|
Apollo11 -> (10/11/2003 2:14:59 PM)
|
Hi all,
[QUOTE=mdiehl]
Leo -
In what year are the Allies seeing perfect success? 1942 would be too early (and in no year should the allies have a guaranteed kill). On the whole, however, Allied crews were far better trained at ASW and the Allies should be better at it, even when the only weapons deployed are pressure-triggered DCs.
[/QUOTE]
The 1942/1943 is way to early for almost 100% certain kill of Japanese
submarine when attacked with depth charges (and yet this is happening almost
all the time in UV 1942/1943).
In UV v2.30 (and I presume in WitP ALPHA) when Japanese submarine is attacked
by depth charges from escorts it would receive hits which would render it sunk
(2 hits) or fatally wounded (50% or more damage).
What I would like to see instead (and what is historically accurate) is:
#1
Many many more unsuccessful depth charge attack where submarine is not damaged
at all but such attack would force submarine to hide fore hours and thus not
attack.
#2
Many many more partially successful depth charge attack where submarine would
suffer all kind of damage from near misses (like leakage, system damage,
weapon damage, reduced speed from engine damage).
#3
Much much less direct hits where depth charge(s) would hit directly and cause
massive damage (like we have now: 50% for 1st hit and sunk from 2nd hit).
This is what I had in mind when I initially posted my first message...
Leo "Apollo11"
|
|
|
|
