponents names that allows you to send the email via the forums.
5) When setting up the game the option is 1 turn every 24 hours/72 hours, one week. I really think this option would be good for allowing players to play to their level of engagement. We had this with ONline Axis and Allies, and the standard etiquette was, if it was a 24 hour turn rule, you gave the person in extra day to play, and if they didn't close the game out and collect your win. Same with 3 days, you give an extra day and move on.

How feasible these options are I have no idea, but I also don't favor shaming or calling players out. Everyone learns this game at different levels and speeds. I can relate to the player above who said, "I didn't even know you could talk to the other player!"


Just had another quitter mid'41 with no comment (ahv). I like your suggestions. I would like my own list as it's frustrating to spend so much time on a match and have a player drop out just as it's getting interesting. Advantage of SP is the AI doesn't just quit.



ThunderLizard11 -> RE: MP Quitters (10/15/2019 1:47:22 PM)

Another quitter right before Pearl Harbor Dec' 41 attach (zyprokza). I don't get why someone would play 60 turns and quit right when things start to get interesting.



Treefrog -> RE: MP Quitters (1/15/2020 11:22:59 PM)

I have been playing wargames for recreation for 60 years. If my opponent is not enjoying himself I have no problem with him quitting the game. In ftf we usually then chat about the game and start another. I agree that a comment to your opponent when resigning is the civil and mature way to step out.

It would be helpful if there was some way to communicate host experience level/talent when issuing an open challenge.

That being said, I'm a rookie in WaW looking for a campaign game against another rookie if my current opponent zyprokza remains missing in action; however I see that all the invitations are "locked". I prefer axis but will play allied if asked.



Ralph1961 -> RE: MP Quitters (1/16/2020 3:17:14 AM)

I’m game let me know if you want to take on another game



Treefrog -> RE: MP Quitters (1/16/2020 2:32:51 PM)

see my email to you.



Mercutio -> RE: MP Quitters (1/22/2020 10:38:12 PM)

I think it would help if there was some sort of rating system. While I enjoy playing, even getting my butt kicked, I don't enjoy wiping out someone. It would help to see some in house system ranking who might be a player you would have a good game with. Of course new players would be a wildcard, but at least it is a starting point.



Treefrog -> RE: MP Quitters (1/22/2020 10:43:30 PM)

I agree on the rating system as I am a newbie.

I keep getting messages from Slitherine that I am enrolled in a MP game; I didn't actually sign up. How does one un-enroll?



taffjones -> RE: MP Quitters (1/23/2020 12:20:07 PM)

Hi Mercutio and Treefrog

If you look in the Multiplayer forum

SlickandJake has set up a ELO ranking system. If you post the results of your games. He will update the rankings and you could then PM a player with a similar rating to you.

Treefrog - If you are issuing open challenges (No Password) then any player can accept the game/challenge.



celebrindal -> RE: MP Quitters (1/26/2020 2:26:17 AM)

After mid Feb I could be up for a game. Just in the process of moving and heavy work schedule. I also host a discord server and folks are welcome to use that as well.



El_Condoro -> RE: MP Quitters (1/26/2020 10:59:19 PM)

Perhaps something like when we hit 'Unsubscribe' on an email - a tick box answer as to 'Why did you end this game?'
- Real Life intervened - sorry.
- You are killing me and I want out.
- etc.
Of course, these options would be language specific so non-English speakers can read them.

I definitely agree that SC games would benefit from a better chat system.



ThunderLizard11 -> RE: MP Quitters (1/29/2020 1:52:41 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: taffjones

Hi Mercutio and Treefrog

If you look in the Multiplayer forum

SlickandJake has set up a ELO ranking system. If you post the results of your games. He will update the rankings and you could then PM a player with a similar rating to you.

Treefrog - If you are issuing open challenges (No Password) then any player can accept the game/challenge.


This is a good idea but it would make sense to have this as a built in feature where every player got a ranking based on their win/loss record.



Sugar -> RE: MP Quitters (1/29/2020 2:55:09 PM)

1. While watching the latest opponent turn, a message can still be posted in game before resignation.
2. After an opposite resignation I usually watch the last turn looking for a message.
3. Not every match is meant as a partition in tourneys/rankings, but for trying or training.



Christolos -> RE: MP Quitters (1/29/2020 3:36:23 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: taffjones

Hi Mercutio and Treefrog

If you look in the Multiplayer forum

SlickandJake has set up a ELO ranking system. If you post the results of your games. He will update the rankings and you could then PM a player with a similar rating to you.

Treefrog - If you are issuing open challenges (No Password) then any player can accept the game/challenge.

I'm not so sure how accurate a rating would be just based solely on the number of games won and lost, if I understand the ELO ranking system correctly, since this would also depend on the relative skill/experience levels of the two players in each game.
For example, some players may appear to have a high win/loss ratio simply because they happened (by chance) to play mostly against less experienced players. The converse situation could also skew one's rating in the opposite direction. I'm not sure how this can be controlled for.

C



taffjones -> RE: MP Quitters (1/29/2020 6:00:07 PM)

Hi Christolos

Yes I know the ELO ranking will not be perfect, as you say the players skill v their opponents could well give a false ranking initially.

But if people play others of a similar ranking in time it will even out their ranking.

I also think it would help Hubert and Bill with the "Balance of the Game" debate.

I remember in WiE there were many people saying it favoured the Axis, but when someone started the ranking system it showed the Allies were winning more games.

Also the ELO rankings are not a competition or tournament.



Helsingor -> RE: MP Quitters (2/1/2020 10:54:47 AM)

To return the original subject of the thread, I like the idea of a "roll of honor"--in other words an informal list of those who stuck it out against an opponent even when the end was clear. I have a few shining examples in mind. Anyone care to start a new thread?



Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
3.21875