New game - Hex of Steel (formerly known as Operation Citadel) (Full Version)

All Forums >> [General] >> General Discussion



Message


Simulacra53 -> New game - Hex of Steel (formerly known as Operation Citadel) (7/4/2020 2:53:45 PM)

https://store.steampowered.com/app/1240630/Operation_Citadel/

Operation Citadel

Operation Citadel is a turn-based WWII themed 2D game in which you can play against a friend, the AI or follow one of the campaigns. You can also use the in-game tile editor and unit editor to come up with something else if you'd like !

https://youtu.be/v_QPD_g48j4

EDIT:
The designer has decided to change the name and pricing.
https://store.steampowered.com/app/1240630/Hex_of_Steel/

More info here
https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/1240630/view/3061857423720005510




Simulacra53 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/4/2020 3:19:33 PM)

Early access, single developer - very low price.
Judging by the dev’s YT the titles holds real promise.

Seasons, scenario editor and easy unit editing.
Potentially a mod’s dream.




MrsWargamer -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/4/2020 3:31:46 PM)

It looks similar to some other Panzer General/Panzer Corps looking titles I have experienced in the last few years. Which is not a negative really, as those titles are also good.




terminator -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/5/2020 9:38:58 AM)

The title of this game makes us believe that we can only play Operation Citadel while this game covers the whole of the European theater of World War II.




valentin56610 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/12/2020 11:23:42 PM)

Oh hi ! I'm the developper and just came across your post about my game on this site ! Lucky search haha.

If any of you have questions, please ask, I'll answer with as much details as I can !

edit : The game's name is Operation Citadel because all good names were already taken, and I could not come up with something else.




AndySfromVA -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 2:09:53 AM)

I bought the game and I like it, so far as I've gotten. It has a lot of potential. It's certainly worth the few bucks I paid for it.




valentin56610 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 2:14:04 AM)

Is there stuff you wished to get but did not ? Or features ? (Not mentioning any Undo button, this is beyond my programming skills for now hehehe)
Basically any ideas to make it better ? I'm listening !




darbycmcd -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 2:51:24 PM)

It looks really interesting! Can you explain a bit about the scale you envision for the game, as far as what each counter on the map will represent, how much area each hex?

How are you resolving combat?

What other aspects of military operations are you including, supply, planning, C3I or ???

Keep up the good work!





darbycmcd -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 3:00:29 PM)

Oh, and change the name. why would you call it something very specific when it is a very wide open toolbox, you are limiting sales that way. People who are interesting in just Kursk will be disappointed, people who are interested in a toolbox will not look at it.




Franciscus -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 3:13:20 PM)

Hi
- new name, definitely.
- new optional unit graphics (specially for infantry, please [:)])


Regards




valentin56610 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 4:34:15 PM)

I will answer both of your message into this one so I'm not creating a ton of new messages.

The scale and what I decided for my campaigns and my map is around 4 km per hex, but it can vary on the scenario (thinking about the eastern front especially where distances are just huge) so I tried to cut the scenarios into stuff that still make sense but that also tries to respect the scale at all point. So for example small countries like England, for the Sea Lion scenarios I cut it into 2 maps of 70 x 45(south) and 45 x 70 (north).

Now about units, well the thing is once again, due to the various editors you are able to give the game the scale you want. But for my campaigns / scenarios, it's at an operational level. Few hundred kilometres not more. So for units it's often divisional level but can also be regimental level. But once again, as you can edit or create anything, it's up to you to decide when making for yourself.

About combat, it's pretty straight forward. Final damage = damage type (soft/hard/air) - enemy unit's armour - terrain modifier.
But it does not apply to everything. CAS / ground attack planes will ignore 50% of the armour. Strategic bombers will ignore 100%. Submarines deal a random damage value between 0 (miss) and a max of its hard damage value, to simulate the effect of a torpedo, because hitting does not mean sinking.
Also the health point percentage of the unit will modify how many damage it deals, a weak unit won't deal as much as if it was full health, makes sense, less people alive / ready to fight.
So all in all, if you want to know every little detail I'd advice you to take a look at the official guide I wrote and look at the combat / damage section (it's on steam).

