Withdrawing infantry

Matrix Games Forums

Forums Register Login Photo Gallery Member List Search Calendars FAQ

My Profile Inbox Address Book My Subscription My Forums Log Out

Withdrawing infantry

View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest

Users viewing this topic: none

Printable Version

All Forums >> [New Releases from Matrix Games] >> War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition >> Withdrawing infantry

Page: [1]

Message

<< Older Topic Newer Topic >>

Withdrawing infantry - 4/7/2012 11:38:25 AM

flyboy999

Posts: 26
Joined: 9/19/2011
Status: offline

What is the effect of LCU not withdrawing?

Attachment (1)

_____________________________

Post #: 1

RE: Withdrawing infantry - 4/7/2012 11:42:54 AM

KenchiSulla

Posts: 2948
Joined: 10/22/2008
From: the Netherlands
Status: offline

destruction..

edit: Assuming you lose with a margin otherwise forcing a withdraw. This will happen if the unit is somehow unable to withdraw (if on an island, for example)

< Message edited by Cannonfodder -- 4/7/2012 11:43:45 AM >

_____________________________

AKA Cannonfodder

"It happened, therefore it can happen again: this is the core of what we have to say. It can happen, and it can happen everywhere.�
� Primo Levi, writer, holocaust survivor

(in reply to flyboy999)

Post #: 2

RE: Withdrawing infantry - 4/7/2012 12:09:45 PM

flyboy999

Posts: 26
Joined: 9/19/2011
Status: offline

No, if a unit as to withdraw because of date, what will happen if I don't withdraw the unit? As an example I have an Infantry unit that must withdraw in 5 days!

Thx.

Attachment (1)

(in reply to flyboy999)

Post #: 3

RE: Withdrawing infantry - 4/7/2012 12:15:45 PM

Roger Neilson II

Posts: 1517
Joined: 7/16/2006
From: Newcastle upon Tyne. England
Status: offline

Land units just withdraw, you don't have to do anything unlike ships and ari units.

It just won't be there in 5 days time.

Roger

_____________________________

(in reply to flyboy999)

Post #: 4

RE: Withdrawing infantry - 4/7/2012 12:27:10 PM

Itdepends

Posts: 937
Joined: 12/12/2005
Status: offline

Even if it's on a tiny island in the middle of the Pacific. It just goes away. Not a problem unless you happen to be relying on it being there.

(in reply to Roger Neilson II)

Post #: 5

RE: Withdrawing infantry - 4/7/2012 12:34:22 PM

mike scholl 1

Posts: 1265
Joined: 2/17/2010
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Roger Neilson II

Land units just withdraw, you don't have to do anything unlike ships and ari units.

It just won't be there in 5 days time.

Roger

If only this worked with ships and A/C, you could cut at least 100 hours of "no fun" drudgery from playing the Allies in a Campaign Game.

(in reply to Roger Neilson II)

Post #: 6

RE: Withdrawing infantry - 4/7/2012 1:43:45 PM

Roger Neilson II

Posts: 1517
Joined: 7/16/2006
From: Newcastle upon Tyne. England
Status: offline

In 90% of the cases I'd fully agree with you there. There would however be some scope for gamey play..... marginal effectiveness though

Roger

_____________________________

(in reply to mike scholl 1)

Post #: 7

RE: Withdrawing infantry - 5/7/2012 1:18:18 PM

Cmdrcain

Posts: 1161
Joined: 8/21/2000
From: Rebuilding FLA, Busy Repairing!
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: mike scholl 1

quote:

ORIGINAL: Roger Neilson II

Land units just withdraw, you don't have to do anything unlike ships and ari units.

It just won't be there in 5 days time.

Roger

If only this worked with ships and A/C, you could cut at least 100 hours of "no fun" drudgery from playing the Allies in a Campaign Game.

With Ships they need get to a proper port in rear area to be withdrawn... not simply disappear in middle of pacific.. through one could say it does sail off on a withdrawal... The difference I guess is that at some points one may wish to retain a ship or plane group past time and pay the political repercussions
Like keeping a British CV in IOA for a bit longer

Remember too we can in settings before play turn withdrawals off...

With LCU's on an island you have to presume that the lcu's had some transports arrive and take the men off

_____________________________

Noise? What Noise? It's sooooo quiet and Peaceful!

Battlestar Pegasus

(in reply to mike scholl 1)

Post #: 8

RE: Withdrawing infantry - 5/8/2012 4:52:14 PM

Alfred

Posts: 6685
Joined: 9/28/2006
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: mike scholl 1

quote:

ORIGINAL: Roger Neilson II

Land units just withdraw, you don't have to do anything unlike ships and ari units.

It just won't be there in 5 days time.

Roger

If only this worked with ships and A/C, you could cut at least 100 hours of "no fun" drudgery from playing the Allies in a Campaign Game.

Each of the 3 different combat arm dev teams came up with their own solution to the withdrawal issue. That is why the mechanism varies amongst all three.

If you applied the land unit withdrawal solution to air and ship units you would run into problems such as:

1. Game exploitation

(a) In the past Don Bowen has explained how allowing ships to be withdrawn anywhere can lead to gamey play. Allowing them to just go "poof" would be a similar matter.

(b) Ships in particular represent a pile of PPs. Some players who know they will just go "poof", could send them on logistically kamikaze missions and cause quite ahistorical problems for their opponent

2. Coding problems

(a) What would happen to air units which themselves are not scheduled to withdraw but are on a ship which has just magically gone "poof". Would the unit magically reapear. What about the airframes and pilots, do they go into the pools or are they lost just as if they had been on ship which is sunk.

(b) Would there be difficulties if they went "poof" in an off map area as opposied to an on map area?

3. A very much more vociferous complaint from players

(a) Can you imagine the screems from players when the experienced and trained pilots of a permanently disbanded air unit just went "poof" before the player "rescued" them beforehand by replacing them with rookie pilots.

(b) Almost all LCUs which just go "poof" are small units or large units which are permanently restricted. Essentially it would be very rare for a critical ongoing combat situation to witness the sudden "poof" of a land unit. The same is not the case with sea and air units. How would players react when they found out on day 2 of a 2 day turn cycle, their carriers had suddenly found themselves without CAP or strike aircraft because their airunits had gone "poof" in the middle of the battle.

Once again I find players not giving proper consideration to how deeply the devs thought through issues.

Alfred

(in reply to mike scholl 1)

Post #: 9