Shannon V. OKeets
Posts: 22095
Joined: 5/19/2005 From: Honolulu, Hawaii Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Dr Deo First off, let me introduce myself. I played a little bit of WiF years ago, but stopped when my gaming buddy moved out of town. Back then I was active in the WiF discussion list and I became a beta tester of CWiF until Matrix took over and the public beta was closed. As time went by I lost interest, but I'm happy to see that Matrix has now reached "the beginning of the end" at least! :) Anyway, I've now taken up CWiF again, to try out some strategies and now I'm stuck on how far to expand and how to defend the Japanese perimeter. I have three question marks: 1) NEI territories. NEI is a minor country aligned to NL, which is (usually) aligned to CW, but there's no minor country aligned to NEI. This means that after Batavia falls to the Japanese, NEI is completely conquered, right? The RAW says that a completely conquered country's territories become neutral if no major power has influence there. That means Dutch New Guinea (NEI territory) will become neutral if Japan hasn't taken a port or a major power has a garrison value there. However, the harrifications on Crete tell the opposite - the territory Crete belongs to the conqueror of Greece, even if CW has a higher garrison value! Applying that logic on NEI means that all NEI territory will be Japanese controlled after Batavia has fallen. Is that the general consensus? 2) Minor ports/islands. There are so many minor ports and small islands within Japan's perimeter that's impossible to garrison them all. I'm leaning towards only garrisoning the minor ports which are either a capital (e.g. Kuala Lumpur), have oil (Balikpapan, Tarakan) or border two or more sea areas (e.g. Kwajalein, Saipan). However, this means that for example I wouldn't garrison Guam once invaded and that Bonin Islands would be ungarrisoned as well. They could of course then be captured by the Americans relatively easy, but there are so many of them that it might be better to act reactively in force to any American threat to minor ports, rather than being spread thin. Comments? 3) Midway - Honolulu. I assume capturing Midway would only makes sense if Honolulu was also intended to be captured, because otherwise the supply lines are too threatened (if using LOS option). However, there's an ambiguous harrification on the US production multiplier if Hawaii is invaded. Hawaii wasn't a state at the time and shouldn't affect the multiplier, but how is Harry's "maybe" interpreted in practice? If it means the US multiplier goes up, I'd never even come near Honolulu with ground troops... Welcome to the forum! Take a look at the AI Opponent Geographical Breakdown thread (or some such name). There are screenshots there that show how the AI (actually Peter and I) figure the islands in the Pacific should be grouped. We started with Europe and then more or less worked our way around the globe, so the Pacific is towards the end.
_____________________________
Steve Perfection is an elusive goal.
|