Geredis
Posts: 29
Joined: 6/22/2014
Status: offline
|
While I'll agree that I'd love to see animated models...at a certain scale, counters really is the only way to go in order to accurately and succinctly show a wide range of information.
I mean, to use your example, how do you make a 3D model really look distinct at a glance without the units becoming charicatures of themselves?
By that I mean, what is REALLY the difference, in physical appearance, of an engineer soldier model and a generic rifleman? Not much; unless as a game designer you make the conscious decision that your soldiers run around and fight with their shovels instead of rifles or something ridiculous like that. Similarly, with various tank models; the physical, outward, appearance changes of one tank model to another within the same design can be relatively subtle to the uninitiated. I mean, in the heat of the moment with 3D models, will anyone really notice while trying to get a lay of the land the fact that the ERA pattern on a T-80BV is just a little different than that of a T-80U, or notice how the range-finding aperture on a T-80 is different than that of a T-80UM because the Buran thermal imager is shaped a little differently compared to the Luna IR system? I don't mean to say that these are small, or minor, changes. No, they all have great effects on the unit in combat...but they are the sort of things that are best shown through different stats, and are often hard to visually convey to the uninitiated. This is especially true of a lot of tanks, both East and West where the biggest changes are the sort of things you can't easily show on a physical game model since they are internal - rearranging tank layouts, or upgrading computer systems and armor thicknesses, more efficient engines, stuff like that - things you can show with stats but not a physical model.
These differences are the sort of things that can't faithfully be shown on a model, as they would have to be if the game went 3D without comrpomising its realism in my opinion.
Now, if you were to do a 3D map where it is played on an actual tabletop in a command tent or something with wooden NATO-counter blocks...that could be different, but that's clearly not what is being asked for here.
< Message edited by Geredis -- 6/24/2015 7:11:03 PM >
|
Printable Version
I can dream - 
New Messages
No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages
Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages
Locked w/o New Messages
Post New Thread