Scorpion_sk -> (1/15/2002 5:56:00 AM)
|
Good points, WB and Grumble.
Now, like I said, I´m not bored by the MCs at all-oh no, that´s why I ordered all of them.
However this was just a bit of positive critical feedback to keep in mind for future endeavors. Sure-it´ll take a lot of work and creativity to create entirely new, but feasible "what if"-scenarios on a larger scale (like you said, for example: Rommel in Caucasus)
It´s a part of designing to make these hypothetical scenarios and conclusions feasible from a historical point of view too. More "representation" by the player, bigger forces (and thus fewer, bigger battles on a larger time frame) and smaller, or smaller, more clearly defined operations (like the Battle of the Bulge) should be some of the options to make it possible for the historical "loser" to turn the tables (which I´m pretty sure many of us want to do).
Another good option that´d enable the one of the future campaigns (be it for whatever engine, CL or CA or another game) to be very dynamical would be to give up on scripted battles, and use a powerful battle generator to create the battles in the campaign.
However, it´d be up to the campaign designer to write the situational briefings and other documentation, and enable a dynamic campaign map (With supply lines etc.) and script all the campaign happenings (hypothetical or those that have a historical basis) and use them as a guideline for modifying the settings of the battlemaker for each battle (points, nationality, terrain, mission etc. etc.) Thus scenarios would always have an impact on the campaign (losses would cause the losing side to be weaker until replaced or reinfoced, major victories or a string of moderate ones would cause ground to be won/lost, whatever....and the player could still make the kind of choices that are in the MCs). Do you catch my drift?
This, in my mind, would enable the campaign to go on until a conclusion, be it for good or bad, could be achieved, and it´d enable Rommel to take the Canal....and go beyond it.
I´m continuing to have fun with the MCs and hope you have fun designing campaigns in the future, too. They´re very important parts of the wargame for me (I can´t stay interested in single scenarios...multiplaying excepted) and for many of us, too.
Still, I don´t think I´ll be returning to the desert anytime soon after I´ve shaken the dust and sand out of my boots and headed to the Steppes...and from there to the jungle-hells.
I´m pretty sure it´s time for something else after that
|
|
|
|