Paulchen
Posts: 46
Joined: 4/13/2001 From: Schneverdingen,germany Status: offline
|
quote:
It might be possible to build something like this if you really enjoy TOTAL NONSENSE. Nazi Germany was NOT going to defeat Soviet Russia in the summer of 1941. No how, no way. It was impossible to go far enough and fast enough with an army that was 90% horse drawn to do that. If you think it was, then you've "got your headquarters where your hindquarters should be". But even if it were: 1) The Trans-Siberian RR would be 4,000 miles of demolitions, sabotage, and Partisans.., worthless for years. 2) It would take 75-100 divisions of manpower to garrison/occupy/hold down the Russians for quite a while. 3) LOTS O LUCK See #1 above. 4) Defeating England in the Middle East does is no guarantee (look at your lines of supply) and if accomplished doesn't guarantee anything vs. India. 5) If China could be conquered (and the "whole japan army" had been trying to do that since 1937), You would still need most of it to garrison the place. IMHO, this is the kind of pipedream that comes frome sniffing too much glue and playing to much "Risk". No one who's seriously studied the period and the realities of logistics could possibly come up with it. But if that's what you want to play, then I imagine the editor can be "bullied" into giving you some sore of replica of the situation you describe. But WHY? If you say it is TOTAL NONSENSE, then have you right, but then is any hypothetical scenario TOTAL NONSENSE, and any discussion about this can end and no game need to be play. But whithout bad weather in Nov/Dec 41, what happened at the front at moskwa. No one will it knows, that is fact! Hypothetical, and i mean hypothetical, russia make peace with the germans like france (eventually a military revolution happen and Stalin is dead). And in this case the Trans-Siberian RR can be open fully in function, and then, and then, and....... I know this is very hypothetical, but not 100% impossible.
_____________________________
veni, vedi, vici
|