byron13
Posts: 1589
Joined: 7/27/2001 Status: offline
|
Don't THINK! Hesitation kills. You have to follow your gut. My gut is telling me that you should attack Port Moresby, Noumea, and Cookstown - all right now. No, wait. I'm sorry. I was eating lunch, and my gut was telling me to eat the three chocolate chip cookies - all right now. Apologies, and I hope you didn't do anything drastic based on that advice. Seems to me that you need better intelligence before you even consider any of these options. If I recall, you said you thought the 1st Marine Division was in Noumea. If that's still true, I doubt you could ever dislodge them. In addition, you'd have to park your fleets off the island to support them, which will make the AI's job a lot easier in finding you. The supply line would be horribly long. You would need all of your fleet resources active all the time to support the battle and, at any given time, half of the fleet would probably be in transit to and from Rabaul to refuel. Can your fuel stocks support a long-term supporting role for the fleet? Is Luganville one of the Automatic Victory locations? If not, I question a move after it. While you could take it, what purpose would it serve? Noumea will only get stronger, and the problems in taking it will only increase with time. While Luganville might be able to provide some LBA support (sorry, I have no idea whether it could or not), it won't be able to provide any meaningful logistical help in an invasion of Noumea. In fact, it would only divert resources (to support Luganville) from the Noumea battle. Factor in the time to capture Luganville, build up whatever forces and supplies you need before moving on to Noumea. So consider that Luganville might be a stepping stone . . . to nowhere. With Port Moresby still active, I would think an invasion of Cooktown would be difficult to accomplish and then maintain. Supplying or reinforcing your invasion force would have to be ugly. I would also have to believe that the Aussies could eventually mount a powerful counterattack after massing its forces. Of course, I have no idea what they actually have available. Seems to me that Port Moresby makes sense - if you can muster enough of an invasion force to overcome the defenders. Is the defense there weaker than Noumea? If so, I'd say definitely Port Moresby. I also don't know how the ground combat works to know if you would have a good chance of gaining the airfield quickly. You could certainly gain local air superiority for a period with your carriers and LBA. If intel shows that Port Moresby has a weak enough defense where you think you could gain control of the airfield within a week, I'd go there. You've got supporting bases, the supply line is shorter and, with the airfield in your possession, no allied LBA to interfere with you supply line - except at the termination point. You would also consolidate your hold on New Guinea, making it virtually impossible for the allies to recapture any part of it within the period of the game. On a strategic level, you are also consolidated with none of your forces vulnerable to allied LBA but Port Moresby. The Allies would have to mount a major combat and logistical operation to capture anything of value which, with their carriers hurt, they probably would not be able to do - at least successfully. But I still have cookies to eat, and I'm talking out of my backside since I have no realistic idea of how the game plays. Get more intel on your various possible objectives so that the UV On-line Strategic Worthless Advice Committee can get a clearer idea of options. Or, better yet, go gold and let us sim the situation with you!
|