About moral, I haven't came up with anything yet. I'd like to add this. Still figuring out how though, I'm unsure of how it will work and what effects it will have etc. If you have ideas, once again, I'll listen.

That's also the thing, to finish answering your first question, I came up with an idea of making a game, and I just kept / still keep adding up on top. The idea I had for the game in the beginning and what the game is right now are two total different things. I tend to make everything optional in the settings though (such as the supplies), so everyone can enjoy the game with the options he wants.

Ah ! You asked about supplies. Well I guess I'll explain that right after telling you that no, I am not going to add planning (thinking about HOI here in particular) because the game really is meant to be played in turn by turn and each unit individually. Just a real wargame where you have tons of counters and when it takes a long time to complete a turn. Not because it's a hassle and it's painfully long, but because you need to micro manage every move, every supply, etc. That's what in my opinion gives the game its flavour, not having everything automated, and you still have control over it.

About supplies, AGAIN, lol, this time for real. There is a simple and a complex mode. Simple mode is when you hit resupply, it resupplies regardless of the circumstances and where you are on the board, encircled, not encircled, basically you resupply without any condition. Now the complex mod that I added like 2 days ago, this goes deeper. There is a supply line created from every unit to the closest city. If this supply line is disrupted, meaning an enemy unit in the middle, you won't be able to resupply at all. Now if you're not on the road but somewhere in the plains or in the forest, you won't be able to resupply at 100% efficiency, I think it makes sense a truck will have a harder time getting to you in the middle of the forest, than getting to you on a normal road. I haven't added a limit supply number per city yet, that's yet to be decided, by me and the players. Like each unit has a supply consumption value and each city can only produce X supplies and so if you have too many units per city well they could not get as well resupplied. For now, it's not in the game.

about C3I no, don't think this will ever happen.

About your second message and the name, yeah, I get it. I'll rename it to something strategy warfare or something more generic.

Thanks for your questions ! I hope I answered with enough details. If anything, ask again, or visit the guide :)




valentin56610 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 4:37:10 PM)

Hello Franciscus !

new name yes, that will happen.

New optional unit graphics already is available, you can replace them by anything you want ! There is a guide on Steam explaining how to do that. I am not providing anything like new textures cause I'll consider this more like modding'

Same for tiles, you can replace any tile's graphics !




demyansk -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 5:21:38 PM)

How about Matrix on the Eastern Front as a name?




RangerJoe -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 5:34:55 PM)

How about morale as a modifier? Below a certain number, units won't attack. Below a lower number, they will easily break and try to run home to mommy. Above a certain number, they get a bonus.




valentin56610 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 5:36:34 PM)

I don't know if this is serious or not.

Just in case, I'll explain : My game isn't edited / published by Matrix. Someone noticed it on Steam and chose to talk about it here. Also, the game covers not just the eastern front, but all Europe + Pacific with Japan and US.

That's why I can't even just take something about a front in particular, it needs to be even more global :(

Adding that to the fact that I suck I coming up with naming / names ...

Thanks for helping, I appreciate it !




valentin56610 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 5:42:04 PM)

Yeah for moral this is going to influence fighting abilities. My question would be more like how and why do you lose moral, but more importantly, how to you gain moral ? Because some units are there only to support, like artillery, and not to eliminate or definitely kill a unit. Meaning killing an enemy would not really be a solution as not all units actually destroy enemies. Would moral apply to planes or boats ? That's also another question that's tormenting me hahaha. I thought about gaining moral when capturing a city you know, everything gets happy with a victory and want to keep on fighting, and maybe even the opponent would get a moral malus for losing a victory point etc. But I don't know, it does not seem so balanced. And yeah they could lose and gain moral when utterly being crushed or crushing an enemy.

Yeah there are a few possibilities, I'll definitely add it, im just not certain about how.




RangerJoe -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 5:49:23 PM)

Taking losses, no rest, those things tend to be bad for morale. Moral is something else, the "e" is important. Yes, I understand that English is not your first language.

