Rasputitsa
Posts: 2903
Joined: 6/30/2001 From: Bedfordshire UK Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Manack quote:
ORIGINAL: brian brian I would disagree. SUBs sank a lot of capital ships in the war. The rules mechanics makes this more rare in the game, in my opinion. Matter of perspective I guess. I always thought the capital ships sunk to submarines was an insignificant loss compared the tens of millions of tons of merchant shipping lost. Quote -4b) Sinking capital ships with subs is not modeled as well. Historically there were many carriers and battleships sunk by subs, but WiF does not model that well. It is possible but difficult to do. This theme is being repeated, so what is the evidence : Allied capital ships (BB, CV) sunk by submarine where 'Royal Oak', 'Barham', 'Ark Royal', 'Courageous', 'Eagle', 'Wasp', 'Yorktown' (already crippled), if including CVE as capital ships then, 'Avenger', 'Audacity', 'Liscombe Bay' and 'Block Island'. The Japanese suffered the heaviest national loss of capital ships to subs, as part of the huge losses to submarines suffered by all classes of shipping, with BB 'Kongo', CV/CVLs 'Shinano', 'Shokaku', 'Taiho', 'Chuyo', 'Unryu', and CVE 'Unyo', 'Shinyo', 'Akitsu Maru'. Germans and Italians stayed out of the way of subs, unless including the X-craft and human torpedoes ('Chariots') Quick reference, of 38 battleships lost by all nations in WW2 (out of nearly 100 in service), there where only 3 sunk by submarine, total losses for aircraft carriers are 44, with 17 (of which 9 were CVL/CVE) sunk by submarine. Battleships - sub losses not so significant Aircraft Carriers - subs where a threat, especially if you include as capital ships the CVE, which go looking for subs and often found the sharp end, e.g. got hit first. Rough guide, of 82 lost BB/CV/CVL/CVE, there where 20 lost to subs = 25% Strategy matters, these naval losses are from coming out to fight, or running large convoy networks, some nations reduced losses of capital ships to submarines, by staying in port. Losses in capital ships to submarine, particularly battleships, seems very limited until the convoy war comes into play, then especially the aircraft carriers are put into harms way. Disclaimer - these are the best details I could get, there may be more.
< Message edited by Rasputitsa -- 3/5/2014 2:53:07 PM >
_____________________________
"In politics stupidity is not a handicap" - Napoleon “A people which is able to say everything becomes able to do everything” - Napoleon “Among those who dislike oppression are many who like to oppress" - Napoleon
|