|
Gridley380 -> RE: Someone left the cake out in the rain (7/7/2021 4:57:30 PM)
|
I considered doing several AARs:
A. "Let them eat Wake"; do some tweaks to get a historical first battle of Wake, and focus on doing an all-out attempt to hold it. On the assumption that it would eventually fall, keep following the units that participated in the effort.
B. Flush Deckers at War (working title): "This AAR will focus on a family of elderly, often scorned, sometimes forgotten ships: the USN’s “Flush Decker” Destroyers - and transports, minelayers, tenders... At the start of the game there are 63 flush-deckers on the game map..." in between AAR posts I had lined up some ideas for related posts:
1. Eldest Sister: USS Manley
2. First Shot: USS Ward
3. Day of Infamy: USS Walker (IX-44)
4. (A) First Loss: USS Reuben James
5. First Pacific Loss: USS Peary
6. POW: USS Stewart (IJN PB #102)
7. Bullied: USS Pillsbury
8. Youngest Sister: USS Decatur
9. Tragic Twins: USS Colhoun and Little
10. Fighting Retreat: DesRon 29
11. Long Way Home: USS Childs (AVD1) & USS W.B. Preston (AVD7)
12. Frontline REMFs: DesDiv 80 – include USS Allen (DD66)
13. To the Bitter End: USS Dorsey, Barrey, and Greene
14. (A) Canal Guards: DesRon 33
15. Famous Flag: USS Paul Jones
16. Orphans: USS Litchfield and Noa
17. Banana Boats: USS Putnam, Dale, & Osborne
18. Green Dragons: APD
19. Of Mines and Minesweepers: DM & DMS
20. Tender Loving Care: AVD
21. (A) Officially Miscellaneous: USS Semmes (AG24)
22. Born in War, Died in War: USS Little, Gregory, Colhoun, and Dorsey
23. (A) Suicide: USS Buchanan
24. (A) Canadian, eh?: Canadian DD for Bases
25. (A) Three Navies: USS Herndon (aka HMS Churchill aka Dyatelnyi)
26. (A) Back from the Grave: USS Turner (IX98)
27. (O) Cursed: USS Meredith
28. (O) Honda Point
29. (O) A Death in Peacetime: USS Woolsey
30. (A) Take One With You: USS Borie
31. (A) Friendly Fire: USS Sturtevant
32. (O) Three Digits: USS Maury (DD100)
33. (O) Small Families: USS Tillman (Charleston NSY) & Gwin (Todd Dry Dock)
34. (O) Haven’t We Met Before?: USS Gridley, Mahan, Edsall, Farragut, Somers, Sumner [yes, named for Allen M. Sumner]
35. (O) Rumrunners: USCG service
36. (O) Boiling Over: Yarrow boilers
C. "Politics in the Pacific"; "In many AARs the player asks for advice.
I’m going to ask for orders.
You – anyone reading this thread – are going to play the part of various politicians, commanders of other theaters, even journalists manipulating public opinion. Anyone who would be in a position to influence strategic decisions.
I’m going to periodically ask a question that would have been of political significance. I’ll give a day for voting and then I’ll do what the majority voted for, whether it’s a good idea or not.
You are, by the way, under no obligation to vote historically, or for what you think the best in-game answer would be. You can vote however you like..."
All three were intended to be played with a variant of Babes where I'd made some corrections to the OrBat, but I wound up more or less re-writing the US Army and USMC game OrBat in the process (based primarily on Rottman and Stanton's USMC and US Army Ground Forces OrBat books), and it became more frustration than fun.
|
|
|
|