Think of the morale of the British fighter command during the Battle of Britain. Some pilots went up but found an excuse not to engage. During the American bombing offensive in Europe, some bomber pilots would find things wrong with their aircraft but the mechanics could not find anything wrong. That is the effect for low morale.




valentin56610 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 5:54:10 PM)

There is no rest mechanics and probably won't be. I'll go with losses and fighting odds, as that's what's the game mostly focuses on.
Ahh English you my old friend. So in French it's the opposite. Moral (fr) = morale (en) and morale (fr) = moral (en) AWESOME :D

Yeah ok why not, I'll add it for all units. A global representation of how goes the campaign + regional / personal casualties / battle results.




RangerJoe -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 6:10:51 PM)

Morale can increase when resupplied. Morale can increase when friendly units are near. Morale could decrease when enemy units are near. In combat, if you have defensive artillery support, the defenders could increase while the attackers could decrease. Morale could increase when the unit does not participate in combat, hence a rest mode if you will. It may be that it is on a defensive assignment.

Yes, the English language is so much fun. The English will spell a word one way while the Americans will spell it another way:

colour = color
armour = armor
cheque = check
tyre = tire




valentin56610 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 6:17:41 PM)

Ok those are good ideas I'm taking notes.
Well it might not be a long time before I implement all this ! Thanks for the help !

What about Australians and New zelanders in all that ? They spell like the British ?




RangerJoe -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/13/2020 6:25:35 PM)

I think so but I am not sure. Someone from those countries could chime in, so could the Canadians as well.




terminator -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (7/19/2020 4:15:58 AM)

It looks like it’s a French game [:)]




Simulacra53 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (2/8/2021 5:23:18 PM)

Been a while - forgot about the title until I stumbled into it today - downloaded the demo and enjoyed it enough to purchase the title.

https://store.steampowered.com/app/1240630/Operation_Citadel/




RFalvo69 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (2/8/2021 6:39:23 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: valentin56610

I don't know if this is serious or not.

Just in case, I'll explain : My game isn't edited / published by Matrix.

That was was made obvious by the existence of a demo and a OSX version [:)]




MrsWargamer -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (2/8/2021 7:19:41 PM)

I liked a lot of what I saw, but this matters enough to mention it.

Quote from the source on Steam.

"“Remember the name ‘Valentin Lievre‘. If this relatively young (21), inexperienced* French coder can produce a WW2 TBS as compendious and competent as Operation Citadel in under a year then heaven knows what wonders he’ll produce in the decades to come.”
RockPaperShotgun

“Overall, I’m pleasantly surprised with Operation Citadel. There’s a lot to like here if you’re in the mood for a light, simple Panzer General-like. The inclusion of the gigantic scenarios offers something unique and interesting, and the potential of the building tools is almost unlimited.”
Wargamer"




ncc1701e -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (2/10/2021 4:59:43 PM)

The title is funny: Operation Citadel. But, it seems to cover a world map...




Simulacra53 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (2/10/2021 6:29:32 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: ncc1701e

The title is funny: Operation Citadel. But, it seems to cover a world map...


He did not know a better name as all the nice ones were taken, he’s open to suggestions.
Try the demo, Westfeldzug, I had a blast getting a feel for the game, including air landings.

Nice mix of simplicity, yet a big map with many units, dare I say sweet spot.




LarryP -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (2/11/2021 2:14:32 AM)

What a great way to spend $15! My gosh, this game is packed with goodies. I just worked in the map editor and it's worth the price of the game alone. I hope the sales of this game skyrocket, he deserves it. Look at the threads in Discussions and you will see that Val the Developer answers issues right away. Great game! [&o] [sm=tank2-39.gif]




Rebel Yell -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (2/11/2021 3:58:32 AM)

The description makes it sound moddable.

How easy does it look to change unit values, pics etc, to change it to some other time period?




Simulacra53 -> RE: New game - Operation Citadel (2/11/2021 6:46:19 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Rebel Yell

The description makes it sound moddable.

How easy does it look to change unit values, pics etc, to change it to some other time period?


https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2360690666&searchtext=

Seems to be possible.




Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
0.609375