Slitherine

quote:

ORIGINAL: Centuur

You'll want another mistake you've made: here is one... The Netherlands got DOW'ed on last turn. Where to set up the Dutch TRS... answer: far, far away from the Netherlands in NEI. So no capture or destruction possible by the Germans... The more TRS you've got, the better it is for the CW. TRS are the most important units for the CW, since they have to move so many units over long distances at sea.

Now, prudent CW play regarding the use of land units in the first turn is:

At setup the spare INF goes into Malta and a gun goes into Gibraltar
In SO 1939: get the BEF (2 units) into France and an infantry unit to Gibraltar. You've now got 2 units in Gibraltar, so the Italians can't grab it. There's very much time left in the game to get a second infantry type unit into the place, before things are getting out of hand on the Iberian peninsula. Also, the BEF is in place and bolstering the French defense.
Next turn, add a unit to the BEF, so Gort can move out of the frontline.
In most games, the Germans wouldn't be able to attack Lille at all before 1940. You've got bad luck with the weather in the first turn, which is the reason the Germans have already conquered Belgium.

However, I don't want to blame you. WiF is a very, very difficult game. Personally, I've made a lot of the same mistakes in the past with the game. I probably will make some mistakes, whenever I'm going to play again (it's been a while, but I really am getting back in the spirit of things, I'm probably going to look for someone to play a Vassal game, if I'm getting to understand how some things work in that program...). Especially the naval system is probably going to be my setback, since I used to have problems making decisions on what ships to put into what force.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Red Prince

And now, for the restructured French defensive lines. The reason I like the MOT in Paris is because it has the most movement points, and a good combat factor. I'd rather use it to plug a hole after the coming attack than placing it on the front lines right now. Otherwise, I've tried to create an un-Blitzable shield, but I just don't really have anyone to plug that hole SW of Lille, unless I put the MOT there, which is a possibility.

The Reims hex bothers me. In my last game, this is roughly what I did with my defense, and the Germans used the O-chit to break the Maginot Line instead of using it elsewhere. That allowed them to completely outflank the French force. Last time, though, there was a German MTN that was causing trouble in the southern part of the country, and there isn't one now.
-----
Edit: I should add, that if I'm lucky, I might be able to use a combined impulse for the CW next time up, in order to get the BEF into France, but I'm not sure if it will be useful or successful. I may need to do some very creative thinking to get it done. I'll look into it while you are checking out the new defense.
-----
Anyway, here is my revision:

quote:

ORIGINAL: composer99

IMO the French defence is broken, so the O-chit did its job.

Still, that means the French have absorbed an offensive chit for the Allies (talk about taking one for the team), so it's 15 bp the Germans need to scrape up somewhere if they want to replace it. I don't think they can afford it if they want to undertake a 1940 Barb.

quote:

ORIGINAL: composer99

The snow should slow down German attacks, but it doesn't slow down mobility.

Can you post a screenshot of the current situation in Northern France along with what you are thinking of doing with the French?

quote:

ORIGINAL: Shannon V. OKeets

If nothing else, your screenshots sure make the Flyouts look good.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Red Prince

And, while I still haven't actually thought about what to do with the French, here is the cluttered version, showing you every unit in this particular region:

quote:

ORIGINAL: Centuur

First, next time if you've got a choice of destroying a MIL or an INF, you should always destroy the MIL (even if it is the better unit). The reason for this is that that unit will of course be rebuild immediately and will also appear on the map the next turn (provided it's city is still controlled).

quote:

Second: the French made a judgment error in the setup, regarding the Italians. I personally would have set up two units on the border. One in the hex now occupied with the Italian 4-3 and another in the hex of the Italian MOT. A third one could be set up in Nice, however I prefer moving the Marseilles MIL into Toulon as one of the moves in the second turn. This forces the Italian army to fight the French head on. It's a pretty tough fight on the high slops of the passes through the Alps. There is no way he can walk around you in that case. Only the Italian MTN can walk accross an Alpine hexside, but it is immediately OOS.
The goal of the French defense is to make the Axis pay for every hex. So let him fight you. You don't run away from any fight, since doing so, means a faster collapse of the French army.

quote:

Personally, I think this part of France is really, really in shambles. First: you're goal should be to gain time. This means that the Italian MOT cannot be allowed to move freely next turn. If it does, it's going to Lyon or (even worse) to Marseilles, thus forcing you're precious BB's to rebase to a very threathened Toulon (since Corsica is already Axis territory).  There is only one unit capable to prevent this, and this is the CAV. It has to move one hex east, even if it means that it will get disorganised. Also, leaving it in the hex isn't going to do you any good anymore.
Toulon looks like a save haven for the Fleet, however, if Marseilles is captured French forces there are OOS. And if BB's are forced to rebase a second time, there isn't a place they can move to except out of France. If Vichy is than created, a lot of the territories might go to Vichy and there is even a slight possibility that Free France isn't going to get created at all. Dangerous, very dangerous to the Allied side...

quote:

Now, you're going to get the Marseilles MIL back into his home town. How: by railmoving that unit there. Yes, it's going to get disorganised, but there isn't any other unit available for this at the moment. Things are still not looking good at all, after these moves, but you haven't got any other possibilities at all. The 1-3 division should move now towards the Italians, since it might become important to stop the Italian moves next impulse.

quote:

Now for the North part of France. Problems all over the place? Not really. Yes, there's a breakthrough of the front. Yes, there is a problem regarding the defense of Paris. But you're General Staff is really optimistic about things developing: Paris in Axis hands? "Impossible"... Also, the French PM finally got his message accross to Chuchill, so Gort is going to arrive at least...

quote:

IMHO you've got to gamble now, as the French. Bad weather (snow) it there, so the fighting is going to be less effective on the German side.

quote:

First: how to repair the front. Since TAC factors are halved with this weather, the possibility of succesfull ground strikes is decreased. You should use this. It's time for you're Georges to leave his precious Chateaux with the excellent wine cellar and start to earn his pay in action. After all, you're out of reserves. Move you're Paris Mil one hex east.

quote:

Move you're MTN with his INF one hex west. Move Georges and the MIL into the empty hex under the 9-4. Move the 5-4 INF SE of Lille to the hex with the MOT and move the remaining two units one hex west.
Lord Gort, would you please be so kind to disembark at least one corps in Calais and yourself into Boulogne? Rouen is far away from the action at this point. You'll need Gort to prevent the Germans from making a four hex assault on Lille at this moment...

quote:

Now, you've got only one place with one unit the Germans can attack. This is as far away from Paris as possible (and it's got an expendable MIL in it with very good combat factors) all other hexes have two units in them. I wouldn't empty the Maginot line, since he's already suffering from weather conditions (-2 odds level isn't particularly nice at all). 
Now, start praying the weather stays bad, so it will take the other German HQ's a lot of time to get to the front.

quote:

- 1 bomber & 1 (twin-engine) fighter (giving the French a very slight edge as their fighter is single-engine)

quote:

Also, for your Med strategy involving aligning Yugoslavia ... what happens if the Russians don't demand Bessarabia? This is part of the question of playing solitaire each side as best as possible, or playing a test game to see what happens when you combine certain decisions on each side. I see you doing much more of the latter, making decisions for one side based on already knowing what the other side is going to do. An educational way to learn the game, to be sure, but not something you can use in a real game. One small example of that was setting up the CW pipelines knowing the Netherlands would be in the game on the first turn. What if the Germans hadn't attacked the Netherlands until late 41/early 42?