|
Chiteng -> (11/15/2003 7:42:41 AM)
|
[QUOTE=byron13]Nope, sorry Chiteng. Mdiehl wins this round. Assuming you actually said that Mac and Nimitz were wrong to try a two-pronged approach, you're licked. The statement - if made - presumes you believed that they had the assets available to successfully execute a single-pronged advance and, therefore, should have done so. Now in WitP, having been allocated the same forces they were allocated, you say you cannot make a single-pronged approach cannot work. I don't see King coming into this equation at all. Either you can successfully execute a single-prong attack through the Central Pacific with the forces historically allocated or, if you can't, I think you've got to admit that the historical strategy is somewhat validated.[/QUOTE]
In no case. All statements were postulated on the release of WITP which at that
time was billed as having USA production. Obviously it does not. It isnt even close.
|
|
|
|
