Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature?

Matrix Games Forums

Forums Register Login Photo Gallery Member List Search Calendars FAQ

My Profile Inbox Address Book My Subscription My Forums Log Out

Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature?

View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest

Users viewing this topic: none

Printable Version

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> Advanced Tactics Series >> The War Room >> Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature?

Page: [1]

Message

<< Older Topic Newer Topic >>

Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature? - 1/23/2010 6:18:14 PM

springer

Posts: 414
Joined: 5/14/2009
Status: offline

In the Sixth Army AAR, there's a problem I notice. On the offensive, MGs die just like regular infantry. In your opinion is this a bug or a feature?

For the bug argument, I would see the following. The combat program should have a situation in which during an attack MGs function as backline units. In defensive situations, MGs function as frontline units. This would reflect doctrine that MGs are rarely units that springboard offenses. For the bug argument, I could see a suggestion to modify AT's combat engine.

For the feature argument, I would make the following. Having MGs act exactly like infantry on the offense is a matter of the player's operational decisions. If MG units are misdeployed in offensive operations, then the AT player gets what he (or less likely, she) deserves. The player should have ensured that MG heavy units stay out of the offensive battles. For the feature argument, I would see the deployment of MGs being one of the nuanced features that show the difference between a good and great AT player.

< Message edited by springer -- 1/23/2010 6:19:29 PM >

Post #: 1

RE: Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature? - 1/23/2010 10:58:05 PM

tweber

Posts: 1411
Joined: 6/27/2007
Status: offline

MGs in the standard unit set have as much HP as Rifle so they should received casualties in a comparable level. The difference is they have slightly more than 2x attack power and 3x defense power. So, they should probably inflict more casualties than if they were not there.

You could make MGs back bench units (light mortars and guns). If you did, the casualty levels would be much lower. Another option would be to increase HP. In the 6th Army campaign, it does not matter too much since there is not sftype production. It would matter in a game with regular production. Increases in capabilities should be offset with changes in cost.

(in reply to springer)

Post #: 2

RE: Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature? - 1/24/2010 10:39:52 AM

Josh

Posts: 2576
Joined: 5/9/2000
From: Leeuwarden, Netherlands
Status: offline

Tom is right. (as usual I might add) I feel it is somewhat awkward to see the Mg's die like flies in an attack, but you can't do without them in a balanced unit....*and* they are much cheaper than backbench units. So maybe there should be distinction between Mg's and Heavy Mg's which would cost the same as Mortars.

(in reply to tweber)

Post #: 3

RE: Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature? - 1/24/2010 3:23:29 PM

Grymme

Posts: 1821
Joined: 12/16/2007
Status: offline

If it helps you can consider that at this scale the MGs are used tactically every bit as much as riflemen. They were very much in the first combat line. Also even though we coin things attack and defense in reality there is almost always a lot of fluid movements with small counterattacks etc. Finally you can consider that a lot of the casualties during WWII was caused by artillery, where MGs were equally vulnerable to riflemen. For a treatment of the use of MGs in WWII i recommend you read the classic novel "unknown soldier" (ok�nd soldat) by finnish author V�in� Linna.

So, all in all, i dont feel the MGs are handled unhistoricly. Now mortars, thats another matter.

_____________________________

My Advanced Tactics Mod page
http://atgscenarios.wordpress.com

30+ scenarios, maps and mods for AT and AT:G

(in reply to Josh)

Post #: 4

RE: Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature? - 1/24/2010 7:29:01 PM

Josh

Posts: 2576
Joined: 5/9/2000
From: Leeuwarden, Netherlands
Status: offline

Yep, if there is one "�berstack" it is the dreaded Mortar stack.

(in reply to Grymme)

Post #: 5

RE: Machine Guns Dying on the Offensive: Bug or Feature? - 1/25/2010 1:45:43 AM

springer

Posts: 414
Joined: 5/14/2009
Status: offline

All the comments are insightful.

@ Tweber and Grymme
I particularly appreciate your comments on the MGs particular characteristics. You are both amongst the most experienced scenario designers, so beyond doubt you are both very familiar with the guts of the game engine as you pursue that quest to create great scenarios.

(in reply to Josh)

Post #: 6