Pilots Don't Lie!

Matrix Games Forums

Forums Register Login Photo Gallery Member List Search Calendars FAQ

My Profile Inbox Address Book My Subscription My Forums Log Out

Pilots Don't Lie!

View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest

Users viewing this topic: none

Printable Version

All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [World War II] >> Uncommon Valor - Campaign for the South Pacific >> Pilots Don't Lie!

Page: [1]

Message

<< Older Topic Newer Topic >>

Pilots Don't Lie! - 6/3/2002 7:42:42 PM

Mark W Carver

Posts: 83
Joined: 4/26/2002
From: South-central PA
Status: offline

I caught this off of the WWII email list...

June 3, 1942: The Japanese Invasion Group is spotted by land based aircraft from Midway. An unsuccessful raid by USAAF B-17s is mounted.
Amplifying the above:
Preliminary action begins in the Battle of Midway. Nine B-17 Flying Fortresses, flying out of Midway Island, attack five large transports 570 miles (912 km) off Midway, claiming 5 hits and several near misses; actually, [B]they hit nothing[/B]. Seven other B-17s leave Oahu, Territory of Hawaii and fly to Midway. (Jack McKillop)

... sound familiar guys?:eek:

Post #: 1

- 6/3/2002 7:47:00 PM

Drex

Posts: 2524
Joined: 9/13/2000
From: Chico,california
Status: offline

But they might have got a week-end pass for the report.:D

(in reply to Mark W Carver)

Post #: 2

a similar battle report - 6/4/2002 12:05:24 AM

brisd

Posts: 614
Joined: 5/20/2000
From: San Diego, CA
Status: offline

During my campaign as the Japanese in October 42 I am invading Lungaville and had pretty much suppressed the local airbases except Noumea. I was smiling at my great success and then I had a flight of 3 B-17's from Noumea attack a CV tf. My CAP damaged one and destroyed 1, so 2 B-17's attacked the Kaga and the combat results showed a 500 lb hit! I was steaming, then checked her the next turn. No damage, those flyboys sure do lie! :p

_____________________________

"I propose to fight it out on this line if it takes all summer."-Note sent with Congressman Washburne from Spotsylvania, May 11, 1864, to General Halleck. - General Ulysses S. Grant

(in reply to Mark W Carver)

Post #: 3

Pilots Don't Lie - 6/4/2002 8:07:28 AM

bill_k

Posts: 36
Joined: 6/19/2000
From: Browns Mills,NJ,USA
Status: offline

I can understand the reports filed by the pilots of 5 hits, 1 probable and four near misses. Bombing from altitudes of 8,10 and 12 thousand feet with their perspective distorted and tons of water spouting skyward you have to be a gifted observer to tell the difference between a hit or a miss.

Bill Keys

(in reply to Mark W Carver)

Post #: 4

- 6/4/2002 1:18:56 PM

JohnK

Posts: 285
Joined: 2/8/2001
Status: offline

I've read (and actually confimed by looking at some old newspapers) that immediately after Midway, it was basically reported in the US the battle was won by Army Air Force land based air, and the Navy assisted.

There was an unbelievable "spin machine" in the AAF creating worship for the B-17. Also, in an even more notable incident, a B-17 supposedly sank the BB Haruna in the Phillipines; widely reported in the media, was really seen as the first "victory,", not the Tokyo raid. I think the B-17 in question crashed or was destroyed and the pilot got a Medal of Honor; I believe they actually just damaged a destroyer.

And the most inflated kill stats of the war were B-17 gunners in Europe; if their claims were true, they were shooting down the ENTIRE Luftwaffe fighter force in Western Europe every two weeks :-) What happened was that B-17 losses were so bad, they eliminated all investigation and standards for gunner claims (as compared to fighter claims). So everyone who fired at a plane that was destroyed got a "kill."

In reality, in Europe, hardly any LW fighters were shot down by B-17 gunners. It was almost entirely the fighter escort, when they finally got them.

(in reply to Mark W Carver)

Post #: 5

Pilot's Don't Lie - 6/4/2002 6:13:54 PM

bill_k

Posts: 36
Joined: 6/19/2000
From: Browns Mills,NJ,USA
Status: offline

Where did you come up with your claims about LW planes shot down. I think the B17 you are referring to in the Pacific was the one flown by Colin Kelly. I would be interested in what books you have read on the subject. The B17 wasn't noted for it's expoits in the Pacific, the European theatre was it's stomping grounds. As far as the number of aircraft shot down, I would think the escorts should have more kills, that was their job, where as the B17 sole purpose was bombing, shooting down fighters was secondary to the mission and in self defense. I have looked everywhere to get the fiqures for kills during the war but have not found anything and I have tons of books on the B17, 8th Air Force,etc.

(in reply to Mark W Carver)

Post #: 6