Russian Guard
Posts: 1251
Joined: 10/14/2005 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: bjmorgan quote:
ORIGINAL: Russian Guard You cannot draw supply into or through a red "X" province, period, even if a depot is adjacent. You are _always_ out of supply in a red "x" province, regardless of all other considerations. Well, let's review your statement, shall we? You said that units are ALWAYS out of supply, regardless of all other considerations. They're not. I said that units in the city are in supply and that other units can forage. I was pointing out that it wasn't neccessarily just being in an X province that caused the loss. "Regarless of all other considerations," units in those provinces will not lose men, if they are garrisoned and under the weather-related forage limit. Go back and read what I said. No need to get defensive. Allow me restate, with obvious context included: "You cannot draw supply into or through a red "X" province, period, even if a depot is adjacent. You are _always_ out of supply in a red "x" province, OUTSIDE THE CITY, regardless of all other considerations. Foraging is not supply." Garrison supply was a distinction not asked about, as the post "Ah, you were talking about units in garrison." made clear.
|