Gil R.
Posts: 10821
Joined: 4/1/2005 Status: offline
|
This is the list of 25-percenters I have so far, plus ratings that I came up with. (There isn't enough time to have voting on another large batch of generals.) I would appreciate feedback on any ratings that should be raised or lowered. We're hoping to get 10 USA and 10 CSA, but somehow are a bit short on CSA 25-percenters. I'd welcome suggestions on whom to add. USA: Abner Doubleday: Leadership Great, Tactics Fair, Initiative Good, Command Great William S. Rosecrans: Leadership Excellent, Tactics Good, Initiative Normal, Command Great Joshua Chamberlain: Leadership Excellent, Tactics Good, Initiative Normal, Command Superb Gouverneur K. Warren: Leadership Good, Tactics Normal, Initiative Poor, Command Good James B. McPherson: Leadership Great, Tactics Good, Initiative Normal, Command Good Don Carlos Buell: Leadership Good, Tactics Normal, Initiative Poor, Command Good George A. Custer: Leadership Great, Tactics Normal, Initiative Great, Command Good, Cavalry Excellent David McM. Gregg: Leadership Normal, Tactics Normal, Initiative Good, Command Great, Cavalry Excellent Nathaniel Lyon: Leadership Good, Tactics Normal, Initiative Good, Command Great John Sedgwick: Leadership Good, Tactics Normal, Initiative Poor, Command Good CSA: Leonidas Polk: Leadership Great, Tactics Poor, Initiative Fair, Command Normal Felix K. Zollicoffer: Leadership Fair, Tactics Great, Initiative Good, Command Normal J. Johnston Pettigrew: Leadership Good, Tactics Fair, Initiative Poor, Command Normal John H. Morgan: Leadership Excellent, Tactics Normal, Initiative Good, Command Great, Cavalry Superb Lafayette McLaws: Leadership Normal, Tactics Good, Initiative Poor, Command Great Richard H. Anderson: Leadership Good, Tactics Good, Initiative Normal, Command Superb EDIT: Additional CSA: John B. Magruder: Leadership Good, Tactics Normal, Initiative Poor, Command Good Lewis A. Armistead: Leadership Excellent, Tactics Good, Initiative Normal, Command Excellent Fitzhugh Lee: Leadership Good, Tactics Normal, Initiative Great, Command Great, Cavalry Superb Joseph O. Shelby: Leadership Good, Tactics Normal, Initiative Great, Command Normal, Cavalry Great Henry Heth: Leadership Good, Tactics Good, Initiative Poor, Command Normal William D. Pender: Leadership Good, Tactics Great, Initiative Good, Command Good Robert E. Rodes: Leadership Great, Tactics Good, Initiative Normal, Command Excellent
< Message edited by Gil R. -- 10/15/2006 2:12:31 AM >
|