Monter_Trismegistos
Posts: 1359
Joined: 2/1/2005 From: Gdansk Status: offline
|
Let's see if you are telling truth: quote:
ORIGINAL: Monter_Trismegistos S-52 - commisioned 430609 Better, but still not fixed S-53 - commisioned 430130 Better, but still not fixed Old ones: 1. Class 1585 (Leninet): a) Name should be changed to Leninets (as last cyryllic sign in their name is in English transcribed as ts), or even better "L (proj. XI/XIII)" FIXED b) To few torpedo tubes, ships of "L class proj. II" had 6 torpedo tubes, proj. XI and XIII had 8 torpedo tubes (6xF 2xR). There is no need for averaging them as all Far East ships were of 2 latter subclasses. NOT FIXED!!! c) They were capable of carrying 20 mines, not 28 as in RHS. - d) Are you sure that they should have better manuv. than S-class? These were large and not so new minelayers... NOT FIXED 2. Class 1588 (Stalinets): a) Name should be changed to Srednaya, or even better "S (proj. IX-bis)". Since later names of types were no longer named after ships but after its size (Srednaya means medium) and name Stalinets was already used by ship of another class (L2), thus it was NOT POSSIBLE to name this class Stalinetz. FIXED b) Wrong number of torpedo tubes. Should have only 6 (4xF 2xR). NOT FIXED!!! 3. Ship 3893 Raztoropny: a) Should be named Rastoropny - this is most common version of its name in English. NOT FIXED 4. Ship 3813 Baku: She was on Far East from commisioning (401211) until leaving to North fleet in late 1942. Its arriving date (420915) in not correct. She was leaving theater on late 1942, not arriving - change its start date to 411206 FIXED 5. Ship 3418 Tibilsi: Incorrectly named as Tibilsi, should be Tbilisi FIXED 6. Ship 4106 Revnostny: Commissioning date: 411214 NOT FIXED 7. Ship 4115 Razyaryonnyi: a) Should be named Razyaryonny (to keep consistent with style in which other ships names are transcribed into English) NOT FIXED b) Commissioning date: 411214 NOT FIXED 8. Ship 4320 Razyaryonny: Ship doubled with 4115 NOT FIXED!!! 9. Ship 4227 [now moved to 4225] Vnushitelnyi: a) delete it, it was commisioned 471229. (I know you wont do this ) b) at least name her Vnushitelny to keep her name consistent with others. NOT FIXED 10. Ship 3586 Radyashtchi: Should be Razyashchy. NOT FIXED So let's count: of 18 errors: - 12 were not fixed, 10 of them wasn't even touched - 2 were discussable - 4 were fixed You also didn't answered why name TShch-XXX is too long. Also new ones: 11. Ship 9410 S-51: Still you don't understand in which way Soviet ships were moving during war. ALL Pacific ships that changed theater during war were LEAVING, not arriving. 421028 is more less date of end of its assignament to FE Fleet. It was commisioned 30.11.1941.
< Message edited by Monter_Trismegistos -- 10/20/2006 3:48:02 PM >
_____________________________
Nec Temere Nec Timide Bez strachu ale z rozwagą
|